How much do you just have to learn on your own, and how much can you be helped along?

<p>Like if you’ve recently stumbled upon your “vocation” or something recently. Do you wish you had found it sooner? Do you regret all the years you spent absorbed with other endeavors that you now regard as practically pointless? Do you wish someone would have told you what it was that it took you seemingly forever to realize?</p>

<p>Now, I know self-discovery is important. Some things have to be developed from experience. From the process of growing and exploring and learning. But I feel this process for me has been highly inefficient for me. There have been some critical junctures where I completely dismissed certain ideas or promulgated absurd viewpoints to people, and could have valued critical feedback from them - anything to prompt me to reconsider - but didn’t receive any. And the thing is, I know they recognized my ignorance. They could have steered me away from such close-minded behavior, but didn’t. So instead I was left to continue to act based on my false and damaging beliefs until finally (usually slowly over time) I came to more sound conclusions. </p>

<p>I don’t resent these people for slowing me down or anything, but I think it’s something to consider - how saying something, of all things offering criticism to someone, can actually be incredibly helpful to him/her. Maybe they didn’t think feedback would have benefitted me (and there’s a chance it might not have) or maybe they didn’t care enough to correct me (this was probably the case), but still. When you are exposed directly to someone’s distorted or misshaped beliefs or perceptions or goals, I think it is important to confront the person. Otherwise their (usually undesirable) resultant behaviors go unchecked, and continue to permeate society. </p>

<p>Yes, there are cases where confronting someone is not best. Sometimes ignorance generates desirable behaviors (for example religious adherence). Also, adults are generally not very malleable, so criticism here is often futile. And the same goes for some kids.</p>

<p>In fact, I think it is because so many people are bad at responding to criticism related to what they think, that people end up refraining from offering it. (because our criticism often isn’t received very well - even when it is constructive and not derisive, and all things that the kind of criticism I’m talking about should be - we might end up not giving it as much). Which is sad. Because some of us could really use it (like me). Criticism is one of the most valuable things we have to offer each other I think.</p>

<p>Anyways, I realize I’ve strayed from my original inquiry. I’m curious about people’s thoughts about criticism, though. And more criticism of thoughts and ideas, because this is where we tend to field less (and maybe not enough) criticism I think. While people will be reproved of their wrong actions, the underlying thought patters responsible - the thing really worthy of criticism - often remains unidentified.</p>

<p>Ugh, you need a tl;dr version X_x</p>

<p>“The trouble with the world is that the stupid are cocksure and the intelligent are full of doubt.”</p>

<p>Said by Bertrand Russell, I think it sheds quite a lot of light on your inquiry. People don’t bode well with criticism because of their state of mind in thinking that their ideas/thoughts are the best. Peoples’ intentions are to constructive criticism as internet chat is to the tone of chat conversations. It’s not too easy to pick up a person’s good intentions in offering constructive criticism, and as such they retreat into their shell at the slightest hint of negativity.</p>

<p>Criticism is good. But even the most open-minded people cringe at hearing constructive criticism sometimes. Such is the situation for me. And if open-minded people do that, how would you expect close-minded or adamant people to react?</p>

<p><em>likes post</em></p>

<p>But I have hw due at 11 PM today.</p>

<p>Anyways, I’ll read it after today. For now I’ll just say that it highly depends on subject. Also, on some subjects you’re faster when helped along, but can still do it all by yourself.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>ah, that quote fits really well :). Yeah, sincere criticism can be hard to detect. In part because so much of the criticism people receive is negative. So even gentle guidance can be mistaken as criticism. And the fact that so many people automatically shut down in response to good-intentioned criticism only contributes to making people more cautious about sharing it.</p>

<p>So those “full of doubt” end up missing out on instruction they might have otherwise gotten (if not for those that make criticism such a testy topic). </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I’ve sort of learned to appreciate criticism (constructive criticism, that is). But its totally understandable that you would sometimes cringe at it. I mean, I think most people get excess criticism of the pointless and ineffective (and sometimes malicious) type, so it can be hard to decipher when someone is actually trying to help you. </p>

<p>yeah, the close-minded and adamant are usually hopeless causes I think. The minuses (getting attacked backed, or destabilizing a friendship or relation) outweigh the pluses (the small chance they might listen and consider what you have to say).</p>