Free In-State v Likely Full Freight Out-of-State

There are LOTS of good options out there that might offer a different experience than OU, while still offering either a very attractive list price or substantial merit aid. I am not looking to start a flame war here, but Vandy and Rice, while both are well respected, neither would be considered an engineering pinnacle. That certainly is a matter of perspective, but the number of relative peer level institutions is pretty large, many of whom would likely offer him substantial money (Case, Lehigh, RPI and WPI to name a few). And no, neither Rice or Vandy would be seen as superior to UT by hiring engineers. Again, both are well respected, but neither has the national engineering reputation of the major state schools like Illinois, Texas, Purdue, or Georgia Tech.

What is “best” is HIGHLY dependent on perspective, basically what is important to the individual student. Names, like MIT, Stanford, Berkeley, Caltech, etc. have value, but there is far more than name. My dad, a MIT grad, my uncle a Stanford grad, and two of my patients, both retired Caltech/JPL faculty, each raved about the graduate programs at their respective schools, but warned my son away from their respective undergraduate institutions.

I suggest you talk to him to try to tease out what is important to him. Is it class size? Reliance on TAs? Is admission to major 1st, 2nd or 3rd year? Is it competitive? How easy is it to switch? Location? Urban? Rural? Inbetween? Weather? Sports? What hobbies does he like? How far from home would he be comfortable? What about political balance of the student body? Whatever is important to HIM, is what is important.

Notice, I didn’t list ranking. I think they are GROSSLY overused because, especially for engineering, they don’t capture the student experience. They also vastly over rate Ivy schools. Beyond Cornell, the rest are peers with middle tier state schools, some lower. We’ve been, and seen them up close. Why anyone would choose Harvard for engineering (unless they want to be a banker), is beyond me.

Then, if you have the budget, go visit. For some, visiting isn’t affordable, and others feel it wasn’t helpful. It was immensely helpful to our son. Seeing first hand the facilities undergraduates use, the projects they can be involved in and the campus feel is very valuable.

Don’t fall into the trap either that selectivity equates to quality. It may or it may not. When the dust settled for our son, his final three choices were a school that accepts nearly everyone (Utah), one that accepts about 50% (WPI) and one that, for ME, accepts a bit over 10% (Cal Poly, students compete for admission by major only against those who declare the same major, so selectivity by major is all over the map). He didn’t make his final decision until 2 day before the deadline. They were all unified by one thing, starting mechanical engineering on day one in a meaningful way.

Good luck. It’s a fun process!

P.S. The point @RayManta made about Case vs. Florida typifies what I see is wrong with our college selection discussion (please don’t feel picked on). I am in NO WAY saying Florida is inferior. They have a great scholarship program for high achieving instate students. The College of Engineering is very well respected. Florida however is one of the biggest campuses in the nation, accompanied by large classes and heavy reliance on TAs. Case on the other hand is small. Let’s spin an example, a student who is a bit lost in the big crowd, that wants to study BME and is an accomplished musician. Case Western boasts one of the longest established BME programs in the nation, approaching 50 years. It is affiliated with a vibrant medical community, including Cleveland Clinic. It is also adjacent to the Cleveland Institute of Music. Case students can study privately with CIM instructors if they want to continue very high end music, but don’t want to major in it. That MIGHT make Case a superior to U of F (Go Gators!). It really is a matter of perspective and fit. They can also be generous. They offered our son $100,000. While certainly not a Bright Futures scholarship, it was a solid award. It is very much like saying Porsche is better than Chevy. It isn’t if you have 6 kids or need to tow a boat.

Fascinating thread. We’ve tried very hard to communicate to both of our kids that we would pay 4 years in state tuition - if they wanted to go out of state, they needed to find scholarship funds to cover the difference. That plan means graduating debt free. So far so good with the first kid who graduates in May 2019. Second kid is working with the plan but does express from time to time how she is frustrated she can’t apply to any Ivies (she would likely be competitive for them) - but at the same time, she expresses interest in BME, which the Ivies don’t seem to be well known for - of course I question if she’ll change her mind. It will be really interesting to see where we are next spring.

