My response was based on your earlier remark:
At any rate, the 47% that met the guideline was based on interviews. ![]()
However, does that include scrolling, bathroom breaks and filling one’s water bottle? ![]()
IME, I’ll disagree with the surveys.
My response was based on your earlier remark:
At any rate, the 47% that met the guideline was based on interviews. ![]()
However, does that include scrolling, bathroom breaks and filling one’s water bottle? ![]()
IME, I’ll disagree with the surveys.
Admittedly, I’m not normal. ![]()
I’ve said this before, but some movement is better than no movement. The flip side of that is that many healthy humans, even healthy humans aged 40 and over, are capable of so much more.
What age does that “average adult”
Encompass?
IMO, people need to meet an exercise goal that is achievable for them and their current health AND pay attention to what and how much they are putting in their mouth. Especially when living in a non-public transportation driven city. If I look around my city (drive most everywhere) NO WAY are 50% of adults meeting a daily or weekly exercise goal.
And I’ll say one more thing…which I should keep my
BUT, I despise when people “brag” about how they hate exercise and never do it like it’s a badge of honor!
I am totally in agreement on “movement is better than no movement.” I admit to being frustrated listening to people complain about their weight/health while doing nothing about it, when they have plenty of time to make better meals, drink fewer high calorie beverages, exercise, etc., and nothing health-wise from preventing them.
IMHO–It is better to be encouraging of folks that are doing any kind of physical activity then being negative that they did not hit a goal.
Pre-retirement and outside of the soccer season if I missed playing soccer on Tuesday nights, I rarely hit my goal. It is only in retirement that I am hitting it consistently
And that is a perfect example of giving yourself or others permission to modify their goal. Looking for 30 minutes of cardio a day but have an exceptionally busy week? Modify to aim to hit it 3-4 times that week.
Went to the gym yesterday AM with a workout plan developed by my trainer and put in an app. TBH– while I am glad I did it, I did not like it as much as I like cardio stuff.
I then played 90 minutes of soccer in the evening which was much more fun ![]()
Doing some exercise is so much better than doing none. It seems many don’t even try, fearing they need to be super exercisers to have benefit.
Recently I had a fun discussion with a 25 year old who is in pretty decent shape (she’s a sailing instructor). Her summer goal is to run 2 miles without stopping… I thought that was cool. She was so impressed that I often run 3 miles (or once in a while 6 miles, though I do walk a bit before starting a 2nd lake loop). I explained that my pace is verrrry slow, but she was still impressed. I also mentioned that when I started run/walk it was not possible to go more than 30 seconds running… so she should not get discouraged.
I thought this might be of interest to several posters in terms of minutes to exercise and how to structure workouts - as well as why strength and cardio in combination are so important.
Thanks @sabaray . Good article.
I do want to add that although you don’t need a gym , it’s good to hire a trainer to teach the correct form for the strength training. Even for a few sessions.
+1 to thanks for that article.
But while I’m happy that I’m meeting those goals for the most part (very much so on cardio, need to work more on the strength) I think Sooooo many women are not even in the ballpark. Sometimes for health reasons, often just for lack of motivation.
I’m so grateful for every day, month, year I can move. It’s so important to me.
I like how the article provides linked references to support recommendations, making the numbers of minutes per week seem less arbitrary. However, I don’t agree with the author’s conclusion that 250 minutes per week / 7 days in a week = 35 minutes per day, so work out 35 minutes per day split as 20 minutes cardio + 15 minutes weight training consistently every day.
It’s more effective to split up cardio and strength on different days than do short cardio + strength workouts sequentially, on the same day. There are also often benefits of waiting longer periods than 1 day before repeating workout, particularly for weight training on same body part. There are benefits from having rest days as well.
In general it’s good to do both cardio and strength training, and workout several times per week (with cardio and strength on different days or at least different workouts). However, it’s difficult to give a generic one size fits all type recommendation because different people have different goals and different health/fitness/injury/time status. For example, I’d recommend very different workouts for a sedentary senior whose primary goal is to maintain independence and walk up stairs , a busy parent whose primary goal is to lose weight and look better within limited schedule, a former XC runner who wants to do a 10k in 3 months, a 45 year old worried about cardiovascular health who wants to improve LDL/HDL type stats and reduce mortality risk, and a 55 year old who wants to preserve strength and mobility.
I read this via email while waiting for lunch and was going to post it when I got home! Good info!
In general, I agree with you, but this article is targeting menopausal women. And it also seems to be encouraging women who do no strength training to do something. So breaking it up into 15 min intervals each day may seem more manageable to that demographic. And something is better than nothing
I can’t speak to the effectiveness generally, but many, if not most, CrossFit workouts are programmed this way. And I personally find them very effective, for me.
For example, and this just today’s programming, I had for my strength portion wall walks to handstand holds, lateral walks and shoulder taps. I do have a wall behind me just in case, so I don’t fall.
The 2nd part of the workout was a 15-min HIIT or WOD (workout of the day), which consisted of an AMRAP of rowing, pushups and toes-to-bar.
