High School Junior. PA resident, Aspiring Electrical/Mechanical Engineering – Top 20 Public Universities [3.4 UW, 1370 SAT]

Demographics

  • US citizen
  • State/Location of residency: Pennsylvania
  • Type of high school: Public Magnet School (900+ enrollment) - International Baccalaureate (IB)
  • Other special factors: None

Cost Constraints / Budget: $175,000 before aid/scholarship for four years. No need based aid.

Intended Major(s): First choice Mechanical Engineering, second choice Electrical Engineering

GPA, Rank, and Test Scores

  • Unweighted HS GPA: 3.4
  • Weighted HS GPA: 3.8
  • Class Rank: N/A
  • SAT Scores: 1370 (Math: 660, English: 710), planning on doing one more SAT

List your HS coursework

Junior, Class of 2028

  • English: PD World Literature, PD American Literature, IB Language A1 Y1 Lit SL (planning for Y2 as well)
  • Math: PD Algebra II, Geometry (summer before sophomore year), PD Math Analysis, IB Math Y1 HL Analysis and Approaches (planning for Y2 as well)
  • Science: PD Universal Physics, PD Biology, PD Chemistry, IB Physics Y1 SL (planning for Y2 as well)
  • History and social studies: PD Civics and Government, PD US History & the Modern World, IB Psychology HL (planning for Y2 as well)
  • Language other than English: PD French 9, PD French 10, IB Lang French Y1 SL (planning for Y2 as well)
  • Other academic courses (all weighted): Art in the 21st Century I, Health and Wellness I, Engineering Technology, Health and Wellness II, Driver Safety Education, IB Design Technology Y1 HL (planning for Y2 as well), Industrial Robotics/Automation I, Industrial Robotics/Automation II (both in Junior year, plan to continue in Senior year), IB Theory of Knowledge Y1 SL

Awards: High Honor Roll Freshman year

Extracurriculars

  • Technology Student Association Member: Throughout high school (Ongoing)
  • Nonprofit: Secretary - manage meetings and coordinate with other nonprofits as well as organize events, began summer before Sophomore Year (Ongoing)
  • School Club: Executive Member, plan schoolwide events and meetings, began Junior Year (Ongoing)
  • Senior Living Home: Dining Specialist, prepare and serve food, 4hrs Fridays and Sundays, 8hrs Saturdays, $16/hr (Ongoing)
  • 7 Cups: Volunteer Listener, Verifier, Safety Checker, Listener Welcomer beginning late Sophomore Year (Ongoing)
  • LLC: Director of Instruction in a recently created LLC made by students, designing and creating hundreds of courses across all fields of Engineering, as well as managing the creation of courses in other branches, such as Medicine, Human Sciences, Law and Ethics, Sciences, and Languages, began Junior Year (Ongoing)
  • Tutoring: Tutored middle schoolers in freshman year via club at school (Stopped)
  • Kumon: Job, taught children with ages ranging 4-15 among other responsibilities, began late 2024, finished early 2026 (Stopped)
  • Nonprofit: Former Vice President, Secretary, and Publicity Coordinator during Freshman Year (Stopped)
  • Local Ambulance Corps: Volunteered for events and learned BLS Sophomore Year and some of Junior year (Stopped)

Essays/LORs/Other: I have not started those yet.

Schools

Based on her SAT scores, GPA, and our budget, these are the universities where we believe she has a realistic chance of admission.

Extremely Likely:

  • Mississippi State University
  • Missouri University of Science and Technology
  • University of Oklahoma
  • Penn State Behrend

Likely:

  • Iowa State University
  • University at Buffalo
  • Temple University

Toss-up:

  • Penn State University Park
  • University of Minnesota Twin Cities

Lower Probability:

  • Virginia Tech
  • Purdue University
  • North Carolina State University
  • University of Wisconsin–Madison

Low Probability:

  • Georgia Tech
  • University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign
  • University of California, Berkeley
  • UCLA
  • University of Texas at Austin

Are there other schools that she should consider?

Note: The above template was completed jointly by the father and daughter.

