Fitness, Nutrition and Health- All Welcome (Hardcore and “Light”)

I can remember being in Salt Lake City for 4th of July. Twice. Our 1969 camping trip to CO put us a nice campground in town. For our extended 6 week cross country trip, my mother planned the same stop.

Lookin good!

Here’s me on mine earlier in the week at Minnewaska state park in Ulster county, NY.

Nothing better than a great gravel trail.


9 Likes

That gravel biking looks fun!

Do you definitely need a special kind of bike or could you use a regular mountain bike? (going to buy some kind of bike in next few years and trying to figure it out)

you could for sure use a mountain bike. I prefer a gravel bike for the flexibility - in addition to gravel trails, it is good for road cycling (unlike a fat-tired mtn bike which feels like a slog on the road) and could* handle single track, lightly technical mountain bike trails.

*I have a real fear of mountain-biking and don’t do it, but my H uses his gravel bike for lots of single track trails.

4 Likes

I think of gravel bikes as having drop handlebars, and hybrid bikes having the straight across handlebars?
Other than that, I’m not sure what the differences are.
@Jolynne_Smyth, I recommend you go to a local bike shop or REI kind of place when you’re ready to buy a bike and try different styles to see what feels comfortable to you.

3 Likes

My H and I have the same bike frames (he built our bikes) and he put drop bars on his and upright on mine (per my preference), clipless pedals on mine, clips on his…I think of those things as little modifications, not a difference in the actual bike.

4 Likes

I get confused on whether “clipless” is the term for having the things you need special shoes for or not :).
I DO NOT use them. Even though I ride a fair amount, and I know it’s more efficient, I feel like my chance of falling would go up a lot. Old fashioned pedals are good for me.

2 Likes

The terminology is definitely confusing! It comes from when there were ‘cages’ on the toe clips. ‘Clipless’ was the term used to describe the new way of just clipping in and not using the old style toe clips that had to be strapped on. I can’t even imagine trying to use the old style!

2 Likes

Same! I don’t like technical mountain bike riding at all. I love the flexibility of my gravel bike where I can ride on dirt or paved roads.

I’m getting used to the clipless pedals. One fall and a scraped knee so far!

1 Like

Ah, a happy childhood memory!

After our daughter had her road bike stolen (off a 2nd story balcony!), she got a gravel bike which she really likes.

3 Likes

Nice work! I share your frustration about the HDL, though. I feel like I’m doing what they say to do to improve it, but it remains stubbornly unchanged.

1 Like

Exercise is generally considered the most effective way to raise HDL, but the volume of exercise needed for the HDL increase to be noticeable may be significantly higher than the common recommendations.

2 Likes

I have very high HDL (always over 75; in 2015 when I was 20lb heavier and not yet running it was 79; highest was 94). HLD does seem to fluctuate, sometimes not logically. But not a concern for me since high / good.

So I focus on LDL… not all that successfully. My very best LDL was 111, but usually 120s or 130s (once surprisingly 148, but at different lab than usual).

2 Likes

There are many medications that are associated with far larger increases in HDL than exercise. However, meds are rarely used primarily for increasing HDL, as there is usually not a comparable reduced risk of cardiovascular events, with the HDL increase.

For example, in the study at Evacetrapib and Cardiovascular Outcomes in High-Risk Vascular Disease - PubMed over 6000 persons took Evacetrapib. The Evacetrapib group had a huge mean HDL increase of 133% – many times more than is associated exercise. The placebo group only had no significant change in HDL. Nevertheless the study was terminated prematurely because there was no difference in rate of cardiovascular events between Evacetrapib group and placebo group, and another study found a slightly increased rate of cardiovascular events with a similar type of med. A quote from the drug’s Wikipedia page is below:

On April 3, 2016 at the American College of Cardiology cardiologists first saw the data for Eli Lilly’s ACCELERATE trial of evacetrapib involving 12,000 patients.[10] They were “stunned” by the result which showed there was no benefit from taking evacetrapib—434 participants who took evacetrapib died from “cardiovascular disease, such as a heart attack or a stroke” and 444 participants who took a placebo died.[10] The ACCELERATE trial led by Stephen J. Nicholls who observed,[10]

““It’s the most mind-boggling question. How can a drug that lowers something that is associated with benefit not show any benefit?”

— Stephen J. Nicholls 2016

A similar pattern occurs with Niacin. Doctors used to regularly prescribe Niacin to increase HDL. I once had a doctor who recommended it to me for this purpose. And Niacin does indeed increase HDL at high doses, much more so than is common with exercise. However, Niacin is rarely prescribed for this purpose any more, after subsequent studies found no reduction in cardiovascular events with Niacin in spite of the increased HDL, yet negative side effects were common.

One theory is the increased HDL with the meds above is dysfunctional or poorly functional. In contrast HDL increased via exercise is not dysfunctional and is associated with reduced risk. Exercise also has a variety of other benefits that are associated with reduced cardiovascular events, which can make it difficult to entangle how much is due to increased HDL vs reduced visceral fat, insulin sensitivity, blood pressure, inflammation, ApoB, …

IMO, the “at least 150 minutes of moderate-intensity aerobic exercise or 75 minutes of vigorous-intensity activity per week” is not adequate. But I’m assuming a majority of people do not even meet this basic recommendation.

1 Like

You are a super-achiever.

A good friend and I had some words about this. She kept trying to act like I was being judgmental about her working out/not working out. Not at all. She was trying to say that my level of exercise is super-human. It’s not, although I acknowledge that I do work out more than most 63yos, because I really enjoy it. What I was trying to say is that what I do (lift weights/walk on the treadmill) is, in fact, doable by most people in their 60s. I am not doing murphs or marathons. What I am is consistent, and most people aren’t as consistent with their exercise. Does that make sense?

The bottom line is that whenever we talk about exercise she feels judged. She is projecting.

4 Likes

Looks like about half of the US adult population meets that recommendation.

1 Like

Ok, because I can’t find it and now I’m annoyed, where is your quote starting with “at least 150 minutes…” from?
It’s really just a curiosity thing, and I want to know what the recommendation is.
Thanks

That exercise recommendation comes from https://odphp.health.gov/sites/default/files/2019-09/Physical_Activity_Guidelines_2nd_edition.pdf

3 Likes

A pet peeve of mine is recommendations that list arbitrary numerical thresholds like this, without clear explanation of why that particular number is selected. It occurs in many fields besides just fitness.

There is nothing special about 150 minutes. In general more is better (overtraining or lack of sufficient recovery time can be an issue, if extreme), and incremental benefit becomes increasingly smaller as number increases. However, there can be significant cardiovascular benefits for events as short as something like sprinting up a flight of stairs for <1 minute a few times per week. There is not a minimum threshold time one needs to cross to see benefits. Instead optimal duration per week varies from one person to the next depending on their goals, what specific exercises/training is done, health/fitness/injury status, available time, etc.

In fairness, the document linked above does go in to greater detail at end, including printing the table below, showing relationship between all cause mortality and amount of physical activity. The chart specifically says “no lower threshold for benefit” and “no obvious best amount”, which I expect is the correct conclusion.

2 Likes