High School Standards: How much excellence is TOO excellent?

<p>I go to an extremely competitive school, as I’m sure many CC’ers can relate to!
The standards for “excellence” are so high across the board. Be it academics, sports, theatre, orchestra, you name it, the competition is fierce for any sort of recognition. </p>

<p>In some ways, I feel proud to be from a school that can boast about being the best in the state in a plethora of categories. However, quite frankly, I also feel deprived of the quintessential “high school experience.” </p>

<p>I am an above average, amateur actress, and I would be lucky to get the role of Extra #5 in the school play. I’m a decent swimmer, but I do not meet the standards of our award-winning swim team. I can sing well (objectively), but have been rejected for numerous school “talent shows” because there were too many good acts to include. </p>

<p>Basically, if you aren’t on track to be an NBA superstar, the next George Clooney, the next academic prodigy, etc, etc, you cannot expect many opportunities. If you don’t come in an expert at whatever, you don’t get the chance to participate. </p>

<p>I pose the following question:
How much excellence is TOO excellent? </p>

<p>And furthermore, at what point does prestige get in the way of an enriching high school experience, in which you hopefully grow as a person? </p>

<p>Would love to hear other CC’ers experiences with the ultra-competition that goes on in today’s American high schools.</p>

<p>Lol. Wow this is a very conceited post. “How much excellence is TOO excellent?” Arre you serious? Stop complaining. You go to a lovely high school. Go watch Waiting for Superman. Most kids would kill for what you have.</p>

<p>That is exactly how my high school was. All of the sports teams and theatre productions cut, even the Science Olympiad team cut a very significant number of people. I really resented the school for a while because it was so stressful to go there and I felt I really missed out on having a real high school experience. However, one thing that I did learn was that nothing comes easy in life and that if you really want something you have to be able to not only work hard but be willing to take risks and reinvent your purpose when it seems like you can’t go further. You can’t let others shut you down, if you really want something bad enough and you are willing to do whatever it takes you will eventually find success. I go to an ivy league school now but when I was in high school I didn’t feel like I was on top of the world like in the experience some of my peers had, I never felt like I was good enough. I feel like my professors have so much more faith in me than most of my high school teachers ever did, so in college I have learned to relax a little and to let things come more naturally.</p>

<p>@sen12or</p>

<p>I agree, your post came off as conceited, and selfish. Sorry, but even if you didn’t intend it to be, you could have written it in a better way, rather then act like a elitist because you go to a named high school in your state.</p>

<p>@Sen12or and @nothingto:</p>

<p>I am not being an elitist whatsoever, lol. Not sure why you would perceive it that way. What I am saying is the reality where I go to school, and in many other schools across the nation, and I earnestly feel it is becoming a problem. It is not specific to my high school, and I am in no way suggesting I am better than anyone else because I am in attendance of a good public school, lol. </p>

<p>My point is that within a lot of school districts, the pressure to maintain “competitive” academic and extracurricular programs has become so intense that only a fraction of the students are getting involved in said programs when a far greater amount would LIKE to, but have been rejected. It causes a huge percent of my school’s population to feel like they are not “good enough” at anything, which is not good for morale. It leaves many students struggling to find their place in a high school environment.</p>

<p>@Poeme</p>

<p>Glad you can relate! And I agree about learning to work hard to achieve things. I’m looking forward to college where I can hopefully get more immersed in the academic environment. :)</p>

<p>Stop complaining.</p>

<p>@sen12or:</p>

<p>I’m not complaining. I’m just bringing up an issue that seems to be a problem at my school, and others in my area. If you can’t relate, why post?</p>

<p>Bc I feel like.</p>

<p>So the argument is</p>

<p>1) other people have worse schools
2) therefore, OP has no right to complain about her school</p>

<p>Then say someone goes to a school that is worse than OP’s school, but not the worst school. Some kids have it worse than that person, right? So that person cannot complain! If you keep using that line of logic, you aren’t allowed to complain about your school unless your school is the worst school. And in that case, maybe you still can’t complain because many people don’t even have the opportunity to go to school - a “bad” school is better than no school. So there is no point in complaining about your school no matter how good or bad it is.</p>

<p>Something doesn’t seem right about that.</p>

<p>Almost all (if not all) schools have their problems. What happens if your skills are above average in a competitive school? If space is limited, then you may be barred from opportunities because too many other people are simply more skilled than you are. What then? Even though students in less competitive schools do have many problems, it’s not fair to completely dismiss this issue based on that. (OP, maybe “today’s American high schools” was a little too broad, though.)</p>

<p>Ways to tackle this:</p>

<p>1) Focus on one or two activities and train so that you can stand out in those activities. Ask for advice from the people who are really good and find out how they became experts. After all, almost nobody is born a natural genius in <insert activity=“” here=“”> - most people have to practice in order to become better.</insert></p>

<p>2) Go out of your way (out of your school if you need to) to find opportunities related to your activities. Start something up with other people in your school or community at about the same level of ability as you are.</p>

<p>As for morale, our school is supposed to be one of the best high schools in the nation, but the talent is mostly concentrated in math and science (where almost all of my interests are, sadly). There are a lot of niche clubs for whatever interest you might have (guitar, anime, fashion, you name it), so most people don’t really feel that they are kept away from opportunities. Many people are just satisfied by hanging out with their friends, playing video games or shopping or whatever. So does your school not work this way? Are most people interested in pretty much the same activities? (Yeah, I am kind of clueless here.)</p>

