HS newspaper article on choosing the valedictorian

<p>But that impression you have is so stereotypical! All of my school’s vals and sals have been well-liked (ok, at least well-known) and participated actively in the community and the school. And I resent that you deem me a “study freaK” just because I am <em>hopefully</em> going to be valedictorian. Sure, I study and I care about my grades, and I’m an overachiever, but I’ve been close friends with many of the recent vals and none of them were weird or bookworms. They cared about learning, they loved to learn and excel in what they did, but they were in no way strangers to their classmates. </p>

<p>And if you think it will be dry, well I guess you don’t have the humorous people we do at my school. One of the val’s speeches was THE most inflamatory speech…ever. I don’t think most of the audience got that he was being satirical, but it was talking about politics and the past four years, and it wasn’t jsut the “yeah, congrats, we just got through 4 years.” And, the icing on the cake was our sal speech. Haha, makes me laugh thinking about it. I’ll jsut say it had references to Nelly and Chuck Norris and one of our crazy teachers. It was probably the most entertaining speech I’ve hear din my life, not exagerrating. </p>

<p>And THAT is the point, you need to give people a chance and not pre-judge what they will say and turn your ears off. Maybe, they are actually smart AND funny, I know you think they don’t go together but they do. And you know what, they have worked SO hard to get there with late nights and insance teachers, they deserve that five minutes of a reward. People in sports get attention everyday, but how often do academics get recognized? Hardly ever, at least at my school. </p>

<p>So, Jman and others, give these “nerds” a chance and maybe you’ll be surprised, maybe you’ll understand the zeal they have for learning and finally understand that they/we are not some sub-human species but actual PEOPLE, who care about things other than school (shocker). </p>

<p>Please, just let valedictorian be an academic award since it’s practically the only thing left in the school system that retains the purpose of education, allow for once the smart guy/girl to be on top and not be behind the athlete, the student council people. I know people assume I’m weird because I get straight A’s, and they judge me before they get to know me, and I hate that. Don’t be like that, learn to get to know someone before you pass judgement on them. </p>

<p>Be more optimistic! At its worst, it’s only five minutes of your life, at it’s best it could open your eyes.</p>

<hr>

<p>Last note: You don’t have to be an athlete to be well-rounded. I love math, history, government, physics, philosophy, reading, music, singing, dancing, theatre, writing, and painting. I’m sorry if that is not well-rounded for you because I’m not in a sport.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>It’s so easy to become a multi-millionaire pro athlete.</p>

<p>that is what Prom/Homecoming Court is for.</p>

<p>Dance is NOT a sport, its a form of art. i wont argue the point, though. </p>

<p>elect someone to give a senior address but valedictorian should remain an academic award. there are millions of well rounded people in the world who are ordinary and normal. why award them when you should be awarding the BEST student in the class? HE has achieved something, has worked hard for something, has come out on TOP. stop trying to make this politically correct. </p>

<p>how will you decide who’s “most well-rounded” anyway? a popularity contest?</p>

<p>thats what class president is basically (since the students pick from the ppl running for it)</p>

<p>I completely agree with you- the valedictorian is an academic award
HOWEVER, i think there should be a system that when a valedictorian is announced, they can be removed by their fellow peers because apparently in my brother’s year, they had a valedictorian that EVERYONE HATED, and quite frankly, since everyone hated her, they were completely against her speaking at graduation.</p>

<p>At my school the valedictorian is chosen - by the faculty. he’s supposed to represent the most academically accomplished person of the student body, and neither athletic nor social merit is factored into the decision. However, we also have awards for each of those two categories.</p>

<p>Also, you’re an idiot if you think that the people who are good at sports are any more endowed with ‘good genes’ or ‘luck’ then those who are good at school. You have to work hard to get anywhere in life, and that includes the football field. All of you complaining about how the athletes get the limelight sound like bitter 5 year olds.</p>

<p>I think it needs to be based on all-around achievement. I think someone with great grades, sports achievements, and who is active in clubs/volunteering wins over someone with perfect grades.</p>

<p>Don’t make it into a popularity contest. It should be an academic honor.</p>

<p>Think about how absurd that might get. If you choose the #1 and 2 in the class by votes, will you vote for everyone in the class? Then the least liked kid gets a rank of 95 of 95 even if he was a decent student?</p>

<p>Yeah, that sounds like a terrible idea.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I second that (this poster said it the best). Now that school has become diluted with sports and such, it is easy to forget that the school is supposed to be, above all, an academic institution. The top honor, therefore, should go to the most academically achieved student.</p>

<p>

</p>

<ol>
<li><p>There’s a reason for that. Well-rounded students are usually average-good at many things, but aren’t amazingly good at anything.</p></li>
<li><p>If you really wanted to have an award for that, we should make the “Well-Rounded Student Award”, not replace the highest academic honor. This is like saying we should replace summa cum laude with a popularity contest.</p></li>
</ol>

<p>“I second that (this poster said it the best). Now that school has become diluted with sports and such, it is easy to forget that the school is supposed to be, above all, an academic institution. The top honor, therefore, should go to the most academically achieved student.”</p>

<p>I would like to point out that I agree that being valedictorian is purely an academic honor and should remain that way.</p>

<p>but honestly? diluted with sports and such? do you even know what dilute means? what a joke.</p>

<p>I don’t really get what is a Valedictorian. Is it supposed to be the best student of the graduation class? The student who gives the graduation speech?
There’s no such title here in Brazil so it has always made me confuse…</p>

<p>Pssh, yeah. Valedictorian is the honor given to the student with the highest GPA, isn’t it? Not unweighted GPA, because what would be the point of taking harder classes? It’s a position held as bait to encourage kids to work hard in school, or to keep kids interested.</p>

<p>I don’t see the point of dismissing the position just because “people don’t care”. Give them a chance to say something. Valedictorian is HIS/HER honor, not the honor of the rest of the student body to hear something non-academic. And what’s this assumption that all vals have to be socially inept losers who do nothing but study?</p>

<p>Because generally speaking, people who do nothing but study don’t get too far in life. People who are well-rounded get farther, yes, but well-roundedness is not the target of the award. There’s college admissions for that lol, and Student Council (in some cases)/Prom king/queen for general consensus on popularity…</p>

<p>^^^^^^^^Way to bump a 3 and a half year old thread</p>

<p>Sigh, 2007…</p>

<p>Anyway, the valedictorian of my class got there by stealing exams in his classes. His AP scores did not reflect his grades, but this does not count any bit for class rank. I’m hoping that he gets kicked off the top this year. He’s also annoying, with a Napoleon complex, so a speech would be unpleasant, especially hearing him go on about academic excellence, when others have heard him brag about stealing the exams in AP and honors courses to get to that point.</p>

<p>I think that the valedictorian should be based on academics. However, maybe the speech should be given by the person in the top X% of the class that has the best speech. Just a thought.</p>