How to work towards a better chance at really prestigious schools: Harvard, Princeton, MIT?

I note every once in a while someone at a highly selective holistic review college will get a copy of their admissions file (which you have a right to get as long as you enroll), and very often they report being somewhat surprised at what really made the difference for them. Including because often it wasn’t what they thought was most impressive about their application, instead it was some narrative that the readers saw emerging from recommendations, possibly certain non-competitive activities, and so on, that fit broadly into this “Be nice” category.

So it is in fact a very real factor. But again, it seems almost totally ignored in the online discussions I have seen.

But not in many of the sorts of private K-12 systems that “feed” kids at disproportionate rates into the most selective private colleges. We know a lot of that is happening precisely because their top students academically are also more likely to get top personal ratings, and then there is often a LOT of focus on developing social skills and values, including from an early age.

I don’t think that is entirely about gaming college admissions, like I think they believe that is good for kids in general, and for their own school communities. But I think they are in fact aware this is a large part of why their college outcomes are so strong (even after controlling for test scores, demographics, hooks, and such). In a nutshell, they share a vision of what makes for a really valued member of a school community, and from an early age are trying to encourage and support kids developing along those dimensions.

1 Like

Your background is already very impressive. Academically, you have crossed the bar and your ECs sound very solid too. At this late date there isn’t anything you can add that would be substantive - but, again, your resume is already strong. What seems more critical right now is to get a firm budget number from your parents. As a student you can only borrow $5k as a freshman and a total of $27k over 4 years - likewise, your parents can only borrow $20k per year using parent plus loans and a total of $65k over 4 years. Otherwise, it will be out of pocket, via savings/education accounts or private loans. So, a frank conversation is called for so you can have a strategy for what kinds of schools will be affordable for you - that could be elites with generous need-based aid, schools with generous merit or schools where you might be in the running for an academic scholarship (i.e. STAMPs or the Johnson at W&L).

Admittedly, “being nice” is a thing that is not so easy to put in a “chance me.” Lots of these kids may be very nice in person. But if a parent posted that their kid was very nice, would it make any difference to how the kid was chanced? (Don’t most parents think this about their kids?) And if the kid wrote in the chance me that they were very nice, wouldn’t that sound kind of weird?

I really didn’t know how our children’s kindnesses reflected on others until after all of the senior awards and school choices.

I did have neighbors who knew that their kids could be terrors, and I would hear them say “I wish my kids were nice like yours”.
People know whether their children are viewed as kind or nice.

In other words OP: please continue to treat people with respect, kindness, and courtesy. Continue that trend in your college experiences. It will take you far in your adult life.

1 Like

I wonder about this. I assume it might come via letters or a counselor note or off school LOR. Hence it’s important they have a resume b4 writing your letter.

Yes, “being nice” would be reflected in LORs and so on, and I agree that it is important.

I just think it is no surprise that we don’t see a lot of it in “chance me” posts, because the post is written by the parent or the student, not by a LOR writer.

1 Like

Not to me, at least not if how they phrased it was they were trying to be very nice in their daily interactions.

Of course I do understand it isn’t the normal habit to discuss such things in “Chance Me”/”How do I improve my chances” threads and such, but that to me is precisely the problem. These online discussions have “normalized” a way of thinking about highly selective holistic review college admissions which is not consistent with how these colleges actually make their admissions decisions.

In fact, I think you are putting your finger on a basic reason why this remains such an effective filter for these colleges. I think there are lot of complex explanations for why this general topic feels “weird” to some parents, kids, and so on, but I think the practical effect is most applicants to these colleges are de facto settling for what Harvard internally called a “generally positive” personal rating. And yes, most parents, most teachers, and so on are generally positive about these kids. So they aren’t really hearing from anyone this could be a problem.

But we do know that in the vast majority of cases that is not good enough, meaning if you are applying unhooked to these colleges, to be fully competitive you typically need what Harvard called a “very strong” personal rating. And whatever they call it internally, that sort of “very good” personal rating appears uncommon enough relative to “generally positive” personal ratings that it serves to explain a lot of which otherwise highly qualified unhooked applicants actually get admitted, and which do not.

