HS newspaper article on choosing the valedictorian

<p>Well, valedictorian is defined as “the student with the highest grades in the class who USUALLY delivers the valedictory at graduation ceremonies.”</p>

<p>Are they choosing a valedictorian, or are they choosing a speaker?</p>

<p>At my school, the valedictorian speaks, the Student Body president speaks, the Senior class president speaks, as well as a few elected speakers (there’s usually some overlap).</p>

<p>The title of the article is “Valedictorian should be more than number one”, i.e., we should change what it means to be valedictorian. The writer interviews the head counselor about our school’s criteria and what it’d take to change it, and interviews counselors from other schools. It is explicitly to change what a “valedictorian” is. </p>

<p>I don’t have a problem with an additional speaker, per se, although I think it would be best to simply extend the priviledges of Senior class president.</p>

<p>However, it’s actually a really personal issue, which I failed to mention. In the past, the vals and sals at my school have always been very popular, but my sister is not. Alot of students unrightfully resent her, because she dares to speak her mind and engage herself in class and get the most out of her education–the mantra of my school is “do enough to get an A, and then relax”. She wrote an article for the newspaper last year about attitudes towards homework and learning, and we got physical threats from both parents and students alike. Maybe I’m just being paranoid, worrying too much…but I really do think it’s a personal issue. Previous classes have never, ever brought up this issue. They just don’t want HER to speak. </p>

<p>Because it’d be better to half the football player prom king who will study education give a speech than the MUN affeciando teacher’s favourite Russian major. My sister has worked very hard to be valedictorian; not out of competition with other students, but as a personal goal to meet, kind of to validate to herself. </p>

<p>I just don’t know how to address that part without attacking other people. </p>

<p>I go to a very typical, semi-suburban semi-rural non-competitive high school. This should be a non-issue! </p>

<p>:(</p>

<p>What happens if you have the highest GPA, but don’t want to be valedictorian? They don’t force you to be val do they? :D</p>

<p>Drama is physically demanding, you are on your feet hours a day. Plus, I was always a dancer and thus I was dancing upwards of 6 hours a week. And don’t even go into “dance” is not a sport. And you have to practice other thigns everyday. What you are missing is that sports IS NOT for everyone. Sure, most people watch it on TV, but not everyone has the time or wants to participate in sports. I love how you ignored the most important parts of my previous post.</p>

<p>^^ I think that drama, especially ensemble-type performances are just like sports! At my school, there isa group called ‘Ensemble’ who practice dancing, singing, and acting everyday afterschool for the ENTIRE year. I think it can be just as demanding. </p>

<p>I don’t understand the arguments in this thread saying that valedictorians wouldn’t have interesting speeches. In order to get good grades, you need to be prolific, and therefore the val’s speeches would be innately interesting. The 2 top people at my school are shy asians, but I wouldn’t care about listening to what they have to say, because they obviously have learned to form sentences better than I have.</p>

<p>There should be a math contest to determine valedictorian. :p</p>

<p>I agree with the OP. I’m sick of our school giving accolades to the high-profile “well-rounded” kids. The smart, somewhat less flashy (but still well-rounded!) kids get looked over and are never appreciated by the school. Keep valedictorian!</p>

<p>^ Well-put.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Ok, drama is not a sport lol. I’m not going to say dancing isn’t, but it isn’t one of the most physically demanding.</p>

<p>If people have time for extracurriculars, then they have time to participate in sports.</p>

<p>Why are you arguing with me? We have different opinions. I think val should be chosen based on versatilty. You think the val should be chosen based on GPA only, even if they don’t do any EC’s or sports.</p>

<p>Valedictorian should be based entirely on academic merit. </p>

<p>Grades are one of the most important things in high school, people go to classes and get grades in them, the person who succeeds in getting the best grades deserves the “Valedictorian” title. To me, it’s common sense.</p>

<p>This “representative of the Senior Class” thing that the OP’s school’s newspaper is suggesting should simply be a yearbook superlative or at least don’t play with the “Valedictorian” title and think of a new title for this “popular kid”.</p>

