Which would be the better choice: Full ride at University of Oklahoma, or paying something close to full freight at a school like Rice, Vanderbilt or University of Texas? We are in the category of folks who probably make a little too much to get significant aid, but not enough to pay full freight out-of-state without out raiding a material chunk of our retirement savings in taxable accounts, etc. I.e., incurring some real pain to pay the crazy full freight fees. We are in that parental purgatory - not low income enough to have money thrown our way, not wealthy enough to comfortably scratch a check for $280,000. Could we do it - probably. Is it worth it, I don’t know. Son likely will pursue engineering. It’s a tough call with many considerations beyond cost as well (such as fit, which will open up more job opportunities, etc.). Thoughts?
Easy: Free in-state. The difference is not worth $280K
I suppose realistically the range of out-of-state fees might be more in the neighborhood of $160-280K (max end). I suppose it’s possible to round up a few merit scholarships here and there, perhaps obtain ‘some’ aid based on reduced employment and current wages (vs the tax old tax return(s) that would be submitted with FAFSA), etc… So, $280 may not be actual reality.
So, how about this then: At what dollar figure do Rice, Vandy or UT look more enticing vs essentially free in-state at OU? At some point the pendulum would have to shift I think insofar as a degree from Rice (relative to OU) may prove more valuable long term and provide a better education
Unfortunately there is not good data to inform your decision (ROI, job outcomes, etc.) and you will find opinions all over the place regarding your question. Search for some past threads here on CC, look in the parents forum, there are some recent ones especially regarding engineering degrees. Here is one starting point, with a general (not engineering) focus: http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/parents-forum/2112065-different-schools-of-thought-about-paying-for-college-p1.html
I will tag @eyemgh, @engineer80, @merc81 to see if they can answer your question from an engineering perspective
Will your S qualify for honors college at Oklahoma? If he is competitive for the other schools you listed, it would seem likely, and that could be another pro for OK.
The answer will differ by family and depends what you mean by more “enticing”. If you are talking about pure ROI in terms of ability to get a higher salary, then for engineering the answer is “not much”. If you are talking about the “life of the mind” and the intangible benefits of spending four years amongst intellectual peers, then some would say educational spending should be more of a priority.
Many families set a budget and stick to that, for example equivalent to the full pay cost of their instate flagship. But then the question is what if any incentive your kid has to opt for a less expensive/less prestigious school. We gave our kids the budget and let them choose, and said they could keep the difference for later grad school or a home downpayment if they were below budget. That’s a way to crystallize the huge amount of money involved (both chose the cheaper option in our case). See the debate in this thread: http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/parents-forum/2112065-different-schools-of-thought-about-paying-for-college-p1.html
From a pure dollars and cents perspective, even MIT and Stanford don’t come close to penciling over free. To figure this out, you need to calculate opportunity cost. Take the difference, run the return on investment of simply sticking it in the market for 40 years. I use 6% and age 19.5 to 59.5, the year you can draw from a tax advantaged retirement account.
Let’s assume the OU scholarship is tuition only, and you’d pay the same room, board and fees at both institutions. At $46,600 per year Rice would cost just under $186,000 more than OU. Using the assumptions above on opportunity cost, Rice costs just under $2,000,000 more. That means to break even, he would have to earn that much MORE over his career.
The experiences would be different for sure, but if you pull salary data from all the institutions in question, you’ll see they are pretty similar.
That said, our son didn’t choose the cheapest school. He didn’t apply to any full pay, no merit aid schools though. We set a cap of $200k. He ended up at a school that was $140k.
Stop trying to convince yourself that you should spend the money.
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. My personal perspective is that, while one can get a quality education anywhere (good professors and the same textbooks exist at every institution), the college experience is more than that. The interactions with fellow students go a long way toward personal development, of course, so don’t discount the benefit of being part of a smart, hard-working, diverse student body. That’s where many lifelong friendships develop, and with them, contacts. All that has value that is hard to quantify.
Speaking for myself, I’m telling my daughter she has to have a really good reason to not go to our state’s flagship college. If she gets into Harvard, she can go to Harvard. If she gets into Case Western or Tulane, probably not, because I don’t think they’re much better than the University of Florida. She’d need to get into a top school that has a truly national reputation–that is, one that would impress an employer anywhere in the country.
Vandy, I think, clearly qualifies. Rice, too. Less sure about UT. I think you need to find a line and stick to it. And, of course, there are other public schools in other states that won’t cost quite as much, but do have a better reputation and possibly a better overall student body, if that’s important. Like Michigan, Georgia Tech (great option for engineering), or one of the California schools. Or even UF 
Also–and this is something I have NO experience with, so feel free to be skeptical–I’ve HEARD that if you have a free ride at an in-state school, you can POSSIBLY use it as leverage to at least be offered the in-state rate at other public schools. I don’t know to what extent this works, and whether it has any impact at a school like UVa or William and Mary or UNC (or even UT), which are all probably better than Oklahoma, but it may be worth a shot. Maybe someone else can comment on that.
