There are LOTS of good options out there that might offer a different experience than OU, while still offering either a very attractive list price or substantial merit aid. I am not looking to start a flame war here, but Vandy and Rice, while both are well respected, neither would be considered an engineering pinnacle. That certainly is a matter of perspective, but the number of relative peer level institutions is pretty large, many of whom would likely offer him substantial money (Case, Lehigh, RPI and WPI to name a few). And no, neither Rice or Vandy would be seen as superior to UT by hiring engineers. Again, both are well respected, but neither has the national engineering reputation of the major state schools like Illinois, Texas, Purdue, or Georgia Tech.
What is “best” is HIGHLY dependent on perspective, basically what is important to the individual student. Names, like MIT, Stanford, Berkeley, Caltech, etc. have value, but there is far more than name. My dad, a MIT grad, my uncle a Stanford grad, and two of my patients, both retired Caltech/JPL faculty, each raved about the graduate programs at their respective schools, but warned my son away from their respective undergraduate institutions.
I suggest you talk to him to try to tease out what is important to him. Is it class size? Reliance on TAs? Is admission to major 1st, 2nd or 3rd year? Is it competitive? How easy is it to switch? Location? Urban? Rural? Inbetween? Weather? Sports? What hobbies does he like? How far from home would he be comfortable? What about political balance of the student body? Whatever is important to HIM, is what is important.
Notice, I didn’t list ranking. I think they are GROSSLY overused because, especially for engineering, they don’t capture the student experience. They also vastly over rate Ivy schools. Beyond Cornell, the rest are peers with middle tier state schools, some lower. We’ve been, and seen them up close. Why anyone would choose Harvard for engineering (unless they want to be a banker), is beyond me.
Then, if you have the budget, go visit. For some, visiting isn’t affordable, and others feel it wasn’t helpful. It was immensely helpful to our son. Seeing first hand the facilities undergraduates use, the projects they can be involved in and the campus feel is very valuable.
Don’t fall into the trap either that selectivity equates to quality. It may or it may not. When the dust settled for our son, his final three choices were a school that accepts nearly everyone (Utah), one that accepts about 50% (WPI) and one that, for ME, accepts a bit over 10% (Cal Poly, students compete for admission by major only against those who declare the same major, so selectivity by major is all over the map). He didn’t make his final decision until 2 day before the deadline. They were all unified by one thing, starting mechanical engineering on day one in a meaningful way.
Good luck. It’s a fun process!
P.S. The point @RayManta made about Case vs. Florida typifies what I see is wrong with our college selection discussion (please don’t feel picked on). I am in NO WAY saying Florida is inferior. They have a great scholarship program for high achieving instate students. The College of Engineering is very well respected. Florida however is one of the biggest campuses in the nation, accompanied by large classes and heavy reliance on TAs. Case on the other hand is small. Let’s spin an example, a student who is a bit lost in the big crowd, that wants to study BME and is an accomplished musician. Case Western boasts one of the longest established BME programs in the nation, approaching 50 years. It is affiliated with a vibrant medical community, including Cleveland Clinic. It is also adjacent to the Cleveland Institute of Music. Case students can study privately with CIM instructors if they want to continue very high end music, but don’t want to major in it. That MIGHT make Case a superior to U of F (Go Gators!). It really is a matter of perspective and fit. They can also be generous. They offered our son $100,000. While certainly not a Bright Futures scholarship, it was a solid award. It is very much like saying Porsche is better than Chevy. It isn’t if you have 6 kids or need to tow a boat.
Someone hands you the keys to a brand new Honda. Would you turn it down so you can pay $200,000 for a Porsche you can’t afford? In the end, it doesn’t matter how “nice” the Porsche is, you’re better off taking the Honda.