If we are given the capacity to "reprogram" predators, should we do so?

<p><a href=“http://www.hedweb.com/abolitionist-project/reprogramming-predators.html[/url]”>http://www.hedweb.com/abolitionist-project/reprogramming-predators.html&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>After all, we now know pretty much all the nutrients needed for normal growth of all animals. Yes, even the strictest of all carnivores, the cats, can now be fed on a purely vegan diet (seriously, google cat + vegan food). So assuming that we had the capacity to “reprogram” predators (in which case predator-induced suffering becomes completely unnecessary), shouldn’t it be morally necessary to do so, in order to reduce the net suffering of all sentient creatures? </p>

<p>And by moral I mean morals that don’t impose arbitrary illogical restrictions like the species barrier.</p>

<p>You’re asking humans to forcefully impose these morals on nonhuman predators. Isn’t it better if the predators become moral/vegan on their own free will, than to force them to become more moral?</p>

<p>We aren’t forcing treatment on all humans to stop eating meat – we’re giving humans the choice to be vegan. (and if needed, we can set up jails for anyone that’s not vegan, although I wouldn’t go that far) So the same thing can apply for these predators. In order for morality to be worth it, we have to trust them to realize what’s moral.</p>

<p>If you want to generalize more human mechanisms of morality to nonhumans, we can set up prisons for predators that aren’t vegan. Then predators must learn on their own to be moral, or they will be locked up. Assuming they have free will, I think this approach is better than programming morality into them.</p>

<p>Very interesting points. The thing is, there are some humans who would not go moral/vegan on their own free will. Now, for practical purposes, we must acknowledge that it will currently be impossible to do so (of course, it is the goal in the long run). So while this objective may currently be impossible to achieve, one may at least try to look for alternate objectives that aren’t as powerful in the short-term, but that at least minimize the most amount of suffering given the circumstances and constraints. </p>

<p>Many tenets of morality, hold, at least, that the abolition of suffering is more important than complete and total free will. This is why sadistic acts are “immoral” - for while the perpetrator gains unnecessary joy over the domination of his victim, the “value” of his joy is incomparable to the value of the victim’s freedom from suffering. Yes, force the sadist to not be sadistic (which actually doesn’t have to come through punishment - the best uses of “force” are nudges, rather than prisons - which impose a total net cost on society). He will still have freedom to pursue many other things (as long as he has some self-control and his sadism isn’t too bad). The same thing holds for nonhuman animals. While the ultimate objective may be a society completely free from cruelty, we can still only do what is immediately feasible to reduce suffering, so long as we cannot force humans to go vegan (that may happen with in vitro meat though). </p>

<p>So what does this mean? Yes, most nonhumans do not have a conception of a “morality” that is all-encompassing among all sentient creatures. If they cannot be trusted to realize what’s moral, some degree of coercion may be required. But punishment isn’t necessary. Just give them everything except opportunities to pursue meat. That is all. “Reprogramming”, in that same manner, is not punishment, but rather, the redirectment of priorities/desires towards ones that don’t hurt another entity.</p>

<p>And in fact, with advanced enough technology, one may not even have to “reprogram” predators. In vitro meat would work just as well for predators as it would for humans, if not better. It can be flavored in a way such to make it even tastier than natural prey. For natural prey is of variable quality, and few such prey is of the highest quality (a quality that can easily be made through in vitro meat and experimentation of taste preferences).</p>

<p>what do you mean by should, do it if you want to and don’t do it if you don’t want to</p>

<p>im pretending to be a philosopher, see, even tho im technically moral relativist =P</p>

<p>You assume that by making all animals on the planet herbivores this would eliminate violence between animals. However if you force all of the animals to be herbivores there will be more “demand” than “supply,” because animals do not have an economic system the only option is a fight to the death. Animals are still being killed but instead of the food chain, animals will be killed over territorial disputes.</p>

<p>This is without even mentioning that the idea of reprogramming predators sounds VERY “Clockwork Orange.”</p>

<p>inject them with testosterone antagonists = no more fights to the death =)</p>

<p>^ Then how would they determine the methodology to divide the food?</p>

<p>animals rarely fight over food when there is enough food in place. they generally fight over mates.</p>

<p>^ That’s because there is enough food in place! My argument is that if you force every animal in the world to be a herbivore there will not be enough food in place! Also yes animals will still fight over mates (although without testosterone I don’t know how the mating process will go down)</p>

<p>nah, it’s far more cost-effective to grow herbivore food than carnivore food, since the vast amounts of energy are wasted as it goes up the food chain. 90% of the corn grain in the US is fed to pigs - it would waste far less energy to give it to ppl instead. 100 units of land can support 10 herbivores, which can support 1 carnivore. make them all herbivores, then it can support 10 units of any of the animals. </p>

<p>testosterone motivates animals to fight over mates. it also produces sperm. but high levels of testosterone are necessary to motivate animals to fight. low levels are still enough to produce sperm.</p>

<p>For Humans? Yes plants are cheaper to grow than to raise animals but I’m not talking about the farm (not many predators on the farm) I’m talking about “the wild.” When the number of predators goes down the numbery of prey rises dramatically (this is because prey species have evolved to have large litters and sort gestation periods, causing lots of offspring because many will die before reaching sexual maturit) if predators didn’t act as predators there would be the same effect. The numbers in every level of the food chain (bar the zenith) will increase. More animals means that more food is needed, this effect snowballs until there is not enough food to sustain these animals. Animals choose between fighting for territory and starvation.</p>

<p>true for a pre-technological world.</p>

<p>nowadays we can control the fertility of animals that start to overcrowd :)</p>

<p>We don’t need animals to fight. They can die of natural causes. To combat overpopulation, we can just reduce their natural lifespans somehow through programming…</p>