BTW, he is now a Master’s candidate and faced the same decision himself. He was ahead and is able to finish both BS and a thesis based MS in 5 years (or maybe a quarter less) at Cal Poly. When he applied to the blended program, the program advisor and several of his professors said that based on his record compared to previous students who had been admitted from CP that he would have a very high chance of being admitted to Stanford for his MS. It would have taken him at least one extra year, one where he’d lose a year of wage AND pay $55k in tuition. He crunched the numbers like I outlined above and didn’t bother to even apply.
Broken record:
- At what dollar figure would the price be comfortably affordable for you?
- At what dollar figure do you and he think that some other school is worth over OU?
Why not Oklahoma State? They have the better engineering program, in my opinion.
OU is a national merit school who tried to woo my NM winner to their engineering school.
Why not OU?
Not worth it, imo. And you’re talking about raiding retirement. Never ever touch your retirement savings unless absolutely compelled to. This is not such a situation.
@ucbalumnus hit it on the head. The only thing I’d add is to seriously ask yourself what does the difference buy? In most cases it won’t buy higher earnings, but it will buy a different experience and that too has value.
For example, our flagship, Oregon State, is a classic 2 years of books, two years of labs engineering program. They have big classes and rely heavily on teaching assistants. They have a hiring pipeline into some very good companies.
We chose to pay the difference for Cal Poly ($50k more) based on their class size, non-use of teaching assistants, starting ME in earnest first year, and its idyllic location. Will he earn more as a result, probably not. Here’s the thing though, we saved and didn’t have to borrow. Had it meant raiding retirement funds or taking loans, those extra advantages he sought, that we happily paid for, would not have been worth it.
Lots of good comments above. I know it’s an extremely personal decision where different families could come to different conclusions. I posted primarily just to hear some different perspectives. Appreciate the thoughts above.
One factor is the college experience that some above note. I agree that has value - how much, hard to say. I went to OU myself (B.Acctg, then JD). It was fine and it has served me well enough, but I never really enjoyed the campus experience there all that much for various reasons (excluding OU football, ha). Based on personal experience, a part of me would like to see my kids go to a more dynamic environment (particularly b/c I know my son (4.0 GPA (unweighted) type student / 1560 SAT), is in a different class of student relative to me).
I also wonder (aloud) whether there is something to be said for working hard but perhaps finishing with a higher engineering undergrad GPA at OU vs running really hard with the masses at a Rice or Vanderbilt and finding oneself lucky to have graduated with a 3.1, or the like. I suppose that might be relevant to a grad school application. Just a data point.
Also, just take OU and UT for a comparison. UT is, by about any measure, a top 10 engineering program. Also, Texas is an immense job market that a UT degree will tend to open up. OU (and OSU) are way down the list relative to UT and Oklahoma has less career opportunities. Of course, one can move out of state for employment. Nevertheless, this is a data point to consider. Some interesting points above re: cost / benefit analysis.
We have through the years saved adequately (529) to cover in-state education. So, in our case that could be used for grad school (or a “down payment” on out-of state undergraduate education). When I speak of raiding retirement funds, perhaps that’s somewhat misleading. We’ve diligently saved in our 401(k) accounts, and the taxable brokerage account (which would be tapped) was just another saving depot that I figured would eventually be part of retirement savings. Beyond the 529 funds I’m not sure how much I’m willing to spend (two kids approaching college). I guess that’s just some soul searching that needs to be done.
“Unfortunately there is not good data to inform your decision (ROI, job outcomes, etc.) and you will find opinions all over the place regarding your question. Search for some past threads here on CC, look in the parents forum, there are some recent ones especially regarding engineering degrees. Here is one starting point, with a general (not engineering) focus: http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/parents-forum/2112065-different-schools-of-thought-about-paying-for-college-p1.html”
^^^^
Interesting thread. Thanks.
No the full ride is really your only realistic option unless you have significant money in your 529 account that will offset a good chunk of your OOS schools.
What’s the difference in cost at UT Austin and what you have saved already?
@BurOak Getting your student through undergrad debt free is a tremendous gift. Success in undergrad will be determined by your student, not the name of the college. Save your funds for grad school.
@buroak My personal POV is that the college experience is what the student makes it. I have had tippyntop students attend very avg Us on full rides. (One of my kids had completed a math minor and 5 in major physics courses before he graduated from high school.) They have pursued on-campus UG research, co-ops/REUS, and taken grad level courses as UG.
They have ended up working alongside or attending grad schools with kids from top UG schools. From Ur perspective, saving the $$ was win-win. Zero negatives.