Free In-State v Likely Full Freight Out-of-State

@noready No engineering majors are graduating in 8 semesters? I just looked at the requirements for TAMU’s chemE degree and they look very similar to most Us’ chemE semester sequences. So, unless courses are impacted in such a way that students are unable to register for necessary courses, not graduating in 8 semesters seems individual related, not U.

I also question your argument that employment runs on a school calendar, especially for student with co-op experience.

Fwiw, there can be a significant difference between not graduating in 4 yrs and not graduating in 8 semesters. Students who co-op often do not graduate in 4 yr even though they are graduating in 8 semesters. Co-oping is a great option for students bc it gives them actual work experience and makes them more competitive for employment post graduation. Many take 5 yrs to graduate, but 1 yr is spent building their resume with work experience.

Student who enter with credit hrs can graduate in under 8 smemsters. Our ds graduated in 4 yrs including 12 months of co-oping. He attended freshman and sophomore yrs, did research that summer, then started co-oping fall of what would have been Jr yr and co-oped until the following fall. He then attended fall, spring, and summer and graduated in Aug (so 7 semesters total). He had numerous good offers even though he didn’t graduate in May.

Our philosophy was great flagship at decent cost (easily affordable) or much better school with merit.

So even full rides at lesser (in our view) schools were taken off the table.
Higher ranked schools were applied to and weighed in cost with merit. As it turned out the flagship won in the end. The difference in savings paid for graduate school (which scholarship money appeared–Yea!)

We weren’t doing engineering but know a kid who went to MIT for engineering (crew scholarship) and has had a career so far in research that I can’t imagine would be available without that MIT degree (and connections). So yep, name recognition is good at the very top.

@jym626, 4 year graduation rates are typically quite a bit higher at privates than publics. That said, it can be done, anywhere. The trick is simply to never dodge times or instructors. IPEDS tracks 4 year graduation rates. They’re certainly worth a look.

@eyemgh Stating that 4 yr graduation rates are higher at privates than publics is misleading. The “why” factors matter. Is it availability of courses? Finances? Familial support? Unpreparedness for full-time course load? Is it private vs public that is the reason or the self-filtering that means many of those issues are filtered out, impacting the overall graduation rates?"

Both my sons graduated in engineering from publics in 4 years. That was our expectation going in, barring something unforeseen that might have come up.

Ditto what the last 2 posters said. The things that may keep a student from finishing in 4 years at big Publics are ability to get the classes and labs, finances, co-ops, ability to handle the academic demands and willingness/ability to get help, etc.

After eight semesters of full ride, even an extra semester or few at OU at in state price should be lower cost than eight or more semesters at most other schools at list price or partially discounted price. But also, a top scholarship student is less likely to need extra semesters than typical students.

Most big publics are less selective than the private schools people write about on these forums, so that is likely the big reason behind lower graduation rates. Many big publics also have more students from lower SES families who are at greater risk of running out of money and having to take gap semesters to work, or switch to part time to work, or drop out entirely.

But these risks should not apply to a top scholarship student.

Oh poppycock! My kid graduated in four years with engineering and a double major in biology…in four years, and she used NO AP courses to satisfy her degree requirements.

She followed her course sequence carefully. She never failed a course. She did have to drop a course but was able to make it up the following term.

There are plenty of engineering students who DO graduate in four years.

Carry on.

@Mom2aphysicsgeek said: “Stating that 4 yr graduation rates are higher at privates than publics is misleading.”

Misleading? That implies intent to deceive. I do agree that it doesn’t tell the complete story and that one needs to dig deeper into every institution in question.

It was sort of implied by a previous post that lower 4 year graduation rates at publics was guaranteed. I was simply stating a fact, less than elegantly, that although the numbers might be lower, for all sorts of reasons, students can and do get out of public schools with lower 4 year graduation rates in 4 years.

I’ll use my son’s school as an example. Mechanical Engineering is a 200 quarter hour program. The average degree at his school is 180 hours (15 hours per quarter). That makes ME more than a quarter longer. Students are listed as taking 5 years if the take even a single quarter beyond 4 years. At the time my son started, the 4 year graduation rate was 17% :frowning: . He is graduating with a BS/MS in 5 years.

http://flowcharts.calpoly.edu/downloads/mymap/15-17.52MEBSU.GENMEU.pdf has a suggested 12 quarter (4 academic year) course plan for CPSLO ME majors that has 192-202 quarter credit units. This includes several quarters with 17 or 18 credit units (instead of the usual 15 credit units).

Regarding UT Austin and Texas A&M, here are their 8 semester ME flowcharts (both appear to squeeze about 8.5 semesters’ of courses into 8 semesters):
http://www.me.utexas.edu/images/undergrad2016-18.pdf (appears to be about 127 hours)
https://engineering.tamu.edu/media/4992082/Flowchart-2-Sides.pdf (128 hours)

It certainly looks doable to finish in 12 quarters or 8 semesters for a strong student. But then it may be more difficult for a not-as-strong student, or one who needs to back off on the course work because of a need to work part time to afford to attend school.

