How has the president done in his first year of office?

<p>

Difficult to say. Given my belief that the fetus is a human being, the most logical punishment for illegal abortions would be something analogous to infanticide; the crimes are relatively similar. However, the severity of infanticide’s sentencing (it’s a form of manslaughter) is perhaps a bit too extreme here. I do believe, however, that such a crime ought to be a felony with an average sentence running multiple years (but probably less than 10). Although the victim here - the unborn child - can be readily dehumanized by the nature of pregnancy, killing another human being under any circumstance is a grave crime.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Why are the heads of women “wiser” in this scenario? As a male, am I forbidden from making a determination that the fetus constitutes a human being and that abortion constitutes the taking of human life? Presupposing those, my system of morals will not allow me to stand aside.</p>

<p>“You’re a male so you’ll never be pregnant. Shouldn’t you let the wiser heads settle that question, as well? I’m fine (theoretically) with women who are pro-life. I am absolutely not fine with men who are pro-life. I don’t take a stance on, say, circumcision.”</p>

<p>I’m not getting into this argument here (mostly because I don’t care enough about abortion to bother to argue about it) but you fail at sounding reasonable. Implying that everyone who disagrees with you is just dumb rarely works.</p>

<p>@Applicannot: To me that seems equivalent to “You don’t live in Russia so why should you care if atrocities happen there?” Why don’t you take a stance on circumcision? If you thought it was cruel or wrong, wouldn’t you say so? It’s true that as a male I’ll never know whether the inconveniences of childbearing are so bad that they would justify killing another human. But I don’t think I’m any less capable of determining whether and abortion would be killing another human. The point I’m trying to prove is that killing an embryo is killing a human. Others can decide when and if it is justifiable.</p>

<p>^^Applicannot has been fairly reasonable so far. The objection she raised is a fair objection, but to the wrong issue.</p>

<p>Applicannot, I’m surprised at your reasoning. You’re normally very reasonable. </p>

<p>I do NOT agree that as a male, we should have no opinion on this issue. I’m pro-choice but I think people are allowed to have their own opinions on any issue they so wish. Now, making that opinion into law is something I entirely disagree with, because the ability to have safe abortions are a form of women’s rights and human rights IMO should never be put to a vote. It doesn’t make sense for a majority to decide on the rights of a human being (normally a minority). </p>

<p>But that doesn’t mean the pro-life men are not allowed to have an opinion.</p>

<p>@ qwerty, I won’t imply it- I’ll say it. People who disagree with me on this issue are dumb. Abortions have happened since the dawn of human civilzation. Making them illegal will not stop people, it will just make unsafe and uninformed abortions more common.</p>

<p>As for the men issue.I you will NEVER have to make this decision so your opinions shouldn’t matter with regards to legality, Between you and your partner I could care less about how much your opinions matter, but you might want to get that squared away before you knock her up. But your opinion about a decision you’ll never have to make should have no weight on what I do with MY body.</p>

<p>^Of course not. Nobody said that. </p>

<p>As a male, I’m in favor of pro-choice solely because I see it as a form of women’s rights. But I think males should be able to voice their opinion because just saying their opinion doesn’t matter creates more resistance. Legalization is a whole nother animal. Men should NOT have a say in the legal issues of abortions. But lets face it, if we don’t allow men to speak up on their pro-life stance, we can never get them to see where we’re coming from and as much as you and I can say that it should NOT have a bearing on the ballot, social acceptance of abortions are just as important as legal acceptance. Maybe not as much, but there’s correlation between the two. And for social acceptance to occur, we have to keep debating people like MM and hope they understand.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I didn’t realize I implied that they were dumb. My apologies. Misguided and controlling perhaps, but probably not dumb.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I become unreasonable in response to unreasonable arguments. I absolutely cannot understand how anyone could equate abortion with the murder of, say, a 43 year old man. That’s like equating female circumcision to male circumcision: the parallel isn’t there, and I don’t understand how people can possibly make the connection.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I should have re-worded that. I don’t think men should push for law or ideological base in an issue that they don’t have stock in. I have lots of opinions on issues that are irrelevant to me, but that doesn’t mean I act on them. I think men should not act on the issue.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I have to agree with roman here. The problem I have with the pro-life argument is that it is black and white. This is not a black and white, yes or no, legal or not, even murder or not issue. If by some nightmare abortion was outlawed (or further restricted), abortion would go to the back alley. Now, women would die, doctors would go to jail, women would be persecuted, etc. If you don’t want embryos and fetuses to be aborted, then I assume you certainly don’t want women to die. In that sense, I have to ask who you value more. Pro-choicers believe this is a woman’s rights issue. Pro-lifers believe that the embryo or fetus has complete control over the woman.</p>