Any chance your kiddo will get merit $$ from Rice? Vandy? Why not wait til you see the actual numbers and then decide what your bottom line is you might be willing to spend that wouldn’t put a dent in your savings/retirement plans?

Please make sure you look at all the FEES at OU - DS is in her 3rd year there and the fees are almost equal to tuition!

Have you asked your son if he likes OU? It may be that that is his first choice. Help him learn to love it! No need to create an OU/UT rivalry in your own house. Nebraska may have been the cheapest, best fit school for my child, but she wasn’t going there. Never even considered it. Not sure she knows Nebraska has a university as I certainly never mentioned it. Don’t care that they are BiG 10 now and CU is Pac12, the hate lives on. She went to Wyoming, which was fine with me (Mountain West conference). Go Buffs.

I think the things you didn’t like about OU you also wouldn’t have liked about Texas. Big, large lectures, fraternity guys, snow, no snow, big sports, not knowing everyone on campus.

I personally think the dollar figure cut off is where you can’t afford to pay it out of savings, current income, and (small) loans. No borrowing from 401k, no private loans, no parent Plus loans. You CAN provide a good college education without borrowing and that is a very good thing to give your child.

Hey @eyemgh. I agree that this was sort of an apples-to-walnuts comparison, and in fact the variable you raise is one that my family is struggling with. Unfortunately, the south is loaded with gigantic state schools. As far as I know, Florida doesn’t have a public option equivalent in size to, say William and Mary (possibly New School in Sarasota, which admittedly I know nothing about).

However, depending on your individual financial situation, the different atmosphere/school size between Case and UF still may not be worth the additional $250,000 or so. The student may be somewhat happier, but how to quantify it?

Yes, of course a financial award from Case (or any private school the OP may be considering) makes it much easier to swallow. I agree that there’s no reason to make a decision before you’ve gotten accepted and can see what sort of scholarship or grant money they make available–it could make the difference and you never know what will happen, even if you think you aren’t eligible.

Again, deciding where to draw that line is a difficult and personal process–we can probably agree on that.

@socaldad2002 -“What’s the difference in cost at UT Austin and what you have saved already.” Well, absent some merit scholarship money (which might exist), I’m sure it’d be $100K+. Kid #2 would follow three years later - repeat process.

@eyemgh - Lots of good points. I agree, Rice and Vandy aren’t the end-all, be-all in engineering. Frankly, we came up with those schools as a way to start the college discussion that was broader than Oklahoma. Those three are some of the better schools that are “loosely” in our region, and probably have a similar cultural persona (vs say the Northeast). Also, I have this sense that the residential college nature of Rice and Vandy might be a good fit. But, I could also see OU being fine too. To be fair, sure, Purdue, Illinois and some others aren’t much further away, but you get my point. I think finding a school that can literally be driven to in 12 hours or less has some practical advantages. But, to your point, we may end up broadening our look. I see that USC offers some full and 1/2 tuition scholarships. I’m sure those are difficult to secur however, like anything of that sort.

@Mom2aphysicsgeek -“My personal POV is that the college experience is what the student makes it.” I agree. One’s perspective and attitude are everything.

@twoinanddone -“Have you asked your son if he likes OU? It may be that that is his first choice. Help him learn to love it.” I think he likes OU, so I’m not pooh-poohing it. He may like it fine and excel there.

@jym626 -“Any chance your kiddo will get merit $$ from Rice? Vandy? Why not wait til you see the actual numbers and then decide what your bottom line is you might be willing to spend that wouldn’t put a dent in your savings/retirement plans?” I don’t think Rice and Vandy are big on merit money. But I agree, we need to wait and see what will unfold. The discussion on this thread is really more philosophical than anything at this point as we are just beginning to delve into college search subject.

Lots to consider for sure.

I think OU is one of handful of schools that offers the kind of money they do for national merit scholars, etc. I can fully appreciate the appeal and benefit of zero undergrad debt and, better yet, getting there thanks to the type of merit aid OU offers. I went through OU similarly via an Okla. regents scholarship 30 years ago. Ironically, I chose that path vs. attending UT or Michigan which would’ve required heavy parental support and probably loans as we were just a run-of-the-mill middle class family.

