Equality

<p>I had my orientation today, and my school distributed some pieces of SAT literature. This little paragraph jumped out at me:</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Baha. It’s been proven that women, minority, and disadvantaged students do worse on the SAT. So it’s equal! If you’re an upper-middle-class white male. :P</p>

<p>It’s equal in the sense that it’s standardized testing, so everyone everywhere is tested on the same skill set on the same test without the influence of different grading systems and biased teachers prevalent in school systems. It also doesn’t require knowledge of AP subjects, so it is more equal in the sense that, by the time the tester reaches 11th or 12th grade, he should have approached those subjects already.</p>

<p>Whether the tester is actually taught the subjects and about the SAT test is a completely different story. There is a discrepancy between different groups, but there will be one no matter what test is administered due to opportunities given to some groups and not others, I think. </p>

<p>I’m no SAT expert, though, so I’ll leave the debate on the SAT to other posters…</p>

<p>It’s just ironic that they could make such a statement because the SAT’s preeminence has declined because it favors people of higher social circumstance, and it really isn’t the unbiased metric that one would expect a standardized test to be. It does not “still [promote equality in college admission] today,” nor “ensure that students from all backgrounds have an equal chance to succeed.”</p>

<p>It ensures that those who were going to succeed anyway continue on that course</p>

<p>^ resignation to the reality of the poverty cycle</p>

<p>For those who are saying the SAT is unfair, please suggest another way to semi-accurately measure achievement in a standardized way without bias.</p>

<p>For those at the SAT who claim the SAT is fair, please stop lying.</p>

<p>I didn’t say the SAT could feasibly change to eliminate socioeconomic bias. But if there is socioeconomic bias (and there is), they shouldn’t be claiming that there isn’t.</p>

<p>High-school GPA is a far better indicator of college success than the SAT, anyway, whether it’s standardized or not.</p>

<p>notanengineer- I dont get what you’re saying lol (about my comment)</p>

<p>

Just to verify the implication of this… since higher socioeconomic classes score higher on the SAT, they are more likely to succeed. If that they “continue on that course” indicates that they “were going to succeed anyway,” then the implication would be…that only those of higher socioeconomic classes “were going to succeed anyway.”</p>

<p>If your comment was meant to be ironic, then sorry, I missed it.</p>

<p>Oh so you were agreeing with me? Ok now I got it lol sorry I’m slow today</p>

<p>It HAS been shown that low-income, minority, and female applicants typically do worse on the SAT. However, most colleges that people on this website are concerned with look at scores within the context of the applicant’s life. College Board, believe it or not, discourages colleges from using hard and fast score cutoffs.</p>

<p>As long as SAT scores are used responsibly, it is definitely the most equitable part of the college application.</p>

<p>@notanengineer: High school GPA is not a “far better” indicator of college success. On page 5 of [this</a> study](<a href=“http://professionals.collegeboard.com/profdownload/Validity_of_the_SAT_for_Predicting_First_Year_College_Grade_Point_Average.pdf]this”>http://professionals.collegeboard.com/profdownload/Validity_of_the_SAT_for_Predicting_First_Year_College_Grade_Point_Average.pdf), it says that researchers found that the SAT has a .53 correlation with people’s first year college GPA. HS GPA has a .54 correlation, a measly .01 difference. That is not statistically significant, much less an indication of “far better” predictive accuracy.</p>

<p>lol the SAT isn’t “biased” in the way that I think of the word. It tests basic things that a certain part of our society values. Yes, people of lower socioeconomic status may not value the types of things the SAT tests as much (reading, math, nice grammar, etc.), but, I don’t know, if you want to say it’s biased than I would say it’s biased in an appropriate way. Because those are the values that are pretty necessary if you want to succeed in college.</p>

<p>Also there is the fact that people of a higher socioeconomic are (on average of course) innately better at the types of things the SAT tests. That’s not a fault of the test. If a test like the SAT happens to find that a sub-group of people do better on it than the rest of us (like is true for the Ashkenazi jews) that doesn’t automatically mean the test is somehow biased towards those people; rather it’s much more likely to mean that those people are better at the test.</p>

<p>

Yet the microcosm of an elite university is still tilted toward higher socioeconomic groups.</p>

<p>

Eh, College Board-conducted study alleges that SAT and GPA are equal indicators of success… I will agree if you get a source that doesn’t have a stake in the results.</p>

<p>

This is fine–but we also should bring an end to all initiatives that open elite colleges to those who haven’t had the opportunities of higher socioeconomic circumstance.</p>

<p>

Again, this is a fine piece of logic, as long as elite colleges stop trying to help the lower classes.</p>

<p>

<a href=“Redirect Notice”>Redirect Notice;

<p>I remember one time I read an article about how there was a question about polo, the sport.
A lot of people felt that was unfair because that sport is generally all upper-class white people… :confused: So, minorities and the underprivileged were already at a disadvantage.</p>

<p>

Who do you think is more sympathetic to poor applicants: an elite university (who looks at the SAT in light of income/family life/barriers to success) or a huge podunk public state university (who will not consider applicants without XYZ SAT scores)?

If you had ****ing read the study, you would have encountered this:

If you can’t believe those two sentences, you are only being skeptical for its own sake.</p>

<p>As far as the Bekerely study goes, they didn’t consider SAT verbal, math, and SAT II writing together (which would be comparable to today’s three-part SAT). Judging from the predictive power of three SAT IIs (16.9%), I think that today’s SAT would fare similarly to that. 16.9% is less than 20.4%, but would I call a factor that explains only 20.4% of a college student’s GPA a “far better indicator” than one that explains only 16.9%? Especially when those two factors combine to create BETTER predictive power overall? Not really.</p>

<p>"Breaking News: College Board alters the scoring of their SAT tests in an effort to make them more fair. Students who list their ethnicity as anything other than “white” will receive an extra 200 points. Students who list their household income as “below average” will receive an extra 300. Females may now opt to receive a free 800 points on the subscore of their choice. These methods are meant to counteract the longstanding bias held by the SAT against non-white, non-male test-takers. The big question is: ‘Are they doing enough?’ </p>

<p>Film at eleven."</p>

<p>Black people are better at football and basketball…why no equality? :(</p>

<p><<it has=“” been=“” shown=“” that=“” low-income,=“” minority,=“” and=“” female=“” applicants=“” typically=“” do=“” worse=“” on=“” the=“” sat.=“”>></it></p>

<p>just out of curiosity, why would female students do worse on the SAT?</p>