Questions from father:

I am considering shifting her focus from now until college applications toward improving her SAT Math score and GPA. Goal is to strengthen her chances of getting into a good engineering-focused university like above, while also maximizing her opportunities for merit-based scholarships.

Currently, she works at a senior living home for 4 hours on Fridays and Sundays and 8 hours on Saturdays, earning $16/hour. This takes up a significant portion of her time.

I am considering having her reduce these work hours and take up a less demanding part-time job that requires only a few hours over the weekend. This would allow her to dedicate more time to a structured daily study plan focused on SAT Math preparation and improving her GPA.

My question is: How much weight do extracurricular activities carry if her SAT Math score and GPA are not competitive enough? At this stage, should we prioritize academics and test scores over extracurricular activities and work experience?

I would appreciate your advice on how best to allocate her time and what priorities we should set between now and college applications.

chance-me
match-me

I would suggest she add University of Alabama to her list.

@tsbna44 can elaborate.

Her job is a good EC, as it is. Most public colleges are less concerned with the hyper-impressive extras, and more so with GPA and scores.

Her in-state publics are going to cost about 45K/yr. It is going to be hard to beat that, out of state, even with merit money. I’d say add UMass Amherst, but I don’t know if they’ll award her enough merit to match her in-state in PA.

4 Likes

Pitt seems worth consideration.

2 Likes

I would drop the “Low Probability” schools. They are very unlikely for acceptance. At least most of them are unlikely for affordability. Being out of state, I am pretty sure that both UC Berkeley and UCLA are hopeless with regard to affordability. These are very good universities, but there is no need to spend about twice your budget to attend either of them.

The “Lower Probability” schools that you have listed will be reaches.

Otherwise I think that you have a good list (I am assuming that these are ABET accredited, but I did not check your full list).

For a potential engineering student, math and physics are likely to be more important compared to most other classes. It would be sensible to put in the effort to try to do as well as possible in these particular classes. In math jumping ahead is rarely a good idea. Learning each step very well is usually a better idea.

I noticed the “I” versus “her” and “she”. Hopefully the student will be writing the essays, and someone else will be writing the letters of reference. For essays, the student should be sincere, and the essays should sound very solidly like they were written by a high school senior.

U.Mass Lowell is another option. My understanding is that U.Mass Lowell tends to usually be more generous with merit aid compared to U.Mass Amherst. However, I agree that in-state public universities might be a better choice, or at least both more economical and easier to get to from a home in Pennsylvania.

4 Likes

In general, extracurriculars distinguish between applicants with similar academic credentials. But they typically will not make the difference for applicants with uncompetitive academic credentials. Being a recruited athlete is most common exception.

4 Likes

On your list, Mississippi State and Iowa State have stated automatic admission criteria on their web sites, so you may want to check the student’s stats against them. But also check if the desired major(s) are more selective than general admission.

But also check cost.

3 Likes

Yes, prioritize academics first and test scores second.

For a potential engineering student, I would not worry at all about a 710 on the English part of the SAT. I would focus a lot more on pulling up a 660 on the math part of the SAT.

ECs are how the very top universities distinguish between a long list of students with essentially perfect GPAs and near perfect test scores. For someone who does not have the academics for the top schools, ECs really are not very important. I think that less focus on ECs and more focus on academics is appropriate.

3 Likes

Is she in the top 25% of her high school class? Freshman Scholarships : TXST One Stop : Texas State University

So - you have $45K or so a year. Does that include travel, etc.? She’s a Junior - so she’ll take the SAT again as you note. Hopefully she can get 1420.

What dos she seek in a school? Does diversity (i.e. a large Asian population matter? City? Rural? etc.

Your extremely likely and likely are all basically assured.

Miss State is up and coming - excellent but 1.7% Asian. Does that matter? It’s roughly at budget full pay but you won’t be full pay. If I’m reading right, it’s a minimum of $12K off with a potential for more if a 1390. So in today’s $ about $34K a year. But does the small Asian population bother? Pricey to fly but can get close (Columbus)

Missouri Science & Tech - I don’t believe an airport nearby. Asian 4%. $18k merit - so it works.

OU is beautiful, 20 mins or so from the OKC airport. 6% Asian. If they take your weighted GPA, you’d get $16.5K a year off so mid 30s. Tons from Texas.

