How has the president done in his first year of office?

<p>You all are getting nowhere.</p>

<p>I keep forgetting that this is a thread about the President, which has absolutely nothing to do with abortion.</p>

<p>if palin is elected president i am moving to Canada. but she won’t be. She’ll just prove how much of a ****ing idiot she really is.</p>

<p>yes sarah, south africa is a country…</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>This is what I’ve been trying to say. The question to be decided here is: Is an embryo human? Not does a woman have a right to an abortion, or does a human have a right to life. If an embryo is human, then we have to decide if that embryo’s human rights trump the mother’s human rights.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I have opinions of most of those issues, but none of them are relevant to my current argument, which is about whether embryos are human, not what rights humans have.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>It’s the same issue. Embryos are human in that they have human DNA. Embyros do not have personhood, meaning they do not qualify for human rights. See my last post.</p>

<p>U.N. Declaration of Human Rights</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>My argument here, and that of the pro-lifers I know, is that the current scientific definition is in error. The “scientific definition” of Blacks 200 years ago granted them reduced humanity, but they were wrong. The “scientific defintion” of the Nazi’s considered gays subhuman, but they were also wrong. No good scientist dismisses the possibility of error. You can’t use a definition to prove itself.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I’m not Black, and I’m not racist. Does that mean I shouldn’t push for any ideals on racism, since I have no stock in the issue?</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Becoming unreasonable in response to unreasonable arguments isn’t a good way to convince anyone of anything.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Why don’t you draw a parallel between female and male circumcision? I’m guessing it’s because of the evidence. So let’s look at the evidence on embryos. I belive any definition of humanity either leads to the conclusion that a) embryos are no different that other humans, or that b) some person or group of people have the power to arbitrarily define what is human.</p>

<p>Both of those options lead to a moral choice that actually decides whether you are pro-choice or pro-life. I think many of us do not recognise the real choice they have.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>It’s not the same issue. Embryo’s are either humans* or they are not. If they are, they have the same right to life as all other humans. You can decide under what conditions it is morally acceptable to kill humans, but those standards must apply equally to all humans, including embryos. If you don’t think human rights apply equally to all humans, then you must decide who arbitrarily decides who gets what rights, and accept that that person or group also has the right to decide what right any other class of people have.</p>

<p>*meaning having the same sacredness of life that you and I have.</p>

<p>Is it better to kill the embryo when it can’t feel pain and spare it from being born into a likely dysfunctional family, being put up for adoption, having a very low likelihood of being adopted, or becoming adopted and becoming a delinquent (50% of schools for delinquents are composed of the adopted, while they compose only 2% of the population in america. can’t remember where i read this, but it’s not hard to believe - your parents walk out on you, you’re tossed around and someone basically signs a form saying that you’re theirs) and most likely ending up in jail (mmm the economist never lies)</p>

<p>OR
would you let it succumb to that kind of life?</p>

<p>It’s a hyperbolic statement, but it does happen. At least give the woman a goddamn right as to what’s best for her baby. We’re not asking someone to go inside the mother’s stomach and slowly rip the embryo apart (unless it’s only a couple months before pregnancy, at which point I think it’s ******** to back out of a pregnancy you were already aware of)</p>

<p>^Maybe it is better to do that. But if it is, then it’s also better to kill all those delinquent kids that to let them keep on living that kind of life. If you believe the first you must also believe the second.</p>

<p>Okay, okay, wait. You are confusing the terms “human” and “person” and the concepts behind them.</p>

<p>A human is anything belonging to the species Homo sapiens. That is, “any living or extinct member of the family Hominidae characterized by superior intelligence, articulate speech, and erect carriage.”</p>

<p>A person is a subject of human rights. “A person is a legal concept both permitting rights to and imposing duties on one by law.”</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Right. So in that case, science considered blacks or gays subhuman; i.e., not fully human. Science isn’t saying that embryos aren’t fully human (i.e., belonging to Homo sapiens), science is saying that embryos lack certain characteristics. As such, embryos and fetuses are of the human race and pre-persons.</p>

