How do I let my parents know it's time to let go?

<p>N.B. I’ve taken some license with the details for privacy, but all the key points are in.</p>

<p>Warning: Long, upset post.</p>

<p>Hi wise parents of CC, I normally post under a different name but had to create a new account to let off some steam pseudo-anonymously. I’ve been thinking about posting this thread for a long time, and I guess it’s gotten too much for me. I’m a rising college freshman, and have been feeling very frustrated with my parents and family this summer.</p>

<p>We’re solidly middle-class, own our own home and do not have much debt. I’ve always had a roof over my head and food on the table. My parents grew up working-class and received vocational educations, and I recognize it’s not easy for them to have reached the standard of living we have now. In that respect, I can’t complain. I know many, many people are much less fortunate than me.</p>

<p>Unfortunately, my relationship with my parents has always been defined by apathy and a lack of emotional connection. My parents have never been huge influences on me. Our beliefs and values are very different, and we’ll leave it at that.</p>

<p>When I began looking at colleges, I was told that if I intended to attend any college with a higher COA than the state flagship, I would have to find merit money to cover the full COA. I told them I understood, but I didn’t want to attend State U because it was a poor academic and social fit. On top of that, I have a very specific career goal, and State U couldn’t have helped me advance towards it. Instead, I chose to work for a while in my intended field after HS instead while weighing my college options. </p>

<p>To me, this made sense because unlike starting school at State U immediately, I could see a clear progression toward that career goal and I could build up a track record that would increase my chances of a full ride at a much better school when I did apply. I had contacts in the field who could help me find opportunities to gain meaningful working experience. What they saw, of course, was stubbornness, wilful defiance, immature decision-making, and callous disregard of the opportunity to go to college, which neither of them had. They were convinced that I would fail to secure a full ride somewhere better than State U and I would eventually attend State U, tail between legs and at least a couple of years behind my college-aged peers who started school on time.</p>

<p>During this time, my friends and teachers remained very supportive, giving me the encouragement and advice I so desperately needed. I’ve gone to them, ghost-faced with fear of the future, broken down crying from stress, doubted, contemplated giving up or giving in, and they were always there. Sometimes they gave advice that I didn’t want but needed to hear. Every step of the way, they were with me and for me, I owe them so much.</p>

<p>During this same time, what I heard from my parents included “you’re never going to make it”, “your hope is useless”, “relatives are asking me if it’s because you went to Magnet School With Teachers Who Encouraged Your Ambition that you turned out like this”, “it’s not going to happen”, “stop wasting your time”. So often, after those depressing little chats, I’d go to my room, look the door and stick my head under my pillow and just be so paralyzed. I hated being at home. I avoided my parents as much as I could. I took great pains to avoid them. I know it didn’t help our relationship, but put yourself in my shoes… those words hurt, and they hurt bad. I knew the path I chose for myself to college would be difficult, and my own faith was hanging by a thin, thin thread. They didn’t need to rub it in. I couldn’t hear those words. I couldn’t afford to.</p>

<p>We fly out to my dream college tomorrow, where I have a full ride.</p>

<p>The last three months have been frustrating, so frustrating at home. Suddenly my parents are more excited for college than I am. I understand that it’s a huge relief for them, too, but I resent this deeply. From the beginning, my college search has been my project, and I did my own research and coordinated my own apps. During this time I became almost although not completely financially independent. I was working a job I loved and would probably have pursued further if college hadn’t worked out. I cooked and ate my own meals, bought my own groceries, paid for my own transport. I grew up in every way. I became a legal adult. I felt like an independent adult! Now that all is well with the world again, they’re the ones behaving like excited college kids, buying college things for me that I don’t need, doing college research I’ve already done and telling me all about it, reminding me of things to do I’m already on top of.</p>

<p>They’re treating me like the kid I would have been if I were entering college out of HS, not like a young adult who’s held working responsibilities rarely accorded to those my age. There is so much going on here emotionally I can’t wrap my mind around it, but I know I’m frustrated, even a little angry, and feel like they don’t have a right to be this excited or this concerned when they so actively discouraged me from this very path that turned out to have a huge reward. I was effectively told to do this alone. I pulled it off alone. I was looking forward to moving on alone, or with the people who were there for me and who believed in me throughout.</p>

