<p>
</p>
<p>The problem with these conversations is that the truth can be obscured by our emotional connections. I understand where you are coming from. First, let me make it clear that I do not really “support” per se, or encourage, any breeding. I do however, see the benefits and reasons for continued responsible breeding (as I have laid out earlier). Knowing what I know now, what I learned after I got a dog at 13, I will never, not ever once again, buy a dog from a breeder. And yet I have an absolutely gorgeous dog who ia could not adore more, from a breeder (albeit a show breeder who actually meets my criteria). But this was not necessarily the case. My parents did not know all that we know now when they went out to get a dog, and it is extremely terrible that we almost bought from a pet store, etc. But the information isn’t readily out there and even when you see it, it is sometimes hard to accept because it is tied up in your past decisions. It is actually terrible IMO that we bought at all, because there ARE shelties in rescue, they AREN’T that hard to find, and we had the breed experience to really help one. But I am always careful now, this has taught me a lesson, that I can’t allow past decisions and emotional connections to color my perception of the truth when more information is presented to me.</p>
<p>I have had my dog for five years. My interest in homeless animals started as a natural extension of my intense love for our own “Canine American.” It was partly coincidence and partly pursuit, that my passion for homeless animals would go beyond “oh well that’s sad”. Partly coincidence because I found a good group of people who could point me in the right direction. And partly pursuit, because, maybe since I was so young, I was able to check my emotional history at the door. But not at first, not really. I still tried to justify it all “well they (insert pet store puppy, backyard breeder puppy) need homes too.” True, but you cannot perpetuate these cycles. We are drowning in homeless animals because we are allowing emotion to trump reason, and we are allowing ourselves to perpetuate dangerous cycles maybe because that’s just easier than admitting the truth, that we’ve been wrong and need to change some things. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>In fact, one of my criteria in my previous post for acceptable breeding is a lifetime guarantee to take back the dog. Our breeder was very clear: if anything happened, we were NEVER to take our dog to a shelter or rescue, we were to bring it back to her. We are under contract for that. Most (literally, all, actually) of the purebred dogs we get in rescue (and also in shelters) are from what we typically call “backyard breeders” - people who are again, usually well intentioned, but are not breeding responsibility. They typically have a nice pet and buy into the “I should make more nice pets”. The other source is dogs bought from pet stores, which get dogs from “puppy mills” that basically bred female litter after litter until they die (sorry if that is too graphic hope not). These are not show bred dogs in either case. Also, the vast, vast majority of dogs we get in rescue, and the vast vast majority euthanized yearly, ARE essentially perfect. There is nothing wrong with them. They are only the victims of human misfortune, at best, irresponsibility, in the middle, and abuse, at worst. </p>
<p>Also, the biggest problem with these two sources of pets is that they tend to perpetuate a cyclical sort of breeding that is seen as harmless but is a big contributor to the surplus animal population. This is because these sources do not require pet quality dogs to be spayed and neutered. Perhaps the greatest contributor to the unwanted pet population is accidental litters. But litters of dogs that were intentionally bred and not homed well also contribute. Either way “responsible” show breeders are not really contributing to this because they require “pet quality” dogs to be spayed or neutered - if the dog isn’t deemed as furthering the line then they don’t want more litters of pet quality dogs when we already have soooo many and are not in danger of running out any time soon :)</p>
<p>Again, I cannot expect you to accept the truth as I see it. I am just trying to show where I am coming from. I see a lot of what I consider misinformation being perpetrated. This doesn’t help humans or the dogs they get. Unfortunately, although the dogs are lovely, I simply cannot endorse the casual breeding of mixes. This may seem heartless or cruel but I consider the situation as we have now in the US exceptionally heartless and cruel. But we all have to call the stops the way we see them. Like I said I do not want to misrepresent myself, and I do not have material interests per se on one side or the other. I am only sharing my opinion here.</p>