Does anyone here run into vocalization dead-ends?

<p>When I comment on something or respond to an open-ended question, I articulate the main point (often comprising a maximum of 3 sentences or so) well because I had previously intravocalized it. However, I usually feel compelled to either expand upon the main point or otherwise provide additional justification; neither always results in complete success.</p>

<p>Sometimes, I have to “bail myself out” by spewing information only tangentially relevant, which, to the unfamilar, might give the impression that I have a clue about what I’m talking about. Inevitably, when among peers who know not only the constituents of my weakly strung “evidence” but also of counterexamples, I will be exposed for the fraud that I am (again, so to speak, but not so much).</p>

<p>That’s not to say that I’m totally ignorant about everything outside my main points (which are more frequently more abstract than concrete unless I’m answering a one-to-one question); rather, my ability to think on my feet may not be as great as I’d like. However, I view mere recitation as a weakness, though my main points may be little more than this. </p>

<p>When I’m writing, I can pause to contemplate how to best construct what is to follow. Speech is not and cannot be as generous. Is it a simply a matter of underdevelopment of whatever physiological structure is responsible for vocal articulation?</p>

<p>Everybody here is a master orator?</p>

<p>Everybody here isn’t a master at reading comprehension. Say what?</p>

<p>Modesty. The great debate archnemesis of mifune must be a master of reading comprehension. Or else, did you refute his points without fully understanding them?</p>

<p>Knowing what mifune’s sources were helped.</p>

<p>But anyway, as I understand it you mean you have trouble coming up with coherent arguments on the spot, without prior thought. This has made it hard for you to argue with people, because they hit you with a hard question and then you find yourself at a loss for an answer. Correct?</p>

<p>

Yes.</p>

<p>

Not so with every question. Simple questions can be answered simply; complex ones take more effort. That much is natural. However, open-ended questions do not have clear-cut right answers. Whatever answer I provide is usually one that, through light deliberation, I thought right. Troubles arise when (1) I’m asked to find support and (2) when my interlocutor rapidly asks a succession of follow-up questions. Rarely prepared, I can either request a pause (of varying length), or BS my way out. The latter happens more frequently because requesting any pause over a few seconds, with only my prolonged “ummmmmmm” to suspend the queue, only passes the question down to whoever next volunteers to respond to the original question (or, if whoever is feeling particularly competitive, to destroy my statement).</p>

<p>But on the whole, you’re correct.</p>

<p>Yep, this happened to me on my Road to Perdition quiz in Cinema Study today. I usually know what I want to say, but I’m not exactly sure how to word it. Then, I start writing stuff and then decide that I want to write it another way so I have to cross stuff out and it starts to look messy…
Yea, I hate stuff like that. The same this happens with speeches and stuff, but I’m talking instead so I just babble and babble.</p>

<p>Start writing stuff? To recite?</p>

<p>Fluency in language, whether it be vocal or written, is developed through practice. It is also necessary to extensively educate yourself on the relevant material.</p>

<p>Antonioray’s hariolations are tinctured with tribalism. The nub of what I intend to say here is that Antonioray has frequently been spotted making nicey-nice with infernal, backwards sad sacks. If you pay careful attention to his dangerous accusations you’ll undeniably notice that I love hearing the claims of a Pecksniffian lamebrain who doesn’t realize that he’s a Pecksniffian Pecksniffian-type. As a case in point, consider Antonioray’s claim that lawless wisenheimers and postmodernist, demented rotters should rule this country. Antonioray’s rodomontades have grown into an unsympathetic tapestry weaving together classical conspiracy theories of the 19th century and post-Marxian economics.</p>

<p>[Scott</a> Pakin’s automatic complaint-letter generator](<a href=“http://www.pakin.org/complaint/]Scott”>Scott Pakin's automatic complaint-letter generator)</p>

<p>Oh that Scott Pakin. He slays me. (first time I’ve ever been slapped with a SPACLG production.) But now that my hariolations have been beaten dead</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>For practice: “the next sentence” to an answer varies by question. As I doubt I’ll need to pull a sentence once and then again later with slight modification (or else it’d be a completely new sentence). I can see how practice soldifies fluency in structure, but practice’s role in generating content is a little less clear.</p>

<p>For knowing relevant information: I can refrain from drawing weak connections (the breakdown that made me think about what’s here was about the modern size of the government, something I commented on by referring to Milton Friedman, though reference quickly degenerated into a important-dates-in-the-Federal-Reserve recitation). But that’s no fun. Answering the question could have been possible without referring to Milton Friedman (it was open-ended), but without concrete examples, my opinion on the matter would have had little substance. </p>

<p>I can probably write at least a solid paragraph on Milton Friedman’s relevance to the size of government (with what I know already, that is, no further education on the matter), but I couldn’t say it on the spot. Further research into the topic probaby wouldn’t have helped me much.</p>