<p>I know, I know… we’ve never been emotionally close, so the parent-child relationship has always been defined by the parent providing and the child being provided for. For a long time they felt they couldn’t provide for me to go to the college I wanted, and now they can feel like they’re providers and therefore parents again. Blah blah blah… all I know is that that ship has sailed for them, and with the full ride, there is a good chance I will become financially independent while still in college. About time, too, since I’m already over 21. I don’t know if they understand that my moving in to college is as good as moving out of home and they need to treat it as such. I think they might be afraid that without the financial umbilical cord, there will be nothing tethering me to home, and they’re trying to establish some sort of relationship before that happens, but I can’t convince myself that’s definitely possible any more (see the things that were said above).</p>

<p>The only reasons I’ve waited this long to post this are a. there’s a lot of guilt involved. I know I gave my parents a very hard time with my decisions, and I don’t want to make them seem like the bad guys. But how else would you have played the hand I was dealt?
b. Our disagreements started many years before the college search, and generally follow this pattern: You don’t know what’s best for you, so trust us, we will put you on the right path and you will be grateful for it many years from today. Alternatively: you don’t know how much we’ve done for you, you owe it to us to be grateful. I figure I’ve put up with this dysfunctional relationship for so long. There’s no need to make things difficult now when the light at the end of the tunnel is this close. But if so, I need to make sure this really is a light, and they’re not trying to be helpful so they can use it as a “you ought to be grateful” weapon later.
c. As move-in day approaches, it’s getting worse! Have you packed this, have you packed that, have you done this, have you done that, do you need me to buy xyzabc for you??? Why do you want to buy it yourself? Are you sure?!</p>

<p>ARGH! Parents, help! I don’t want to cut them off, but I need to draw the line and say, this is my new life, one I wrought for myself, and you need to let me live it on my own. Or, since move-in day is so near, I guess maybe what I was looking for wasn’t advice, but just a chance to vent and let the bitterness go. Thanks for reading. Sigh.</p>

<p>All of this will be much better once you get to the new college (I assume that you won’t be living at home any more). Until then, just grit your teeth and “smile and nod.” After a while, you will be enjoying your new experiences, and you will find that you are big enough to forgive your parents.</p>

<p>Do not pay attention, they love you, love them back.</p>

<p>I understand how the nagging and checking and rechecking whether or not you’ve taken care of business could be annoying in light of your independent and take charge persona. This will soon be history, however. I agree with above that just nodding and reassuring them that you’ve got it covered would be the best tactic to take.</p>

<p>But you’re annoyed that they are now excited for you. Would you be upset if they were still complaining about your choice to attend this dream school? How would you like them to act? It seems in this one area, they can’t win no matter how they react. You can choose to be critical here, or accept their pride and congratulations-you certainly deserve to be stroked for all your accomplishments. I do get that these warm sentiments are long overdue. Better late than never, though, in my humble opinion.</p>

<p>You’ve worked long and hard to get to this point. Let go of the hurt and recriminations if you can and enjoy these next years of your life. You should be very proud of yourself. And really, a strong sense of pride in oneself, true self respect, and feelings of personal accomplishment are far better foundations of personal happiness than accolades from others can ever be.</p>

<p>I hope you will post an update at the end of the semester to let us know how you are doing. Sincere congratulations on your impressive accomplishments!</p>

<p>Congratulations on landing a full ride to your dream school! </p>

<p>I don’t think you can change anything about your parents behavior before you depart. They’re trying to “help” and repair any damage from their criticism. Sure, it’s probably too little too late, so just try to grin and bear it until you’re gone. </p>

<p>Have you considered what kind of communication you’ll have with your parents when you go away? I’d recommend figuring out how much (or how little) you want and discussing it with them in advance. Text, phone calls, email, skype, facebook. Reach an agreement now so you can prevent major drama later. </p>

<p>In the meantime, good luck. Maybe after moving away and getting a little “cooling off” time, you’ll be able to establish a peaceful, healthy relationship with your parents.</p>

<p>I am old enough to be an empty nester and my mother still does the kind of things you are describing. Don’t add stress to your life by reading too much into their actions. As others have said, when you have some distance this won’t bother you as much. The best advice I ever received was “choose your battles” – this isn’t worth fighting.</p>

<p>Congratulations on doing so well!</p>

<p>I am over 50, and my mother is over 80, and she still does some of those things. I try to take her advise “under advisement” and refrain from arguing with her (usually).</p>