<p>I agree entirely with the OP.</p>

<p>The OP is right, but did someway say that the reason they weren’t doing sports was genetics? What? That is like saying, “well, my IQ is low, why try school?” Sports, or at least some type of athletics should be mandatory, and probably graded. Being smart won’t help if you have a heart attack or something before you reach fifty. And, no, I’m not athletically inclined either, but I’ve still found a sport I enjoy for every season.</p>

<p>Yeah, that was me talking about genetics. And yeah, it’s an excuse, although I’ve been known to show incredible improvement in gym class. Just, I don’t like volleyball, or basketball, or softball, or cheerleading, so I have no options at my school to play sports. Plus, there are more talented kids than me. :)</p>

<p>I am looking forward to PE in college though, because it’s alot more interesting. Coming from a state that requires PE, and a school that calculates it into your GPA, I just have grown to resent it.</p>

<p>Athletics should have nothing to do with Valedictorian. What is done outside of school should be irrelevant. I hate how people are always pressuring extra activities… some people just don’t like doing them, and there is nothing wrong with that.</p>

<p>JMan, the point is that most people do not have time to do extracurriculars AND sports. Therefore, you are asking them to forgo something they WANT to do, something that will HELP society and the community, in order to get an award. </p>

<p>I for one, want to see this country take a turn and produce people who are passionate about what they participate in, instead of forcing everyone in this mold. </p>

<p>And I didn’t have a problem with the extracurricular part, I can understnad that especially since most vals DO participate in activities. But sports ARE extacurriculars.</p>

<p>“Ok, drama is not a sport lol. I’m not going to say dancing isn’t, but it isn’t one of the most physically demanding.”</p>

<p>are you KIDDING me? ive been a dancer for 13 years - dont u dare tell me that my 6 hr rehearsals after school are not incredibly physically demanding. </p>

<p>my school lets the kids elect someone to give the “senior address” besides the val’s, the sal’s, the NHS pres’, the class pres’, the class officers, and the SGA officers’ speeches. as you can tell, graduation will be quite boring for us.</p>

<p>Thank you Paro, I was just waiting for a dancer to reply =)</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I’m talking about competitions here. Do you dance for 6 hours in a competition?</p>

<p>I never said it wasn’t a sport, just not one of the most demanding. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Those are the same people with horrible time management. If you can do an extracurricular, you can do a sport. </p>

<p>Why are you so against exercise? It is good for you. Sports were meant for exercising to be fun. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I agree. I think PE should be mandatory.</p>

<p>PE IS mandatory in most places, you know that it is for FL. And, please, I am the LAST person on earth to talk about time management. I made a homework/activity schedule for each day before school started, including time for internet, phone, dates, football games, and church. If you knew me, which I know you don’t, you would understnad that. That being said, I do not have enough time to play a sport in addition to everything else. (Remember I have this thing called school going on as well). Plus, I want to have a life and I have a b/f whom I would rather spend time with. </p>

<p>PS- I can also honestly say I’m exercising now. And you’ll be happy to hear this: I’m enjoying it, yes, I never thought I would say that but I did. (Probably because I watch Gilmore Girls while on the treadmill). But, it is my PERSONAL decision, well…plus it’s for a class. But, I think I may be in the habit of doing this after the class ends. I know exercising is good for me, but I don’t have to embarrass myself on a team to be an activie person. I like to do things in the privacy of my own home where I don’t feel like I’m being compared to the other girls around me. </p>

<p>I hope that makes you feel better that I’m not a bump on the log, but you still fail to mention or address my point about pursuing your passion. Yours is sports, mine is not.</p>

<p>

Oh. My. Swizzle sticks. You seriously don’t think dance is just as demanding as, say, soccer or basketball? Narrow-minded stereotypes abound…</p>

<p>You might think adding a sport would be a good idea. But valedictorian is intended as an academic award. Why not lobby for a student-chosen speaker instead that fulfills those requirements?</p>

<p>I understand your points, but I have my own opinion, and you have yours. There is no award for well-rounded students…I think the valedictorian should be well-rounded. After all, he is the one who gives the ending speech, so he should be one who is involved in his school. Whereas, a bookworm, study-freak, who does not participate at ALL in his school is not the best candidate for giving a valedictory speech IMO because no one will know who he is…they’ll think he is a stranger. How can that type of person be the one who addresses every student in his graduating class?</p>