<p>This debate gets confused because everyone is using a different definition, and we tend to throw terms around. An embyro is human in the adjective sense of the word, it is not a human (noun).</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>…Oh please. Yes, you can. If I gave you an apple and told you to prove me it was an orange, how else would you do so?</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Obviously. I never said I was an asset to the pro-choice movement.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Evidence? I guess? How can you draw a parallel between semi-voluntarily removing a relatively useless piece of skin and forcefully removing several necessary organs? Similarly, I ask how you can draw a parallel between removing a clump of cells from a uterus and shooting a 43 year old man in the head.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>What reasons do you believe that an embryo (or fetus, even) has “the same sacreness of life that you and I have?”? What, then, is your definition of personhood?</p>

<p>Okay, so, we know that embryos and fetuses belong to the family Homo sapiens. Now how do we decide personhood?</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Let’s say you did assign personhood to an embryo. Would you not also have to assign personhood to any clump of cells with human DNA? What about a chunk of flesh? It has all of the above characteristics, including human DNA. Is it a person? What about a person who is brain dead? Do they have 100% right to life?</p>

<p>It’s not an arbitrary decision, unless you consider science arbitrary, which you clearly do. Why do we consider a human “adult” at age 18? You can thank psychology for that. What about the labels preemie, newborn, infant, toddler, and child? Biology and psychology will do that for you. What about the difference between adult and senior? Biology and psychology. Not to mention the difference between cat and dog, chimpanzee and human, and fetus and embryo, embryo and infant, etc.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Wrong. Again, this is not a black or white issue. Embryos have human DNA. That does not make them totally human, and it does not make them persons. This is not a black or white issue. My liver has human DNA and the same characteristics as an embryo, and while it is human in the sense of the adjective, it is not human in the sense of the noun.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Even if you wanted to say that embryos were conferred the rights of personhood, would the mother not be able to have an abortion out of self defense?</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I think human rights apply equal to all humans, but not all all things human (i.e., embryos, livers, skin cells).</p>

<p>But but but don’t all you prochoice people know that most abortions are done by wealthy citizens and would have been born into a perfect life? Or that our adoption system is soo perfect that there are NO unwanted children? And that a majority of foster care system kids go on to be happy kids who have loving families? Duh!!</p>

<p>The point is, if a woman wants an abortion, there is a REASON that she wants an abortion. Whether there is abuse, neglect, poverty, an age issue, etc there is ALWAYS a reason. Let the woman decide whether or not it is the right time to bring a baby into the world. You antiabortion people are so concerned about the fetus LIVING that you RARELY think about the LIFE it is going to have. Tell me, are YOU going to get that child out of a cycle of abuse or poverty? Probably not.</p>

<p>So I know this is simplifying it, but let’s say a person…IDK just didn’t use contraception and then found out she was pregnant right away. So then got an abortion RIGHT away. What’s the difference? The embryo is just cells, or whatever, it is not even close to resembling an actual person. Let’s say the condom tore. So a person should be forced to have a baby they didn’t want? If they would just take a morning-after pill, they are killing someone? I don’t agree with that. (Don’t even get started on rape…)</p>

<p>Basically, a woman has the right to decide for herself. And the embryo doesn’t feel anything until 20 weeks, I read. As long as it’s not, like, the last trimester, I think a woman should have the right to choose.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>There is the possibility of adoption.</p>

<p>If person hood matters in determining whether or not to kill something, why do we have animal cruelty laws</p>

<p>Right Warts- EVERY child gets adopted. Go look at adoption statistics- they are SICKENING. The majority of kids put up for adoption won’t be adopted- EVER. Newborn healthy babies will, but a good chunk of those who are aborted weren’t going to be well taken care of in the womb. Plus, there are HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS of kids in foster care who need to be adopted. But you’re right- let’s keep bringing unwanted babies into the world. Who gives a rat’s behind about the kids who need homes.</p>

<p>Yeah, I always think about how the kids who are adopted seem always to be newborns. What about the 3 year-olds? 6? 10? Also, isn’t the process to be able to adopt SO HARD? Ugh…Also, it annoys me off SO MUCH when people think that same-sex couples should not be able to adopt. So you deny a child two loving parents just because of their orientation? Messed up.</p>