<p>The high school student who was expelled when her science experiment exploded is now getting a full scholarship to space camp. The funding is provided by a former NASA employee who had his own high school issues when an errant rocket he launched started a forest fire:</p>
<p>People at the principal and superintendent level get paid a lot of money to use their judgment in situations like this.</p>
<p>If they are going to blindly apply a policy without tempering it by any extenuating or mitigating circumstances, then there is no reason to pay them this kind of money.</p>
<p>Just write zero-tolerance and zero-thought policies for everything, and hire monkeys instead.</p>
<p>I read the article and found it wasn’t just any NASA employee. It was Homer Hickham, the “rocket boy” who was the subject of the October Sky movie. </p>
<p>When he was in high school he almost blew up the town’s coal mine with one of his rockets, and the town later sent him to the national science fair. How times have changed.</p>
<p>Lots of administrators don’t have the guts to exercise judgment and instead take the safe route of following the rules to the letter. Hence, you get kids suspended for having an aspirin in their backpack or expelled because Mom packed a plastic knife in their lunch.</p>
<p>A real manager would do the right thing and not be afraid to deal with any personal consequences. But, if you are a principal, you likely have a high salary and great benefits that would be hard to duplicate in another job. If you get canned by the school board, you’ll likely have to move to find a similar position and even that may be difficult if you have to explain the firing. So, the easy path is to follow the rules to the letter. Nobody in education gets fired for that.</p>
<p>Great story! I know school admins have a hard job and the sweeping rules make it so much easier but how much creativity and brains have shut down, kicked out etc. due to these circumstances.</p>
<p>As is common on this forum, many are making judgements without having much information at all. Things that are privy to those making decisions that we do not know are: 1) What has this students relationship with the school been like? Has she been in trouble prior to this? 2) What were the exact circumstances of the explosion? Had she asked the teacher & was told not to use the materials? Were students instructed to not bring in items from home & she did so anyways?
Now it could be as many are assuming, the school administrators are over reacting & making a poor decision, but it may not be that at all.</p>
<p>If her’s is an accurate, “leave-nothing-out”, story than it would appear that the administrators had a serious error in judgement…however we still don’t know if there is “more to the story”.</p>
<p>Not sure what legal duty a 16-year-old has in a science class. To me, the legal duty belongs to the teacher and the school to properly supervise.</p>
<p>Ironically, the expulsion flies in the face of John Dewey’s experiential learning philosophy (as opposed to book learnin’), which is the very basis of scientific curricula in the USA. </p>