@BurOak - Rice can be generous with merit $. Vandy has merit money too, but some required a separate application.

And I have to disagree with your comment - Rice’s engineering is excellent. My S is a Mech E Rice Grad. Excellent program. You just have to decide, if your s feels its the best fit, if its affordable for you. If not, move on. But to say that you came up with Rice and Vandy as a starting place to look outside of OU seems a bit of an unusual way to look at colleges. And as an aside, not that it matters, but my s chose Rice over Ga Tech, for a variety or reasons.

@BurOak OK, if your kid has a 4.0 UW and 1560 SAT, he should be competitive for merit scholarships at many places, both public and private. Cost will probably be somewhat more than the “free” in-state option and less than 70K per year. Rice and Vandy both offer merit as does Case Western. His stats would likely earn him full tuition at UT-Dallas and a significant discount at U of Alabama or at ASU with entry into their Honors Colleges.

Is he currently a junior or a senior?

FWIW, I took the free ride at my state university back in the day. The Honors Program made a large place small and gave me access to compatible peers and some of the best professors at the university.

As parents, we gave our kid a budget limit that was possible to obtain through merit scholarships, but not without. She could have gone to our adequate state flagship tuition-free but we were willing to pay for the intangibles of a higher-ranked private school because we knew she would take full advantage of them.

Good question, @mamaedefamilia - Is this student a junior who is just exploring schools, or a senior whose applications should be done (if EA) or to be submitted within the next few weeks?

I mentioned the big publics (I left out Michigan and a few CA schools), simply because they, along with a few privates like MIT, Stanford and Caltech, carry big name cachet. I’m not though suggesting they are great options or that they should be considered. They can be, but for our son, the collective family decision was that it didn’t make sense to pay a lot to attend a big out of state public school, with large classes and heavy reliance on TAs, because Oregon State is a cheap, reasonable quality in state option with all those same qualities.

Side Bar: Cal Poly is a CA public, but it is a Cal State and not a UC school. The CSUs are about $60k cheaper than the UCs from OOS (that’s about to change for CP). In the charter of the CSUs they are forbidden from awarding PhDs. As a result, Cal Poly is a very undergraduate centric institution with small classes (20-30), even at the intro level, instructors that nearly all have terminal degrees, even for labs and discussions, and very robust teaching labs, more than 80 in the College of Engineering alone. What they lack is access to high level, cutting edge research. Sure, there’s research, but not Nobel level stuff like you find at Berkeley. It’s all about tradeoffs, and which ones are important to the individual vetting the schools.

As for location, being further away can actually result in easier transportation to and from home. Cal Poly is 9 hours away from us by car, but like us, in a small air market. As a result he typically drives. Had he chosen Utah, he could have flown direct. Boston is two flights, connecting in Denver or SLC. The actual travel time would have been less than from San Luis Obispo. It adds to the cost, but driving 12 hours isn’t free, and it’s less likely they’ll come as frequently if they spend the whole day in the car in each direction.

I don’t dislike Rice. There’s A LOT to like. I was answering from the “is it worth it” relative to free. You might also want to look at Wash U in St. Louis if you want a school very similar to Vandy or Rice. If you want a small public, that would likely offer good merit and is close to OK, Missouri S&T, formerly the University of Missouri - Rolla, Rolla School of Mines at its inception, is worth a look. It has had a very solid engineering reputation for a long time.

You will find lots of specific opinions here and in the rest of the world, but remember, we all have very limited perspective, typically the school we attended and the schools our kids attend(ed). It isn’t like anyone has broad experience attending a lot of schools. Then, affirmation of our and/or our children’s decisions drives defense of them. It isn’t like anyone can REALLY tell you that the school they chose was better, they just believe it is. They don’t have first hand knowledge though. My son summarized it well when I asked him if he felt CP was the “perfect fit” after he’d been there a quarter. He said “I like it here a lot, but I’m sure I would have been fine at any of the schools I applied to.”

You’re doing the right work and asking the right questions.

Don’t touch your retirement! Not worth it!