Penn State branch - yeah - full pay.

Iowa State is a yes - it’s right about budget full pay. $9K off and that’s if using unweighted - they may use weighted. 4.2% Asian. Airport isn’t horribly far but not close.

U Buffalo may not work - my guess is it will but they are not upfront on merit. It’s 18% Asian - does that matter (in a positive way)?

Temple - yes

All those you’ll get in.

Penn State - I don’t think so - not for engineering. Worth an app but I would lean against.

UMN - same - yes, into the school for sure - but engineering, my guess is no.

So I ask - what do you want in a school because UMN is smack in a city and 13.4% Asian - and easy transport. Iowa State is not as Asian in population %, not as easy to get to, etc. - just things to think about. UMN shows $60K today but has a $3K engineering surcharge. Would merit get you to affordability - ehhh - possible but unlikely.

Lower prob -

Va Tech - you don’t get to cost so for that reason alone not. And I think no admit but you never know.

Purdue - put in the low probability - but why not? It’s in budget.

NC State - you can’t afford

U Wisconsin - you can’t afford

Ga Tech you can’t afford

UIUC - you can’t afford

UCB - you can’t afford

So I don’t think you get into Penn State and below - but forgetting them, most of them you don’t have a path to get to where you want financially. Purdue and maybe others have a 2nd level of admission so your major may not be assured.

I’d like to know more about what your student wants - Missouri Science and Tech is great - but very different than Temple.

One thing about engineering - where you go, for the most part, doesn’t matter.

I can tell you schools that will hit your cost:

Bama was mentioned - 1.5% Asian, arguably the nicest engineering facilities in the country (my son has been to many and thinks so) - not easy to get to. If they take weighted GPA (they don’t say), your daughter right now would be high 20s and go lower if gets a 1420 SAT.

UAH - a smaller school, very well thought of and near an airport…full cost is under your budget. It’s $9K students , 4% Aisian. Surrounded by aero/defense companies who hire from there. It’s in Rocket City. Will crush your budget after merit.

I would re-start your search. We know your budget is $45K or so a year - assuming you don’t plan to cash flow more.

What does she seek - weather, size, Asian diversity, airport access, religion, sports, size, environment (urban, rural, suburban) and go from there.

There are many publics that will work - from Kansas and K State - to TCNJ to likely Maine to C or W Michigan - to really many.

I would not worry about ECs - she’s got far too many and many schools that you’re looking at don’t even look at them (hello Penn State) - but she’s fine for those that do.

I would just do what you are doing - and not put pressure on her. Not take away her work hours if she enjoys them and is doing well in school. It’s great she balances all.

In engineering - where you go short of a few schools doesn’t matter.

Example of three:

  1. Va Tech - they don’t have enough EE grads reporting but EE and Mech E combined earn $78,261. They don’t show a knowledge rate (what % report) . 17% were still seeking - this is likely 6 months after graduation.

  2. Purdue - electrical is $83.1K. Mechanical - $80.6K. Not sure the knowledge rate or % seeking.

  3. Alabama - has the best career page. For EE, $82.7K with a 92% knowledge rate and only 3% still seeking. For MechE, $78.7k, 91% knowledge rate and 5% still seeking.

Where you go - short of an MIT type, likely won’t matter.

So slow down with the pressure - because UMN or Miss State, Iowa State or Penn State - not a huge deal.

So tell us what she wants - and then let’s find schools to meet it - vs. picking off a list from a magazine, etc.

Have you visited any schools - if not, she’s a Junior - I don’t care about the names - get her to large, mid and small - to urban, suburban and rural.

And salaries are typically based on the where - not the school.

She will be somewhere four years day after day - so let’s make sure she’s comfortable. Engineering is brutally tough - 50% don’t finish - so if that might be her, then make sure a school has other majors of interest too. For example, my Bama kid turned down Purdue and he graduated fortunately - but Purdue has his 2nd love major (where Bama didn’t - Atmospheric Science). On the flip side, Bama had his own dorm room (why he went) vs.. Purdue which would have tripled him. That was 7 years ago so may be different today but - find out what she wants - so that’s another good thing - is a dorm capacity (single, double, triple - or hall bath vs. in room bath - does it matter, etc?

