How to work towards a better chance at really prestigious schools: Harvard, Princeton, MIT?

When I hear things like that extra lunch story (which is truly inspiring, by the way), it really clicks for me what MIT and such mean with phrases like “take care of each other and lift each other up.”

Of course as soon as you start talking about any of this, some people will start thinking in terms of imitation, check boxes, and so on. But I do think as a kid, or indeed as a parent, you can think in terms of basics, like developing the relevant values, ethics, social habits, and so on. And then you will make your own stories like this, because that will be who you are.

2 Likes

Thanks for sharing your thoughts, which just echoed the importance of LoR, which the studants/parents cannot see, but everyone agree LoR and personal assay are just as important as stats.

On other hand, the sport team captain is not the same as club president. Anyone can imitate a new club literally, but the school official sport teams are limited.

If a school allows 70-80 valedictorians, the school better just remove this title.

2 Likes

While that is true, I note some high schools offer a lot more sports than others, and there are some high schools with both a lot of sports teams and yet not so many students. Finally, some teams might have more captains than others. So, the practical opportunity to be a sports captain does vary greatly by school and possibly sport/team.

That said, I agree with the point about just starting a club and appointing yourself president–I think colleges know all about that strategy. However, I think when it is something like a big, established club, working your way up into top club leadership can be equivalent to official varsity team leadership. And I think savvy college counselors can make that clear in their recommendations. Like if, say, being Editor-in-Chief of the Yearbook is a big deal in their HS, they can make that clear in their recommendation for that applicant.

@cloudymind A few kids I know attending HYPSM schools made an appointment to review their admissions files, and universally they were more than surprised at the primacy of teacher / counselor / mentor LoR’s in the AO’s reader notes (for committee)…. far more than the ‘numbers’ (GPA, test scores, class rank). It goes to the old adage that while poor stats can keep you out, great stats cannot get you in to these places.

These types of schools likely employ a “threshold” policy, meaning if you pass some threshold, they start looking at other things in your application file, including “personal qualities” as we’ve been talking about here. Everyone says elite college admissions is a lottery, but I doubt it is that so much as it is AO’s seeking out qualities that are harder to quantify.

@aunt_bea Thank you for sharing two stories: that Caltech story shows some parents are simply nuts; Caltech is not the kind of place you want to attend if you’re not well girded for the fire hose. And also for your 2nd lunch story: as I get along in years, it reminds me that sometimes it’s the small, unspoken things that people remember best.

4 Likes

The eldest (who gave the lunch to her teammate) was our double major CS/electric engineering child who, although accepted to: Yale, Johns Hopkins, USC, and all her UCs, attended Buffalo on a full ride for “premed”.

She knew her sister would be applying to college (Davis) and that it would be expensive for us, so the eldest decided to go to Buffalo to save us money, and loved it.

I now believe that our children were accepted because of their letters of recommendation.

This post made me think about how the staff could possibly know what to write about our kids. Then I recalled some of the conversations that I had with staff.

On my walk this morning with my neighbor, she asked me if my youngest, her son’s age, attended the prom. I said no. He and his friends went out to an arcade and had pizza.

I told the neighbor that our son’s “bookish friends” couldn’t get dates. Our son was asked out for senior prom by several girls.
He told each girl that he was sorry because he was waiting for his friends to get dates before he could commit to the prom (per info from staff).

The principal and staff had asked our son if he was going to the prom. He told them that he didn’t feel comfortable going, while his good friends couldn’t have the same experience. I found this all out from the Principal.

When I spoke to my son about prom, at that time, he said “my friends and I are going out for Pizza; we couldn’t get dates.”

Our middle daughter was asked to peer tutor an autistic student. Apparently, according to the counselor, several students were asked to tutor the student and they all declined.

When they finally asked our daughter, they told her they didn’t want to ask her because she was already over-committed.

The counselor reported to me that our daughter said, “That’s OK, my mom is a Speech Path and she can teach me how to work with him.”

I don’t remember ever teaching them how to respond and how to behave kindly in peer situations. When they were very young they did read a lot of books about compassion and empathy. Apparently the books worked. Coworkers appear to really respect and like them.

4 Likes

So great to hear there are teenagers like this out there. I sense they will go far in life.

2 Likes

This topic was automatically closed 180 days after the last reply. If you’d like to reply, please flag the thread for moderator attention.