But again for a variety of reasons, lots of people are reluctant to really talk in blunt terms about what might make the difference between a generally positive personal rating and a very strong personal rating. Among other things, I think it can feel critical of “generally positive” kids in a very personal way that strikes many people as highly inappropriate. So, while they might have no problem, say, explaining to an unhooked kid with a lot of A-/B+ grades they probably won’t be competitive for Harvard, the idea of suggesting to a kid they have a “generally positive” A-/B+ sort of personality, but probably not a “very good” A/A+ personality, is basically unthinkable.

I do think there is a way of talking about this that can work, which is basically what MIT did in that blog post. And I believe we could in fact have this conversation online, in the same ways I have seen it happen in the real world sometimes. But as long as so many people online have the gut reaction that such a conversation would be weird, well, kids and parents relying on these online conversations for guidance are going to end up missing out on a lot of what they would really need to be thinking about if they really wanted to maximize their chances of admissions at these colleges.

I note there is a whole section of that MIT Applying Sideways post in which they explain how following their advice will serve you well even if you don’t get admitted to MIT:

But what if you don’t get into MIT?

Well, you may be disappointed. But you learned everything you could, so now you’re smarter; you were a positive member of your community, and you made people happy; and you spent high school doing not what you thought you had to do to get into a selective college, but what you wanted to do more than anything else in the world. In other words, you didn’t waste a single solitary second of your time.

Applying sideways, as a mantra, means don’t do things because you think they will help you get into MIT (or Harvard, or CalTech, or anywhere). Instead, you should study hard, be nice, and pursue your passion, because then you will have spent high school doing all the rights things, and, as a complete side effect, you’ll be cast in the best light possible for competitive college admissions.

Sometimes, you really can have the best of both worlds.

1 Like

I really hope no one is “nice” so they can get into a “prestigious” school!

Yeah, it is sort of a trick because what they really want is self-motivated kids who then happen to be one of the sort of kids they like as students. As soon as you are doing things because they want you to, and not because you want to, you aren’t really what they want you to be.

1 Like

I do believe MIT’s stated desire to find “nice kids” is aspirational, but there is plenty of evidence that they (and their peers) admit lots of kids who don’t fit that ideal, or fake it enough that they get in anyway. I would hate for the takeaway lesson here for aspiring high school applicants that being smart, accomplished and nice are necessary and sufficient conditions to get admitted to the likes of MIT and its peers. Sure, do those things aspirationally (because why not as good human beings?), but kids should know sometimes it is important to take on a harder edge to get into some of these places, even if it well-disguised as “nice”.

3 Likes

Agree on this.

1 Like

So we know from things like the data revealed in the Harvard litigation that the personal rating factor is in fact very important.

In terms of successfully faking your way to a high personal rating, I am sure that happens sometimes. But I personally suspect it works less often than some kids are hoping, including because they are not fully in control of things like teacher and counselor recommendations.

So I think the best advice for those interested in such colleges is to genuinely make this a developmental focus area, ideally starting many years in advance, as opposed to hoping to fake it successfully at the end.

Interestingly, though, it does appear that going with faking it is more in the comfort zone for at least some kids, or indeed parents.

That said, of course it isn’t sufficient. Applicants who, say, got academic 2s, activities 2s, and personal 2s had far higher chances of Harvard admissions than applicants who had academic 2s, activities 2, and personal 3s. But they didn’t all get admitted, just a lot more of them.

And you would need to get the academic 2 and activities 2 as well. Which is basically the same thing MIT explained. All three of these categories of holistic review serve a gatekeeping function, and far fewer kids actually get through all three gates than some people seem to realize.

Yeah… although my kids like their friends who ended up at MIT, Stanford, etc, I would not say that these kids are the “nicest” in their friend groups… and my D also knows some kids from last year’s summer program who are going to these schools that she wouldn’t describe as nice at all.