<p>Two things are going on.</p>

<p>The first is a really valid complaint - I call it the Little Red Hen situation. As in the fable, someone (you) does all the work and at the last minutes someone else swoops in and tries to make all the work partly his/hers. I HATE this. In my opinion it is a form of emotional theft and disregards all the hard work the “Little Red Hen” did. </p>

<p>However, you can gain some solace that the other people around this situation are actually pretty smart and no matter how often the person jumping on the train at the last minute tries to make it his/her thing, most people know the truth. (Although it is really nice for someone to tell you that they see this too. Ask someone in your extended circle - have them validate your take on things - and move on.)</p>

<p>The second thing you are resenting - the excessive hovering and questioning - has nothing to do with you. It is your parents trying to channel their anxiety. Just tune it out. Smile and nod. If they press something on you take it and “forget” to pack it or give it away to someone at school. Lose it at the airport. Whatever. </p>

<p>And most of all CONGRATULATIONS!!! Have a wonderful year.</p>

<p>Their fussing and checking is their way of coming to terms with your departure and their last chance to “be involved” in this decision. It comes from love so just smile and nod. You got this far and it sounds like your patience is wearing thin…but keep your eye on the prize. Congratulations on your enormous success. remember…smile and nod, smile and nod.</p>

<p>^ha …smile and nod cross post!</p>

<p>Congrats on all you’ve done, but please remember that in their own ways, your folks do love you. Keep the door open as we never know what the future holds. As everyone has said, the “mother hen” thing is one way that folks show that they love us (even tho it can be annoying as heck and counter-productive). Smiling & nodding is a good strategy. Also, remmber to let those who HAVE supported you through your challenges know that you love them as well. You will go far but keeping your humanity is important.</p>

<p>Thanks, parents. I guess I just needed to get all the negativity out of my system… I feel much better already. I know all that’s been said is true, that the distance will do a lot of good, and “smile and nod” is exactly what I’ve been telling myself to do in the meantime, but it can be difficult nonetheless. Inhale, exhale, breathe in, breathe out, smile and nod, smile and nod…</p>

<p>I also agree this is a lose-lose for my parents, especially at this stage. This summer I’ve reflected on my relationship with my parents, and wondered if things could have turned out differently. As different as our value systems are, I recognize that within the context of their own experiences and backgrounds, they did what they thought was best with the information they had. The conclusion I reached was that in order for anything to have turned out differently, they would have had to have been different people. That’s too much to ask of anyone. So I’ll learn to make do.</p>

<p>You are an adult. You have a free ride to your dream school. You should be proud.</p>

<p>Maybe your parents didn’t do such a bad job after all…:wink: I am sure that many would love to be in your shoes.</p>

<p>Given that you have a free ride to your dream school, your parents do not have leverage over you in your relationship with them. Therefore, you are free to cut that relationship entirely.</p>

<p>I imagine, however, this is not what you want to do.</p>

<p>This is, on the other hand, an opportunity to redefine your relationship with your parents. You have the standing to tell them that their previous treatment of you was hurtful, emotionally cruel, and is entirely unacceptable. That damage cannot be undone by suddenly deciding to play nice. You have demonstrated the ability to succeed magnificently with your own devices, and you expect them to treat you with the respect and responsibility you have demonstrated that you deserve. Their advice is welcome, their mean-spirited criticism is not. They are to treat you like an adult. In return, you will do your part in working towards a better relationship with them. If both you and your parents choose to accept this, you can all look forward to a good-spirited and mutually caring relationship. If they refuse to do this, however, you tell them that they can expect far less involvement in your life than they would otherwise want and a very detached relationship.</p>

<p>Alias - Read the “Wow-I suck” thread. Parents usually do the best they can with what we know. Our goal is to raise independent, self-sufficient kids who contribute positively to society. I sounds like your parents did that. Maybe it was despite them. But, I suspect they did a better job than you think.</p>

<p>

I know my kid has done this to me a few times and it actually makes me smile because I know she’s perfectly competent to handle whatever it was on her own but sometimes as a parent you just want to make sure you give the advice anyway, whether it’s needed or not (other times I exercise more forethought and refrain from giving the advice I know she doesn’t really need). </p>