In summary:

Bottom line - let her do activities she enjoys but don’t overdo it as applications take time.

If she’s doing fine in school, no reason to stress her up or reallocate her time.

And since she’s taking the SAT - maybe get her prep for a higher score - but no pressure - lots of schools will meet budget as is - but some might get cheaper.

But let her enjoy being a Junior and Senior - but if you haven’t, do get her out on some visits to experience schools - go to info sessions, on tours. Walk campuses. Stop students and talk to them. Eat in the dining hall. Walk the surrounds. Even for schools near home.

But I don’t think an overarching strategy is needed here at all.

Finding an environment of comfort, that’s within budget, should be the focus.

Thanks

1 Like

1 Like

If she likes her job and the $$$, I wouldn’t mess with it. Long term jobs are looked on favorably by AO’s. Especially those working in that type of setting. And my guess is they probably treat her pretty well there.

The good news is there are tons of schools she can get into. I would drop the focus on T20. ABET certified and a place that she will thrive should be your focus. There is a big difference between showing up everyday to get through engineering and actually thriving (whether she changes majors or not).

Where do you think she “thrives”? What kind of setting? What is her wish list in a school?

4 Likes

I don’t think it will work with the budget. Oops, in state.

1 Like

What have her math and science grades been in high school?

  • What kind of test prep was done before the first SAT?
  • How likely is it that the D will follow a structured daily study plan?
  • How would not working at the PT job impact the D (i.e. is it something that brings her joy, fulfillment, a social network away from school, etc, or is it just the $$$)?
1 Like

The student is in state so it will hit $$- if interested. Not a safety but worthy of consideration.

They have a PSU campus already but Slippery Rock and Shippensburg would deliver too.

Not sure if OP has interests - like a Formula SAE team.

WVU would also crush budget for OP but in the end, there are schools of varying sizes and environments that might work - from a Clarkson size and ruralness on up.

So I hope they develop a ‘desires’ list vs just where can I get in that I can afford - which is many places.

1 Like

This was an immediate concern when I read through this.

My concern is that she should be the one driving all these questions and decisions. If she’s intending to major in engineering of any kind, she’d better be fiercely independent and know how to position herself for internships.

She is the one going to school, so she is the one that should have been filling out this template. Unless you’re planning on moving with her and deciding her schedule. Did your daughter choose her intended major, or are you choosing it for her?

My children would have brought out the riot gear if I had been this involved in their lives.
I have two kids who majored in engineering and are successfully working in their fields, and a third daughter who is a graduate of medical school and is working for big Pharma.
They ran their academic lives and we helped when they asked for help.

We met with all three kids and said “We have a budget for college for all of you. This is what it is in your 529 total. If you apply to any school that is over that amount, we can’t afford it. You won’t be able to go if admitted.” All they asked us for was the checks for tests and application fees. They applied and did everything on their own, with help from their teachers and counselors. They asked us questions about our college experiences, but other than that they did everything on their own.

All three were strong athletes, and held part-time jobs while maintaining 4.0 GPA’s. They also were very disciplined about how they studied and their homework schedules.

Also, engineering is a really difficult discipline. The students get to their colleges, intending to major in engineering, and they drop out like flies.

Our eldest daughter attended the University of Buffalo, intending to major in pre med studies. She changed majors to electrical engineering and computer software engineering where she constantly had to advocate for herself because she was one of a handful of females in the department, with a lot of young men who didn’t think engineering could be understood by females.

The common link between our three kids is that they were all naturally strong in math.
They were almost equally strong in their English and literature skills.

For any kind of engineering field you need confidence in your math and English skills because there is a lot of calculation involved along with a lot of contractual language requiring interpretation.

Just remember, if you push too hard, it can backfire. If she’s going into engineering, she needs to be able to make her own decisions. If math isn’t her strength, then maybe engineering isn’t the right major for her.

1 Like

Thank you for the response.

My daughter will be writing the essay. We prepared the template together, so you may see references to both “I” and “she” in certain sections.