Help me choose between Cornell and UPenn ED! [international, 97% GPA, 1510 SAT, computer science]

Demographics

  • International student
  • State/Location of residency: Canada
  • Type of high school (or current college for transfers): Competitive public school

Cost Constraints / Budget

  • Full pay

Intended Major(s)

  • CS

GPA, Rank, and Test Scores

  • Unweighted HS GPA: 97-98%
  • Class Rank: School doesn’t report
  • ACT/SAT Scores: 1510 but waiting on October results

AP Classes:

  • AP Seminar: 4
  • AP Calculus AB: 5
  • AP CSP: 5
  • AP Chemistry: 5

Grade 12 Coursework:

  • AP Physics 1 & 2
  • AP Calculus BC
  • AP CSA
  • AP Lit
  • AP Lang

Awards

  • 2021: Gauss 8 Award of Distinction, School Honor Roll
  • 2022: Girls Who Code Scholar Certificate, Kode With Klossy Scholar Certificate, USACO Silver, School Honor Roll
  • 2023: Cayley Award of Distinction, Girls Who Code Scholar Certificate, Kode With Klossy Scholar Certificate, Seattle Children’s Hospital Research Training Program Certificate, Canadian Senior Maths Contest Award of Distinction, School Honor Roll
  • 2024: Hypatia Award of Distinction, School Honor Roll, AP Scholar With Honours

Extracurriculars

  • Unpaid finance internship/shadowing at a top bank in Canada (12)
    • Creating reports on investment and estate planning
    • Researching stock market trends
    • Working with clients regarding their retirement goals.
  • Internship at one of the top 3 universities in Canada (11, 12)
    • I work as a full stack developer for one of their labs and write code for the research projects that they conduct.
    • Typically only 3rd year and above students are accepted into the lab, so I’m the only high school student working with them
  • Starting library programs for kids in my city (9, 10, 11, 12)
    • I founded a library program that works with multiple branches and provides free coding classes
    • We’ve reached over 400 kids in the span of 4 years and raised >1k in grants for purchasing equipment for our classes
    • The leading organization for free coding classes in my city
  • Robotics & Coding Instructor (9, 10, 11, 12)
    • I teach students aged 7-16 about Python, Java, and web development (HTML, CSS, and Javascript)
    • Just became the manager of my branch
    • Led every robotics team I’ve led to competing at provincials (so far )
  • Teaching Coding Online (8, 9, 10, 11, 12)
    • Designed different curriculum plans for various learning needs
    • Taught Scratch and contest coding
    • Supported low-income students with free sessions.
  • Working With a Non-Profit to Write Articles (8, 9, 10, 11)
    • Collaborating with different people every week to finish our tasks
    • Managing the website for quality control
    • Meeting weekly to discuss improvements and changes
  • Volunteering At My Dance Studio (12)
    • Danced in K-pop covers gaining 3k+ Youtube views
    • Emceed for 700+ audience members
    • Organized Random Play Dances to promote student registration.
  • Dance, piano, small things

Summer Activities

  • Kode With Klossy
  • Girls Who Code
  • Seattle Children’s Hospital Research Training Program
  • Selected to volunteer with Health Canada
    • Invited along with around 10-20 other students around the country to fly to Ottawa and give feedback on a game being developed by Health Canada for high school students

Essays/LORs/Other
Letters of Recommendation:

9/10 - My teachers like me and for some of the other ones I wrote the letters myself :skull::skull:

Essays:

Common app: 9/10 - I talk about being a model and how it taught to me embrace failure. I think it’s pretty unique and I asked my teachers for feedback and they said they loved it so I hope it goes well.

Supplementals: 8/10 - Probably a bit weaker, but I haven’t worked too hard on them yet

Schools

Okay, so as an international student, I’m considering less about my “dream school” and more about which one has the highest admission rate/future career prospects.

Cornell has a higher admissions chance for women and ED, but CS is definitely competitive and they cut ED % last year. Also, if I decide I want to work in finance in the future I heard that Ithaca isn’t the best place for networking.

Upenn M&T is much harder to get into, but I’m not sure about the ED % since they don’t release that info either. Would I be able to work in finance or SWE if I applied to just the regular engineering school instead of M&T?

  1. UPenn (ED?)
  2. Cornell (ED?)
  3. UMichigan (EA)
  4. UWash (EA)
  5. Cooper Union
  6. Berkeley
  7. UCLA
  8. Princeton
  9. CMU
  10. Stanford
  11. UofT
  12. McGill
  13. Waterloo
  14. UBC

Thank you for reading all of that. Please suggest any other schools and which school I should ED to!

Have you visited both ?

You want urban or suburban with other cities a distance away.

They are distinct from one another. Pick the one best for you.

1 Like

A city would probably be better for me, but I’m concerned about how strong my application will be for a school like Penn compared to Cornell

In the end, you will be somewhere for four years. Don’t game the system and end up in the wrong place.

You can do those two things from any college but they are distinct careers.

Good luck.