<p>Well I definitely agree that it could have been much, much worse. This school did provide me with a great education (although the reason it was so great was that I was in higher level classes in a very stratified level system) which most people don’t have in high school. </p>

<p>My problem with the school is that the administration is more concerned about their image than the students. They represent the school as something it is not. Even though there are tons of great opportunities at the school, they are not available to most students because it is so large and competitive. Hard work and dedication (and even potential) doesn’t matter to them, unless you are a top athlete you can’t get on most of the sports teams. I’ve heard many stories of freshmen who worked incredibly hard all summer to make a team only to get cut before they even arrived at high school! Later on many juniors are cut from their sport to make space for freshman whose skills they deem good enough for junior varsity even though they have never seen them on the team.</p>

<p>All of this competition added a ton of stress to the student body. It was not a nice environment to go to school in at all. This is even after I had the better teachers, I have heard pretty bad things about the teaching in the lower levels where you truly need good teachers. A lot of kids get lost in the cracks and turn to drugs. No doubt it would have been another magnitude worse to go to an inner city public school with nothing. But his school was pretty irritating in that it does not provide what it promises.</p>

<p>I sincerely doubt that your school is THAT competitive. Several of my childhood friends from when I lived in Northern Virginia ended up at TJHSST, and even TJ doesn’t sound that competitive.</p>

<p>Is the school private or public? Just curious.</p>

<p>Lol. Wow this is a very conceited post. “How much excellence is TOO excellent?” Arre you serious? Stop complaining. You go to a lovely high school. Go watch Waiting for Superman. Most kids would kill for what you have.</p>

<p>^this</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Seems like you’re trying to do a lot at once. Maybe if you focused your strengths in a specific area and didn’t try to do everything at once, you’d have a less stressful high school experience. Also, you’d probably be better at what you’re doing.</p>

<p>You could also try competing with people outside of school through open competitions. If your school is really that competitive you should do fine in the AMCs, Physics Olympiad, etc. Most of the people on the top lists seem to come from the same few schools. Also, you should get good AP scores.</p>

<p>When I was in high school all I did was math team and some olympiads and I got into a top 10 college. I was stressed in high school, but that was because I took a lot of hard classes. If I had done as many extracurriculars as you’re doing, I probably would have had a breakdown.</p>

<p>You could always try to start a new club and with the club, organize a local event or something similar. Of course, you could just work by yourself (ie. code, conduct research, volunteer, etc)</p>

<p>P.S. You are not conceited just because you go to a good high school and aren’t as good as some of the other students. When you go to a good college others will understand your attitude since 80% of them will be in the same boat.</p>

<p>@Wiscongene:
Large public with 3500+ students.
Academic Decathlon takes the top 3 students out of nearly a thousand in a grade (in which about 100 well-qualified students will apply). You can imagine how crazy trial season for Decathlon gets! </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Exactly, Poeme, could not have said it better myself!</p>

<p>@energize
Good advice!
I have actually started a club for env. science at my school, which I really enjoy organizing. We have a strict “Everyone who wants in, gets in” policy, and if you can think of a leadership position that would benefit the club that we don’t have, you’re hired! :)</p>

<p>@Apathetic11
It’s more of a well-rounded sort of competition. They have a huge student body, so they can easily find people who are fantastic at anything (be it sports, fine arts, etc) which makes it hard for students who are just decent at a few things to get a chance. And that repetitive rejection can really lower people’s self-esteem and cause them to give up all together. </p>

<p>@nomber
Oh these are just a few examples from over the years, not from one single period of time. That would drive me crazy as well! Haha. I usually go out of school for extracurricular activities, it’s just gotten to be too stressful.
And congrats on getting into a top 10 college, that is truly great!</p>

<p>I understand that if one goes to such a high school as described on this thread that one should be very grateful for the opportunities provided at such a school. However, I think the point of this thread is that at many competitive high schools, these opportunities are actually very deceiving as they are in reality not available to most students. While I do think I received a great education from my particular high school, I think I would have been much happier at a smaller and less competitive school, even though I did end up thriving where I was. There is always plenty of time for competition in college but I can’t get back those years in high school in which I spent every weekend alone studying for something that now seems very trivial. However, I know that if I did not put that time in at my high school, I would not have gotten to where I was, someone else would have easily filled my place.</p>

<p>While I am truly aware that many people had it a million times worse than I did, when my college classmates talk about their high school experience it can still be very painful to listen to. But nevertheless, I do think that my experience will eventually help in the long run since I became very resilient academically, so in that sense it was all worth it.</p>

<p>I noticed someone mentioned Thomas Jefferson high school. While this is also an absolutely amazing school, from the people I’ve talked to (I know or have met approximately 3 or 4 kids from that school), I think it’s a much different experience than what this thread is focused on. While Thomas Jefferson is incredible schools with incredibly intelligent students, the people who go there absolutely love it. The same cannot be said of the competitive large public schools. This is most likely due to the size. Thomas Jefferson is less than half the size of my school so it makes sense that students feel closer to the school.</p>

<p>Hmm…This is purely anecdotal, but it seems to me that public schools are usually the ones where students end up like you describe. The administration spreads itself too thin and the middle 50% lose out. Private schools seem much more focused on the individual.</p>

<p>Now, I go to a private school but I’m not biased. In fact, my school is on the opposite side of the spectrum. It’s barely competitive at all. We’ve got ~100 students per class and last year’s highest ACT score was a 32. The valedictorian had a 26. Lol</p>

<p>I actually wish my school was more like your’s.</p>