<p>And I got 100% on the FRQ. </p>
<p>Rate/hate/castigate</p>
<p>And I got 100% on the FRQ. </p>
<p>Rate/hate/castigate</p>
<p>Well, as long as you were able to logically support your argument, you probably deserved the 100%… Not that I agree that the 13th amendment should be appealed, but if you were able to support it, then you deserved the good grade, I guess. Last year my APUSH teacher told us about a kid who wrote an essay about how African Americans should still be slaves.</p>
<p>Giving kids full credit for passable arguments for untenable positions sometimes sends the unfortunate message that those arguments are therefore correct.</p>
<p>Because of course passable arguments aren’t worth very much in the real world, unlike in school. Passable arguments won’t lead you to the optimal conclusions. They might even lead you to make dangerous decisions. What you need are correct arguments, careful and considered ones.</p>
<p>But it’s much easier to emphasize the skill of generating arguments than the skill of considering them. </p>
<p>There’s no reason to hate/rate/castigate unless you believe what you argued in any sense <em>and</em> believe that you believe what you now believe for other reasons besides having been inadvertently biased by the positive feedback you received for what you had considered originally to be an imagined position, totally separate from your own.</p>
<p>There were and still are many people who truly do believe that the 13th Amendment should be repealed. I clearly don’t agree with this argument, but if it has real evidence to support the conclusion, you can’t say it’s an incorrect argument. Anybody could say that their own political beliefs are the “correct arguments,” but that doesn’t mean that the people who oppose are automatically incorrect or making dangerous decisions.</p>
<p>Of course I believe that the 13th Amendment is a good thing. But somebody else could believe for perfectly valid reasons that it isn’t a good thing, and I wouldn’t say that’s an incorrect argument. It’s just an argument that most people don’t make these days, because the 13th Amendment is pretty much generally accepted nowadays. Similarly, in the future I’m sure gay marriage will be more or less accepted by the public as a whole, once it’s been around for a while. But for now, there are plenty of people who have arguments against it that are just as “careful and considered.” Those arguments could be equally valid in the future; it’s just that most people won’t hold them.</p>
<p>Of course, it all comes down to whether the arguments you’re making are valid or not. If you’re claiming the 13th Amendment is bad, but your evidence is insufficient to back up that claim, then that would be an incorrect argument.</p>
<p>okay, would this be a good time to ask what the 13th amendment is :)?</p>
<p>obviously valid is subjective. Valid TO WHO?</p>
<p>I don’t really believe in/have standards of argumentation. I’m not going to say one argument is valid and one isn’t. But I will say one seems to be better than the other. Striving for a certain standard of validity is the thing that concerns me (especially when that standard is low). We should strive to endlessly improve our arguments, that’s the thing that promotes growth, improvement, etc. </p>
<p>Science doesn’t just stop once we know x amount of have people living to y age.</p>
<p>the 13th amendment abolished slavery.</p>
<p>I once wrote in AP World a POV letter about opposition to the Revolutionary War. Of course I wouldnt feel that, but my teacher said I did a good job standing for a position and backing it up in an efficient, detailed way.</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>everyone thinks they are correct. you can’t say that one needs correct arguements, because if things were indisputably correct, there would be no arguements.</p>
<p>as long as you backed your arguement up well, you deserve your grade. simple as that.</p>
<p>if you got a bad grade because your teacher disagreed with your point of view, there would be a problem</p>
<p>I was talking about arguments in the real world. In school, yeah, sufficiently supported arguments are all you need. </p>
<p>I am thinking of arguments as being justifications for some conclusion about something.</p>
<p>I mean “correct” arguments in the sense that there are truer conclusions, and truer justifications for the truer conclusions. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>By my previous definition of argument I think you can say one needs correct arguments. </p>
<p>For an argument to be considered indisputably correct you would sort of have to compare it to all plausible other related arguments (hence the need for multiple arguments even when you end up on deciding that one of them is best).</p>
<p>LOL, well you must either be a great author or have really pro-slavery teacher</p>
<p>What I actually discussed was the specific provision in the 13th amendment that allowed for slavery as criminal punishment and how that ought to be struck. Don’t worry, I’m not a racist.</p>
<p>@enfieldacademy you CAN’T say that you have a “correct” arguement. obviously, it’s correct to you, but not to everyone.</p>
<p>in arguing whether slavery should be legal or not, most everyone has an opinion and everyone thinks they’re correct. you can’t just say the other side is not correct and be done with it.</p>
<p>Of course you can’t just say the other side is not correct and be done with it. I never intended to imply that.</p>
<p>What you have to do is compare the arguments, and, after evaluating on whatever weighted criteria you decide upon (minimizes suffering, optimizes productivity increases, etc.) you should be able to say which argument is the most correct, which decision sounds the best, given your objectives.</p>
<p>When you reason about something what you are doing is (obviously) giving reasons about why you should think the way you should about something. </p>
<p>If your reason is - it will cost the least so we should do it - well, we (the people evaluating the argument) have to value spending less in order for that reason to mean anything to us.</p>
<p>So comparing arguments against predetermined criteria is pretty essential I think to determining the relative worths of the arguments.</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>How so? Without that clause it might be hard to legally defend imprisonment as a punishment.</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>Sure you can. For any persuasive writing assignment there needs to be some amount of theoretically disputable yet universally accepted truth. Otherwise arguments could only be evaluated on grounds of logical consistency.</p>
<p>It’s perfectly possible that the ground truth used could invalidate the conclusion that slavery should be legal.</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>oh, this is what I was trying to say with that bit about predetermined values, but I like how you said it. Yeah, it’s important to recognize ground truths influence how arguments for things are evaluated (like you said logical consistency isn’t the * only * thing people tend to value in social arguments, where there is livelihood of others involved, etc.).</p>
<p>You do still at least have to look at the other person’s argument very quickly before you see if it’s incorrect (you have to check that it violates one of the accepted ground truths).</p>
<p>I doubt that you could make a good case for slavery with how people’s minds are equipped nowadays.</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>I see. sorry for misunderstanding you. </p>
<p>although now the problem becomes deciding what the predetermined criteria should be.
that varies from person to person as well</p>