do republican policies even promote "family values?"

<p>for all the talk republicans make about “family values”, the democrats always seem to have policies that are favorable towards family values (maternal leave, paying for childcare, etc). and what do republicans do, meanwhile? restrict others from creating families. which doesn’t even do a thing for traditional families. they might also make policies that protect children against “negative influences” and “mature content”, but is there really any evidence that these policies do anything? If anything, I think they break families apart. Lots of children/teens are going to look at porn, have sex, take drugs, or whatever. And since they’re not comfortable with doing any of these things around their parents, they’ll keep secrets from their parents and won’t be as close to them. </p>

<p>And okay, if youth look at porn, have sex, or take drugs, will any of those destroy a family at all? Maybe families would be closer if they simply had honest conversations with their children about them. And warn them against the <em>negative</em> effects of them. In any case, policies against porn/sex/drugs certainly don’t seem to have any impact on their use among the young. </p>

<p>they’re also against abortion and in some cases, birth control. okay, does abstinence until marriage really strengthen family values? (assuming that the policies actually prevent premarital sex, which they don’t seem to do that good of a job at doing) or in other words, do people who practice abstinence til marriage have happier families than those who don’t practice it? it could be an open question, but I’m inclined to believe “no”. </p>

<p>of course, abstinence until marriage is fine. the problem is when you try to promote it through increasing the danger of the alternative action. when that happens, you generally get lots of babies born under teen parents. the inevitable result of that is broken families. </p>

<p>also, they wish to make families more in control over their children’s education (maybe that helps, who knows). well, that’s something i consider reasonable and not imaginary.</p>

<p>republicans might be more likely to go to pro-family institutions like the church. and may be more likely to belong to social groups that encourage their members to have families. but I’m not seeing how republican policies help anyone maintain stable families (republican values might, but they don’t need any interference from the state. )</p>

<p>note: even if republican policies don’t seem to benefit families as much (from my perspective anyways), that doesn’t make me any more against them (since I don’t care much about families)</p>

<p>=====</p>

<p>Well, what is it that I think that splits families apart? Social pressure/peer pressure (only in SOME cases though). Lots of kids would rather associate with peers than family. Some of them even get along with rebellious peers. And then some of them develop values that conflict with those of their parents, which can drive wedges. Okay, but I’m not sure if any Republican policies help with that all. Except homeschooling (which I’m in favor of but for different reasons) and private schools.</p>

<p>Family values are boring anyway.</p>

<p>Republicans do tend to be more conservative when it comes to family ideologies. I would, however, point out that Republicans are fans of keeping with tradition. With that in mind, Republicans do wish to instill good habits in their family and their bonds are formed with the strength of religion. At the risk of being too generalizing, Republicans are patriotic and they are often Catholics that base their lives on the community, or “family ties”. Nothing further, as I am far too tired to think anymore.</p>

<p>

Catholics lean more Democrat than GOP actually.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>That’s actually mostly for economic reasons. When it comes to social values, Catholics tend to align more with the GOP.</p>

<p>^How does that contradict what I said?</p>

<p>Mostly with reference to the original post, catholics are among the groups that identify with the “family values” platform of the GOP.</p>

<p>Eh, and what do you base that on if most Catholics vote Dem? Even if it’s a slim majority.</p>

<p>Okay never mind then. Sorry. I was just studying too much European Poli Sci recently (Catholics are more conservative in Europe but not America)</p>

<p>

</p>

<h1>===</h1>

<p>In any case, it makes a lot of sense for people to be “personally conservative” while not giving a **** about most republican policies. disagreeing with things most young people agree on (for whatever reason) is certainly a way to try to discourage them from socializing with their potentially subversive peers.</p>

<p>IMO, teaching emotional intelligence to people (especially parents) might be the best way to actually make families closer to each other. When your parents are stuck in their own times and don’t even try to understand you (trying to be interested in others is a key part of emotional intelligence), it’s them that’s preventing a parent-child bond.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Conservative Americans, for at least 150 years of our history, tended to be deeply anti-Catholic</p>

<p>^Again, how does that contradict what I said?</p>

<p>Anyways, adding onto the OP, democrat policies seem better for families in other ways too. democrats are generally tougher on pollution and junk food - things that can almost certainly hurt children - as opposed to the imaginary harm of porn, weed, and protected premarital sex.</p>

<p>^^ It doesn’t, I was agreeing with you</p>

<p>I think it’s a common misconception that Catholicism is the dominant sect of Christianity even today. I know a lot of people from my high school who were unaware that this country didn’t have its first Catholic president until the 1960’s</p>

<p>I thought Evangelicals here supported the GOP.</p>

<p>We call these Nominal Catholics.</p>