My feeling after watching my D go through the application and interview process is that when MIT is evaluating personal qualities in an applicant, niceness is just one of many attributes they are hoping to see… they are also looking for personal qualities like initiative, persistence, etc. (things like: did you find and/or invent opportunities by yourself, or were opportunities provided by your parents or school?) Niceness is nice, but by itself I do not think it is not going to take you all the way to the highest personal rating.

But I do think they are a lot more interested in niceness today than they were back in the day when I attended MIT. At that time it seemed to be all about being spiky.

As @tamagotchi wrote below your reply, I do believe the super elite schools do screen for “personal qualities", but that broad criterion should not be interpreted one-dimensionally as “nice” as the MIT admissions blog seems to imply. In fact, creativity, drive, grit, resilience, resolve, optimism, humility, industriousness, curiosity, persistence, etc. are all desirable personal qualities, even if a particular kid is less than fully “nice” or proactively “friendly”.

2 Likes

I’ve lived in a bunch of places. When I lived in a small city in the Midwest, people in the Northeast would always say “Oh, you’re so lucky, I’ve heard people there are so nice”.

Nobody ever said that folks in London were “nice”, even though they were. Nobody ever said that folks in Rhode Island were “nice”, even though they were.

I’ve lived in New England the longest- and again- nobody describes the typical “Yankee” as nice. But the people in the place I live in now are the nicest people I’ve ever been around.

They are not always polite (that was London). They are not always enthusiastically interested in chit-chat (that was the Midwestern thing). And they can be reserved to an extraordinary degree. But the “nice” piece- generous, giving to a neighbor who is struggling, cutting down someone’s tree because they own the right equipment and why should someone pay an arborist $1000 when it’s “only” four hours on a Sunday to haul out the ladder, chain saw, safety equipment, etc. and then neatly cut and stack the logs??

So don’t over-index on “polite and friendly” when interpreting whether colleges want “nice”. Nice doesn’t mean popular, and it doesn’t mean the person who knows who is having a party for Cinco de Mayo vs. who is having a watch party for anyone who missed the finale of “The Pitt”. Nice can also mean showing a deep commitment to community, patriotism, civic involvement even when it doesn’t involve an award, a prize, a dinner. Nice is the person who meets the school bus for the kids whose mom is having chemo, supervises homework, makes them dinner, and then quietly leaves without wanting to be thanked. I know a bunch of these people.

1 Like

Ah, I very much agree with that. In fact, these colleges are typically putting together what they see as mixes of different sorts of kids, and so there isn’t necessarily one personality type they want repeated 2000 times. And then different highly selective colleges may also have different personality mixes in mind.

This is pointing to another plausible part of the explanation for how “feeder” private schools are averaging a lot more high personal ratings for their top students. Their college counselors typically go through an extended process of getting to know the students they have been assigned in a cohort, and then help steer them to the particular selective colleges they think are good two-way fits–the college is what the kid is looking for, but the kid is also what they believe the college is typically looking for, at least from their sort of school.

I don’t know of something actually proving this, but it makes sense to me that this sort of pre-matching being done by experienced college counselors would help optimize non-academic ratings. Particularly in contrast to applicants who are simply “shotgunning” Ivies/T20s/etc., meaning lists based solely on generic rankings with no attempt to dive deeply into what they say about what they are really looking for non-academically so as to pick the best actual matches.

Absolutely. I note MIT–which really should be seen as just one example, understanding other highly-selective colleges could see things somewhat differently–has an extended discussion available of what they look for:

There are various themes there that help flesh out what they have in mind. They include wanting to use science and technology to make the world better; a collaborative and cooperative spirit (as opposed to wanting to work alone all the time); initiative, including as to contributing to your family or community; knowing how to build a support system to aid in risk-taking; and finding a balance between work and play, including finding joy through various group or community activities.

They wrap up with this statement:

The character of the MIT community

Our community is comprised of thoughtful people from a wide variety of backgrounds and worldviews who take care of each other and lift each other up; they inspire each other to work and dream beyond their potential. Students regularly work alongside faculty and staff to shape MIT policies and further our mission to make the world a better place. Applicants who are a good fit for MIT are trailblazers—they challenge themselves and, in the most meaningful cases, forge a new path not only for themselves but for others around them. We’re looking to admit people who feel responsible to the communities they’re a part of and will help sustain the heart of MIT’s.