<p>

These are things a parent should never say to their kid so I understand your frustration and anger. Not everyone follows a cookie cutter path and your path was out of the norm but perfectly legitimate and well thought out and the results show that. Even though in your mind you could envision this path you followed, your parents just couldn’t envision it or understand it. However, they now can see that in fact, the path worked out well for you whether they realize now that they were wrong or if they just think you somehow got lucky despite the path you took. Regardless, they now get to do the vicarious college experience many of us do that they were looking forward to in the past before you went down your different path. In their mind the ‘off to college’ time is simply delayed but nevertheless, they want to enjoy it as they would have if it happened right away.</p>

<p>IMO you should just go ahead and do a bit of the ‘smile and nod’, let them have their fun with the parental college experience, and take comfort in the fact that very shortly you’ll be out of there and on your own. In exhibiting the behavior your parents did they unfortunately put a wedge in the relationship that may or may not ever be fully extracted but they were probably trying to do what they thought was best for you, i.e. trying to intimidate you into following the path they had planned for you, rightly or wrongly. It’ll now be up to you to decide how much animousity you want to harbor against them for this or if you want to rise above that, above their level even, and understand that they had your best interests at heart and just didn’t know how to handle the uniqeness of your situation, and try to salvage the relationship. After some months away at college this situation will no longer be at the top of your mind so it’ll be easier to re-assess the relationship then and you can be the one to take the lead to make it better.</p>

<p>Good luck and congrats on your successes.</p>

<p>Alias,</p>

<p>I think some of the things that your parents have said to you over the years have been hurtful and damaging and those words define this situation. I have no idea if your parents actually felt this way or if they were trying to make you think they did in order to manipulate you into a different choice. As parents, we have dreams for our children too. Of course they are not really our dreams to dictate, but they are there nonetheless. Your parents probably dreamed during their lives that they would produce, against all odds, a college graduate. From what you have posted, it seems that despite their level of education, they valued the fact that they wanted to provide that for you. When the opportunity arose for you to attend college (and to them it did not matter where you attended, just that when you attended it would have been the start of their dream) you made the decision to not do that right away. I suspect inside they were probably crushed, confused and frustrated. Here they have an intellegent, self assured daughter; yet, they are not getting the desired result. Of course in your mind and heart, you had a plan. You did not want to settle. But they had one too and in their minds, their plan had already failed, therefore they could not put stock in your plan because they were not prepared to fail again. Fast forward and their plan and dream is now coming true, just as yours is too. To them it does not matter how it happened. I suspect in their eyes, the 3 year delay was not necessary and despite that delay, they are finally able to participate in the long lost dream. So now you have two sides to a dream. Your dream has always been a work in progress. Their dream (again, in their minds) was on a delay, and frankly, they probably believed it may never come to fruition. I believe that is where their excitment probably comes from. I don’t see it as them stealing your thunder, but I suspect they feel you stole theirs 3 years ago when you rejected State U. </p>

<p>In no way am I saying the way your parents went about this was correct. But do understand where they could possibly be coming from. Also, you are a lovely writer. I hope for you a wonderful future, a loving relationship with your parents, (despite your differences in life) and completely FABULOUS college experience. You deserve it. You’ve earned it…now enjoy it.</p>

<p>Many of the parents’ responses seem to be framed from an American parenting perspective. This may or may not be appropriate to the OP’s situation. Believe it or not, American parenting values such as unconditional support and pride are not universal.</p>

<p>Again, this may be the case with OP, it may not.</p>

<p>^^ Our responses will obviously be influenced by our own perspective - whatever that may be. The OP came here asking for perspectives knowing, I assume, that there’s a broad background of parents here.</p>

<p>I don’t know what you mean by Believe it or not, American parenting values such as unconditional support and pride are not universal. Why would you distinguish ‘American’ versus anything else? That seems broad to me.</p>

<p>I’m reading, and taking it all in. Thanks y’all, so much. It makes a huge difference being able to unload all of this and know that there’s a group of parents to listen and to offer support, advice, or simply a perspective that I don’t have.</p>

<p>IBfootballer does have the right idea. My parents did not grow up in America, and I am perhaps more American than they would like. Like I said, there’s a lot going on here emotionally.</p>

<p>Working class immigrants with a centered, driven, strong willed, intelligent American kid. That’s a huge leap for any generation. I’ll bet there is a lot going on emotionally. Hang in there.</p>