Here is the 8 semester ME flowchart at OU: http://www.ou.edu/content/dam/CoE/WSSC/Degree%20Plans%20-%20Flowcharts/Summer%202018-Spring%202019/Mechanical%20Engr%20B675%202018.pdf

Total credit hours is 123, only a slight overload from the usual 120. It is likely that a strong student (who earned a full ride scholarship) who has no financial pressure to work to afford school (due to the full ride scholarship) should be able to finish in 8 semesters. (But note the 3.0 GPA weed-out between frosh and soph years – probably not an issue for a top scholarship student, but something to be aware of generally.)

Let me start by saying I am not an engineer, but I’m married to a PhD in engineering, and all of my kids are in engineering programs.

For kids on merit scholarships that require a high GPA for scholarship retention, they sometimes take 13-14 credit hours per semester instead of 16-17. Graduating in 4 years can still be accomplished through careful planning, using AP credit, and taking summer classes (a good number are offered online).

This is the strategy we used for one of our engineering students. He attended a state school on full scholarship, graduated summa cum laude in 4 years, and had multiple grad school offers with funding. He did have friends who took 4.5 or 5 years to graduate. You can easily start a semester behind in engineering just by not scoring high enough on the math placement exam.

If the OP’s student is a junior and possible NMF, then that changes some of the advice given earlier. Some things to consider:

–Look at the AP credit charts on the college websites to get an idea how many credits your student may receive. Then look at the online degree plans to see if any of your AP credit will count toward the degree. If not, then it’s useless. Some students enter with many (sometimes all) general ed. classes covered by AP which helps the graduation time. Knowing this information could also help in planning the senior year high school schedule.

–Find out the requirements to maintain the merit scholarships and if other scholarships will stack.

–Start making a spreadsheet now comparing details of all colleges.

If you’re filling out the ApplyTexas application for UT Austin, shoot one over to Texas A&M. They have top-notch engineering facilities and programs, and TAMU offers a National Merit package. It appears smaller than OU or OSU’s packages at first glance, but other scholarships will stack, and it qualifies your student to pay Texas in-state tuition rates. UT Austin offers little to no merit for OOS students.

Another suggestion in your region is the University of Colorado in the beautiful town of Boulder. There are OOS merit scholarships, but the big ones are competitive. It wouldn’t be a full ride but could be affordable if your student wins a big award.

OU and OSU’s national merit packages do not cover the full cost of attendance. They cover approximately 2/3 of the cost, but you will be able to stack additional scholarships. I would apply to both and compare offers.

I’m partial to state schools for ABET-accredited engineering programs. They have long-standing programs that turn out thousands of engineers per year and are a great value. A top student at a state school will have no problem getting into a top grad school program (in our experience).

@ucbalumnus - post #47 - that’s exactly my point, but didn’t think it needed to be spelled out. Stronger students, perhaps especially if at top tier privates, and more likely to succeed in a difficult major like engineering. There are certainly plenty of strong students at state Us, but comparatively, likely more “less strong” students who may face challenges with rigorous engineering course loads.

And strong students are more likely to be coming in with more AP credits so will be able to finish in 4 years.

@eyemgh - not seeing where anyone even implied that a lower 4 year grad rate was guaranteed at a public school. Where is that posted?

It needs to be spelled out because there seems to be a common assumption on these forums that a strong student at a less selective school will be “dragged down” by the less strong students there, so that the strong student’s likelihood of 4 year graduation is no greater than the overall average of the school and its less strong students. OU’s 4-year graduation rate is about 40%, but is it believable that only 40% of top scholarship students there graduate in 4 years?

@jym626, this is the salient piece of a post #37 I was replying to: “I haven’t seen mentioned is time to graduate. I don’t know any UT or A&M Engineers graduating in 4.” You replied to it too as a matter of fact. :smiley:

Personally, my budget was approximately full sticker of the instate flagship. Kid ended up at a top 50 private within those limits (which was the most favorite school, superior in kids mind to other very high ranked schools accepted to at double the price).

We would have been happy to pay full sticker for the instate flagship, so we’re happy to pay just a tiny bit more for the better (location, major, opportunities) private option. ROI for 70K per year is just not there.

No, @eyemgh I said that in MY experience my son’s and their classmates graduated in 4 years. And later I commented, as did others, about variables that can contribute to it taking longer than 4 years to earn an engineering degree. Not seeing that anyone, especially me, said what you are apparently trying claim, or are trying to read into our posts. Please don’t do that. One poster ever ended their not being aware of a student that has graduated from UT or A&M engineering in 4 years, but its a large leap to see that as meaning that no one does.

That said, @ucbalumnus, strong students are not “dragged down” by less strong students. If anything, its more likely, and often can be an advantage that they will be the top of the middle than the middle of the top.

There’s a product built by Michelle Kretzschmar that is an easy to search, easy to rank compilation of all of the IPEDS data, information that is free, but in its native form, very cumbersome to search. If you want to say, find all the schools with more than 100 engineering classes, less than 15% part time students, less than 20,000 total students, and a 4 year graduation rate above 60% Michelle’s spreadsheet will spit out a list. Then you can rank on whatever of those metrics you feel is important. Those are random things I mentioned. The possibilities are limitless. I found it fun to play around with and far more useful than any other ranking. Click spreadsheets.

http://www.diycollegerankings.com/