It would indeed be a mistake to interpret this as a simple lack of negative qualities, which is what words like “polite” tend to suggest. This is painting a picture of a very enthusiastically active person when it comes to things like collaboration, caring for others in their community, having fun, and so on.

And again, I have no doubt different successful applicants will do this in different ways. What I think is a mistake, though, is not taking this seriously in general. Like, I think everyone can think about broad themes like not just doing things to advance yourself, but also taking care of others around you and lifting them up.

Then what exactly that means for you can vary. But if you really want to maximize your chances, you shouldn’t be thinking in terms of what is easiest so as to check this box. You should be thinking in terms of doing things that would truly challenge you in these areas, such that you can actually develop meaningfully new interests and capabilities.

I’ve been wanting to chime in about being “nice” from an educator’s point of view. I see students/parents who are shocked every year seeing certain other students get into highly rejective schools, and I think a lot of that has to do with the recommendations that of course they don’t see.

It seems like a lot of students/parents in our district (and maybe on CC) believe that the most competitive applicants are the ones two years ahead in math, captain of the sports team, won STEM awards and competitions, etc. But I think what the same students/parents don’t see is that there are 100 other kids at the high school two years ahead in math, multiply that times thousands of high schools around the country and that doesn’t really stick out at all anymore. Same with the STEM awards - there are so many competitions, everyone seems to have won something. And then captain of the team - well there are zillion club teams these days so everyone is a captain. In addition, with grade inflation, our public high school each year has 70-80 valedictorians (straight A’s). So that’s no longer unique.

So perfect grades, 12 APs, STEM awards, and leadership really do not stand out amongst a hundred other students in the school and hundreds of thousands of other students around the country with the same grades and scores and extracurriculars.

What DOES stand out to an educator who is writing a recommendation is curiosity, enthusiasm for learning, and yes, kindness. I could write hundreds of recommendations, “So and so is a good student, they have perfect grades and test scores, they have leadership is some clubs and teams, etc.” But I could write very few recommendations that say, “So and so always helps their classmates when they are confused about an assignment. They are the first person who goes to pick up the pencils when someone else drops the container. They engage equally kindly with every student in the classroom, whether it is the captain of the football team or the emo kid in the corner. Instead of taking a 6th AP class, they volunteer with the special ed PE class. They come in each day and say good morning to me and ask how my ailing relative is doing or how my weekend was. They work at McDonald’s all summer to save for college instead of doing pay-to-play research. They LOVE learning and stay after class to ask questions. They actively engage in discussions AND listen to and value the different opinions of others.” This is the kind of student who will get a glowing recommendation that others will never see and every year will shock other students/parents with their admissions.

In terms of the OP, I don’t think any of this can be planned or plotted. But I do think it is good for students to know that their curiosity and inquisitiveness vs sole quest for a 4.0 is noted, and that their actions towards others, both peers and educators, is always noticed.

10 Likes

Oh, I agree. I had no idea what my kids did in their classrooms each day – regarding behavior. After the acceptances came in, with our last senior, I spoke to the counselors, and they all said that the “teachers and coaches loved your kids”.

According to the counselors, it was the same theme on their LORs: our children went out of their way to help others and they actually like learning.

None of them were presidents of their clubs. Their coaches selected them as captains. They all had paid summer jobs and volunteering in community organizations (since elementary school).

I had one insane parent ask me how much I paid Caltech to accept our son! She was angry that our son was admitted and wasn’t valedictorian. Yet he got in to his schools and her son didn’t.

Our eldest asked me to make a second lunch every day for a friend. (She was receiving free lunch through the school, but was embarrassed to ask for more to last her through the 3 hours of practice.)

Later on, the child thanked me for providing the only meal she had for dinner. I had no idea who the meal was going to.

Everything was intrinsic. I wouldn’t hear of anything until later from a parent or another student.

The “being considerate” factor apparently influences acceptance decisions.

4 Likes