<p>Personally I don't think your scores are bad. I can understand that you want to present the best possible scores as OOS admits are most competitive. Since EA generally doesn't have an admissions bump I would recommend if you feel you can expect higher scores from both the SAT and SAT2s retaking both and applying regular decision. Again, there's nothing wrong with either your SATs or your SAT2s, but I wouldn't choose between the two if you want to retest in both just to make an EA deadline. </p>
<p>Best of luck to you.</p>
<p>Edit to add: I just reread your question. As far as how important the SAT2s are...they are requested so you can assume they matter. They are part of a holistic review and one lower score isn't going to kill an otherwise stellar app. What I wouldn't advise is sending only one when they request two (if that's what you were suggesting). I'm sure you'll make a great decision that's right for you.</p>