In your other thread, this had been a compilation of many of the suggestions made, and a later post seemed as though Wheaton, Bard, and New Paltz had struck a chord with your kid. Are those no longer under consideration?
I’d also take a real close look at Ithaca, Muhlenberg, and Sarah Lawrence from that compilation.
One school that wasn’t mentioned above that your kid might want to consider is Drew which is less than an hour from NYC.