If you’re interested in majoring in CS, there shouldn’t be any question - Cornell. It’s CS program is far better than UPenn’s. In fact, UMIch, UWash, Berkeley, UCLA, Princeton, and Stanford all have better CS programs than UPenn.

In fact, honestly, I have no idea what UPenn is even doing on your list. Its CS program is not at the level of the CS programs of any of your USA universities. Maybe Cooper Union (though I don’t know why that colleges is on your list either.

4 Likes

Isn’t cooper union very strong for engineering? They’re starting a cs major this year and it’s predicted to be just as strong i heard.

I’m considering Penn because of the opportunity to do finance along with CS (kind of like a backup). I feel that my programming skills will be good enough for a job in cs no matter the uni, but penn is also really strong for finance which i’m interested in as well.

Cornell on the other hand, while it’s stronger for CS i heard that its location makes finding a job in finance really hard.

What do you think?

Cooper Union is very strong, but it’s very different than the rest of the schools on your list. They’re all large research universities while Cooper Union is a tiny undergraduate only school. If you’re interested in schools that small, Harvey Mudd colleges is a better choice.

As for location, in today’s world, it’s not an issue at all. My kid attended a small rural Liberal Arts College, in New England, did two summer internships at U Chicago, and interviewed, a and got a post-Bac (short term job between undergrad and grad school) at MIT. Students at UIUC have no problems getting internship across the country.

Moreover, Cornell has a very good finance program, as well.

If you’re looking for a reach which is strong in finance and CS, why not MIT?

I don’t think i can get into MIT :sweat_smile: my SAT is too low and i don’t compete in olympiads. Harvey mudd is a good suggestion though i’ll be adding that for sure!

Do you think my application is competitive enough for cornell or penn ED? If it’s a little too weak for Penn i think i’ll ED cornell

What will make finding a job hard for you is that you’re not a US citizen. Your school’s physical location doesn’t matter much, and of course, Cornell is a very well known school.

You have a strong academic profile and ECs. That means you’re a competitive candidate at all these schools.
But unfortunately, there are thousands of other applicants with similarly strong profiles, so chances are unpredictable (especially considering they’re lower than the average for international students). Give them your best shot but be mentally prepared that you may end up having to go elsewhere.

5 Likes

For a computer science major, I was surprised Carnegie Mellon wasn’t on your lengthy list of U.S. reach schools. CMU has arguably one of the strongest, if not the strongest CS programs in this country.

And I agree…for CS, I’m not sure why Penn would be a consideration at all.

My opinion, it’s not easier to get accepted at either Penn or Cornell.

And also, Cornell has excellent job placement in NYC (for example) in finance and banking.

But I think your citizenship could be a barrier in terms of getting jobs here at some finance and banking institutions.

@Catcherinthetoast

3 Likes

What “other ones”? Most colleges here require only two letters of recommendation…one from a math/sciences teacher and one from a humanities teacher.

CMU is on there at #9, my list isn’t ranked in order of how much I want to go to the school.

Penn is likely stronger than Cornell in Canada Id assume, but i’m sure companies know both

1 Like

I have some written by my employers and people I do internships with for the optional rec letter section

I think some of these colleges will accept additional LOR in addition to the two teachers and the counselor recommendation. But there is no guarantee that these will be read and used in the admissions process.

@Mwfan1921

Yes, it definitely varies by college whether they will accept extra LoRs. IME if they do, they will read them.

Cornell is an IB feeder school and generally sends lots of kids into finance careers. In fact, it is third on this list after Penn and NYU (and for Penn that is heavily a Wharton thing):

That said, it would be perfectly reasonable to prefer neither Penn nor Cornell. Like, Michigan is fourth on that list, and I think some people would reasonably prefer it to Cornell. Michigan doesn’t have ED so that would mean not applying anywhere ED, and that is fine. Or I think some people would prefer Princeton, again no ED, but that is also fine. And so on.

But if you love Cornell, and you want to apply ED there, and your only concern is finance placement–I would not worry about that.

But Michigan does have early action…and that’s not binding…but this student isn’t considering that college…

Two very different locations. Cornell is in a small town, mostly just Cornell and Ithaca college there and businesses that serve the colleges. Beautiful gorges, great swimming holes for September. But it is almost always overcast due to lake effect, often rainy. Can be very depressing in the winter. And it’s isolated.

Penn, on the other hand, is in West Philly. While it has a campus, it has a more urban feel. You can walk across a bridge into the central part of the city. Has a lot of big city amenities, like an art museum, a symphony, sports teams, etc. Plus it’s not that hard to get to NYC or DC. But the reality is, most people spend most of their time on campus during college, even at Penn.

Career-wise, you can get the training and the entry connections at either school.

1 Like

I am considering michigan, it’s 4th on my list and i’m applying ea to it haha

I would probably prefer UPenn’s location since I’m from Vancouver and the weather would be a lot more suitable for me.

UPenn is for need-blind for Canadians, but I’m planning to pay in full. Is paying full at Cornell a large boost for an international whereas it’s not considered for Penn? I know some people say that need blind isn’t actually “need blind”.