@BurOak

  1. You need to run the net price calculators for these schools. Are you self employed? Are you divorced? Do you own a business? Do you own real estate in addition to your primary residence? If NO...then the net price calculators will give you a very good estimate of your net cost.
  2. What year in high school is your kid?
  3. Your student has fine enough stats. It’s possible he or she could get some merit aid at places where the cost would then be below your instate savings.
  4. I don’t see University of Alabama on your kid’s potential list. Why? Great engineering program, and facilities. And he or she would get terrific merit aid. BUT if he is a senior...get cracking because the deadline to apply is the 15th of December. Application takes all of five minutes to complete. Scholarship application is also pretty quick...maybe another five minutes. No question, this school would be affordable.
  5. I’m going to be contrary here about your college savings. Help your kid with undergrad school. Then let him or her get a JOB and pay for grad school themselves. Of course, if you have extra money, that’s another story. Then sure, help with grad school. But you seem to be singing the blues about finances, so I’m SMH trying to figure out why you are talking about grad school.
  6. I believe you mention engineering as a major. You know...as long as the school is ABET accredited, it’s a fine school.
  7. Set a budget for undergrad costs. Then discuss this with your kid.
  8. Who made that list of colleges in your OP? Because there are tons of other options for engineering majors. Tons.

MOST IMPORTANT…REMEMBER YOUR KID IS GOING TO COLLEGE, NOT YOU. And yes, I’m yelling because you mention that OU wasn’t so great for you. Well, that was a generation ago, and times have changed.

@BurOak Yoh should read this thread. Just replace taking out loans with taking $$ out of retirement accts.
http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/financial-aid-scholarships/2113991-parents-are-taking-out-bigger-loans-to-pay-for-their-childrens-college-education-p1.html

Destabilizing our financial situation for our children’s college education is just not ever a good plan.

Sounds like the OP’s kid is a junior. As the OP is a new poster, it would be helpful, IMO, for the OP to read the many, many threads on this same topic. And agree with comments above— help your kiddo figure out what they want- urban? Suburban? Rural? Big? Small? Greek life? Div I Sports? Greek life? Willing to consider single sex? Liberal arts school? There are many things to look at first besides cost.

@twoinanddone - I’m midwest - and all i can say is that at my old work, we had an engineer from Cornell, Rice and NEBRASKA - and all were paid the same.

Lots of good points on here.

One I haven’t seen mentioned is time to graduate. I don’t know any UT or A&M Engineers graduating in 4. Add another semester or two of tuition, living costs for a year (not too many hire for January start) and generally being on your payroll instead of someone else’s. Don’t know about OU, maybe he’d be special enough to get his classes to get out.

While you are building financial models, consider the lifestyle you will be willing to fund. The UT greek scene is expensive, is OU similar? Between fees, formals, ski trips, spring break and the slush fund, add another 10-15k, per year.

If your child is a senior, the USC merit application deadline passed last week.

I agree about looking at some smaller than OU, UT schools which could offer a closer experience to Rice or Vandy but more likely to offer merit, if experience is the draw over ‘ranking’. Unless your child has a real intellectual hook beyond great stats and National Merit, your top tier merit will be hard to get.

In your situation I would absolutely not be raiding the retirement piggy bank. I would be looking for some schools that can be expected to fall between free and $280 and offer some perceived benefits over OU.

Are you nuts?? :slight_smile: Someone hands you the keys to a brand new Honda. Would you turn it down so you can pay $200,000 for a Porsche you can’t afford? In the end, it doesn’t matter how “nice” the Porsche is, you’re better off taking the Honda.

Same with a full-ride scholarship. Someone just gave you $100,000! In the end, both schools are going to get you into an entry-level job at an entry level salary. But you have an advantage most kids don’t. You get to graduate debt-free!

@noready - can’t speak for those particular schools, but unless an engineering program has a co-op component (where the student is typically paid), many engineering students complete their programs in 4 years. Both my s’s are engineers and both completed, as did most of their classmates, in 4 years. (One student, a year behind younger s in the engineering program, took some time off because he won “Big Bother”!)