The strength portion could have just as easily been something like back or front squats, or clean and jerks, deadlifts, snatches, etc. And then incoporating those lifts into a HIIT.
Now I know there are arguments against this type of exercise programming, and I’m sure they’d have a good argument.
BTW, I also do just strength days and just cardio days too. To me it’s about variability.
While doing cardio and strength sequentially in the same workout is no doubt better than not workout out at all, many studies have found it is less effective that doing cardio and strength workouts in separate sessions. An example is the study at Concurrent Training : Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research (“concurrent” is strength + cardio in same day) . Some example quotes are below:
“For moderator variables, resistance training concurrently with running, but not cycling, resulted in significant decrements in both hypertrophy and strength.”
"The mean ES (Effect Size) for power development for strength training only was 0.91; for endurance training, it was 0.11; and for concurrent training, it was 0.55. "
In addition to concurrent training, the linked article recommends doing the 20 minutes cardio + 15 minutes strength workout “consistently” each day. If working out same muscle group each day, daily workouts can further impede progress. The article also doesn’t mention rest days. Working out consistently without rest days can impede progress further still, particularly if combined with working out same muscle groups in same way each day. There also may be logistical challenges with trying to fit in a traditional x sets of y reps type weight workout in just 15 minutes.
I haven’t seen any other recommendation that resembles this structure of workouts. The studies referenced in the article and elsewhere in this thread imply a very different workout structure. For example, the Physical Activities Guidelines ucbalumnus linked above has recommendation and examples of weight training 2-3x per week, with longer workouts than 15 minutes.
The author of the article justifies the recommendations in the article, including references. The justification for the unique workout structure does not mention the target audience being menopausal women. Instead the justification is “250 minutes a week … works out to roughly 35 minutes a day.” – 250/7 ~= 35. It’s a similar idea for 15 minutes of weight training per day. The study referenced in the article found “90 to 119 minutes a week”. The author says “100 minutes isn’t a number I rounded up to. It sits in the middle of the best-supported range”. And 100/7 ~= 15 – 15 minutes per day.
As mentioned in my earlier replies, different people have different workout types and different workout goals, and there are many ways to achieve those goals. I’m sure your workout structure works for you, and the author’s workout structure works for many people. I’m not saying it doesn’t work – only that it’s a non-standard recommendation that is likely to be less effective than alternative structures. The article doesn’t discuss this, instead implying a one size fits all solution.
Regarding CrossFit specifically, CrossFit places a strong emphasis on concentric weight training movements (Olympic lifts). This reduces recovery time compared to more traditional weight training, which makes it more fitting for author’s style of workouts.
In the case of CrossFit, the combination of strength and cardio is foundational and is better explained in this 2007 article entitled “Removing Interference” (i.e., interference between strength and cardio and their benefits).
I’ll quote the concluding paragraph:
And this is what I tell people. CrossFIt is a compromise between elite strength and elite cardio. Additionally, the current popularity of Hyrox is another adaptation.
But I’m always curious about your thoughts @Data10.
Interesting article. At a ten thousand foot level, I agree with the reasons for interference between strength training and cardio in same workout. At a more detailed level, there is interfering signaling.
For example, endurance activities can inhibit mTOR for a few hours following workout. mTOR promotes protein synthesis and muscle growth. As such muscle growth may be reduced if weight training is done within a few hours of endurance activity, with a strong dependence on intensity and duration of the endurance activity. Or like the article mentions, there are competing adaptations to the 2 activities. Glycogen depletion is also relevant, particularly if doing cardio first. Basic fatigue is also important, like the article mentions. This may be the most influential factor, particularly if the workouts are shorter and less intense. This relates to why the reduction in strength/muscle gains tends to be larger if doing cardio first than if doing weight training first.
It’s the title of the article. The doctor is discussing what she tells her patients in menopause. (And note - that is AFTER one hasn’t had a period in 1 year. It’s not the period while you are going through the changes) Hence women 50++, and her message that the numbers are rough guidelines, something is better than nothing, and the key is to build consistency with strength training is quite valid. Knowing many people in this age group who grew up thinking weights are bad, have zero experience in this arena, and have no idea where to start and are super intimated and paralyzed by the thought of stepping into a gym, I can definitely see this being helpful.
My only hope is that for her patients like these, she goes further in her talks and gives them places to go, or videos to watch or something that helps push them past that state of paralysis. She isn’t counseling them to optimize their fitness. She counseling them to getting started.
There are several female physicians (Dr. Jen Ashton springs to mind) who are doing their best to make fitness, especially strength training, more approachable to women of all ages. When I was younger and actually training for an event then sure, I would follow the traditional patterns of days of cardio, days of strength, days of yoga. But now that I am older with some physical limitations I welcome hearing a voice that says it is perfectly okay to do combination workouts that may be at a lower intensity. Today is a rest day for me because I’m tired. Tomorrow I am thinking I will do a little TRX and some treadmill. I get chunks of exercise every day because I have an active Labrador. I think our goal should be to encourage people to exercise, not tell them everything they’re doing wrong when the thought of the “correct” way to exercise might just be too overwhelming to attack at the moment.