<p>However, as I believe roman implies, this is not even an issue of abortion. This is an issue of preventing unwanted pregnancies. That means providing comprehensive sex education, ensuring contraceptives at a reasonable price and availability, improving the adoption system for those who might so choose it, etc. The obvious and easiest way to reduce abortion is not to outlaw them, but to prevent the cause for them in the first place: unwanted pregnancy.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Agreed. I absolutely loathe tattoos, and feel that they are probably the ugliest thing you could ever do to your body. But I’m certainly not trying to outlaw them.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Amen to all of that! Unfortunately, many of the people who want to ban abortions are the same people who want to teach abstinence only, reduce funding to places such as planned parenthood, and make it harder for girls and women to get information and help.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>This is what really makes it difficult for me to stay reasonable, and therefore aid in the pro-choice argument. I don’t think it’s possible for me to comprehend the people you mentioned, whether they are a minority or majority on the pro-life side. I’m all for people who are anti-abortion (I’m not), but you can be anti-abortion and pro-choice, and that’s what’s important. I would never advocate the prohibitation of abortion, nor would I do so for contraceptive or emergency contraceptive. I guess some things that irritate me about the pro-life side are those things. Why is abortion wrong but not contraceptive (if that is indeed the view)? Why do men go free but women have to deal with pregnancy and possibly motherhood (although I don’t advocate father laws, it’s valid)? How can a man say “she can just give it up for adoption” and then make it law if he has no idea what it’s like to carry for nine months? Etc.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>You are begging the question by assuming that people will not cease having abortions if we enforce anti-abortion legislation.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>For the sake of brevity, I will presuppose that the fetus qualifies as a human being. The validity of this premise has been argued ad nauseum, here and elsewhere; I suspect that everyone in this thread already has a firmly set belief as to whether or not my premise is valid.</p>

<p>With this said, I don’t agree with your argument at all. I will never kill a person. I will never be asked whether or not a person should die. This does not mean I should stand by while other people (completely unrelated to me) are taking human lives*. Abortion in my view constitutes a violation of the most fundamental human right - the right to life. I may to be too much the idealist here, but the defense of human rights is the single most important aspect of politics to me, regardless of whether or not I have a direct interest at stake whenever rights are violated. I would additionally argue that human rights, particularly the fundamental right of life, trump a women’s rights in this instance.</p>

<p>On a microcosmic level, I will admit you have a point. If I’m in a serious relationship, I will certainly have discussed this with my partner (although I am fastidious in my use of birth control).</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Not sure what you’re saying. People have abortions whether it is legal or not.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Well if I can take it off my body and it’s still “alive” then I’m killing it. If it ceases to grow when it’s apart from me then it is part of MY body and it is MY choice.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>If we assume that there will no difference in the net number of abortions undertaken, it naturally follows that there is no net benefit to legislating against abortion. The assumption made in your argument (about the change in abortions undertaken) necessarily results in the conclusion. Essentially, your argument needs to prove that there will be no changes in the net number of abortions taken to be valid; else, it is an example of petitio principii, or, in modern terms, circular reasoning.</p>

<p>Tapp, just out of curiosity, are you male or female?</p>

<p>Actually, don’t answer that. I don’t care. Have your opinion all you want but don’t take away my rights. I’m done now.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>It’s not about the number of abortions conducted; it’s about the damage done. I doubt the number of abortions would drop significantly; I highly doubt it would drop more than 30%. I have no proof, but it follows logically, considering that a) unwanted pregnancies will still occur, b) nothing else will have changed, c) the law stops remarkably few people from doing anything (witness: speeding and pot), and d) there are plenty of ways to have an illegal abortion, especially when there’s an entire generation of doctors both trained to perform them and diligent about the right to have one.</p>

<p>However, in terms of net damage done, the cost would be astronomical. As of now, we have a few hundred thousand dead embryos and fetuses every year. If we make abortion illegal, we will still have a few hundred thousand dead embryos and fetuses per year, as well as thousands more seriously injured fetuses, mutilated women, dead women, incarcerated woman, incarcerated doctors, babies thrown in dumpsters, babies on police station door steps, children in the foster care system, women and children in poverty, dead beat or absent dads, etc.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>This. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Women’s rights are a form of human rights. As applicannot has said so many times, a less than 3-month old embryo is not human as per the scientific definition. Therefore, they’re not subjected to all the rights that should come with being human.</p>

<p>The silly thing about abortion debates is that the only variable is the view on what is and isn’t living human and how that should be applied. Yet most seem to talk around the point and take their own view as a given.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Wrong. To qualify for human rights…</p>

<p>U.N. Declaration of Human Rights

</p>

<p>An embryo does not have consciousness - there is no brain matter, and in the late embryo stage, no brain function. Additionally, an embryo and early fetuses are not viable. A fetus is not born, therefore not subject to human rights. Embryos and fetuses are pre-persons. Those people who have suffered irrecoverable brain damage are referred to as post-persons.</p>

<p>Albeit from Wikipedia, this is a good place to start.</p>

<p><a href=“http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Person[/url]”>http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Person&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;