Ack autocorrect above. One poster (uh oh…?? not sure what it said… commented maybe?) their not being aware of engineering students at UT or A&M who graduated in 4 years, but again, that is their experience, not a measure of the overall outcome.
@jym626, I’m replying specifically to ONE comment, this: “I don’t know any UT or A&M Engineers graduating in 4.” AND, I’m responding with the exact same point YOU made, that of course students can, and do graduate in 4 years. I’m not sure how you concluded that I was “trying claim, or are trying to read into our posts.” I’m not. I’m responding to that very unambiguous claim about those two TX schools. That’s it. I did infer that THAT post implied all publics could take longer. Certainly that was not stated. Maybe that’s where you are getting your impression. If that’s the case, I apologize.
Yes, thats what conclusion it sounded like you were jumping to. But I don’t think anyone is saying that all engineering students at privates graduate in 4 years, and none do at public’s. That seems to be a pretty big generalization. Thanks for the apology. Much appreciated.
That said, I do wonder if in smaller departments at smaller schools, where the same students are in many of the classes together through the years, that they probably form a bond and they may help each other through. Just musing.My older s has an annual reunion with a close knit group of friends from college — they call themselves. “team mech” (they were mech E majors). So there is my N of 1. 
“Which would be the better choice: Full ride at University of Oklahoma, or paying something close to full freight at a school like Rice, Vanderbilt or University of Texas?”
Since the original question included UT, I made the statement that I don’t know of any engineers who have graduated in 4 years. Of course some kids have pulled it off, I just don’t happen to know them and it is far from the norm in our area. Please be aware that many very bright kids with lots of AP credit have trouble getting in their classes in 4 years, even with summer school and online courses. Yes, on paper it is possible, haven’t observed it in reality. When we were trying to figure out total cost of attendance, we plugged in 5 years for UT specifically. I would also plug in 5 for A&M (yes the sum total would be much less with National Merit).
I didn’t mean to ruffle any feathers or start a public vs private graduation rate tit for tat, just mentioning what I’ve noticed about this specific school (which is awesome in many other ways). Please do your due diligence.
http://www.engr.utexas.edu/about/dean/messages/7234-march2012 says that in 2012, UT Austin’s engineering graduation rates were 31% in four years and 54% in six years (completing a BS in an engineering major; probably the 2005 frosh cohort). In other words, UT Austin engineering has a high washout rate (including those who switch to non-engineering majors), but most of those who do graduate with engineering degrees do so in four years.
Since UT Austin has gotten somewhat more selective since then, it is likely that the graduation rates are higher now.
https://accountability.tamu.edu/All-Metrics/Mixed-Metrics/Student-Retention-and-Graduation indicates that entering frosh in 2011 at Texas A&M engineering, four year graduation rates were 25.70% in engineering and 36.29% overall, and six year graduation rates were 62.73% in engineering and 81.76% overall.
The above indicate that it is hardly unheard of to graduate in four years for either school’s engineering division. Of course, a student who is at the top end of the range in entering academic credentials (HS GPA/rank, SAT/ACT scores, math, science, and English preparation) and who does not have financial pressure to work part time while attending school is more likely to be in the four year graduate group than one who barely made the admission threshold (or whose class rank was inflated by attending an academically weak high school) and can barely afford the net price of attendance. Someone with National Merit is more likely to be in the upper part of the range, as well as less likely to be under financial pressure due to the added scholarships.
Many schools give little or nothing for NMF. My older s got a whopping $750/year when he went to Rice.Rice gives nothing for NMF now.
Yes, some colleges are selective enough that National Merit Finalist levels of test scores and grades are “ordinary” in terms of those who can get admitted (so no or very little scholarship money for NMF at those colleges), rather than being “top of the class” at less selective colleges (some of which offer big scholarships to entice NMFs to enroll).