In some ways, college admission and/or attendance can be a status symbol just like goods (like fancy watches or hot tubs mentioned above). Just because there is a service that is an investment in a future doesn’t eliminate the shiny status (or lack thereof). The service could be for future earnings (the ROI so many discuss), knowledge (both in-classroom and experiential, and I guess getting to know certain people or groups), or ability to do something in the future (like grad school, prerequisites for jobs), or a vaguer concept of the type of trajectory a person (or the person’s parents) want (successful people go to x – be it Ivy, T20, SLAC, State flagship, etc.). it is an amorphous expenditure, and one that some people get scholarships to, so its value already fluctuates. It can be part pure investment, part insurance, part status symbol depending on the person and family.
Somewhere up above it was mentioned (and has been elsewhere) that student-specific factors are more important than school name in a student’s ultimate success. In that context I thought this LinkedIn post from a Cambridge academic was interesting, in his response to a survey that found Cambridge econ grads have the highest earnings in the UK -the bolded parts are mine:
University of Cambridge BA Economics graduates have the highest median earnings of any undergraduate degree at any British university: £105,000, five years after graduation.
I convene admissions for this course at the Faculty of Economics, University of Cambridge, so I’d love to present this as evidence of what we teach. As an econometrician, I’m obliged to say it’s at least as much evidence of who applies and gets admitted.
Selection, not (only) treatment. Admissions filters for mathematical ability, problem solving, and stubbornness, and those traits get paid whether or not anyone ever explains cointegration to them.
Is there a causal effect of the course itself? Almost certainly. How large? Identification is left as an exercise for the reader.
So he’s not saying school has no effect. But this takes me back to my own econ days back in the dark ages, where we learnt about screening (so: the name of the school is shorthand to employers that candidates are smart, hardworking etc. it saves them time and effort in trying to figure those traits out person by person.)
Of course in the UK this isn’t part of the cost part of the ROI debate, as almost all domestic students pay the same university tuition regardless where they go.
I was just sort of discussing a related point in the LinkedIn thread.
I think it is true that highly resourced generalist institutions will often do well in lots of different specific rankings. And that is an actual point in their favor. Like if you are not sure what you want to do–and how many HS kids REALLY know?–then choosing a well-resourced generalist institution is not a bad idea. The big “problem” is that is an expensive model. Fortunately, most state “flagships” subsidize that model for state residents. And some states realistically have more than one flagship-level option.
However, if you can in fact narrow down what you want to do, then there will also be specialist institutions, or specialist schools within a large university, or special departments/majors, or so on, that have the resources to be arbitrarily competitive in that specific area. And so that is another alternative to choosing an expensive generalist college, to choose a college that is affordable and disproportionally focuses a lot of resources on something you specifically care about.
And then of course highly-resourced colleges may also offer more need aid, but then in a sort of similar set of points, sometimes in-state subsidies for residents are as good or better forms of aid, and sometimes some colleges will offer merit for specific students they really want.
OK, so if a highly qualified kid is looking at all this seriously, and eventually their list includes some very popular, very selective, and highly-resourced generalist institutions, then cool. But if it is a US kid and they don’t at least also consider their in-state options, that doesn’t seem to make sense. And if they also don’t consider some less popular, less selective, and yet still pretty highly-resourced generalist institutions, the kind that might even offer them merit, that also doesn’t seem to make sense.
And then if a kid is actually a self-described specialist kid but seems to be using a generic ranking to choose colleges, that makes very little sense.
So in all these cases, the idea is not that no US News T20 or whatever could ever be a good choice for any kid on actual substantive grounds. It is more that if a kid is ONLY looking at those, that is going to be a hard thing to justify on these grounds. Because there are usually too many other paths worth considering in the US system, for almost any type of kid, to make that plausible.
I agree with everything you said. I worked with high school students, and I saw something else at play as well. Students and parents often decide that a particular type of college is the only environment where the student can succeed. They convince themselves that small colleges automatically provide better teaching, that graduate TAs are inherently inferior instructors, that large universities never offer meaningful interaction with professors, and that class sizes will always be impersonal. At the same time, they romanticize small colleges as communities filled with intellectuals who spend their evenings discussing ideas rather than drinking, while reducing large universities to little more than party schools.
The reality is that outstanding professors, terrible professors, engaged students, disengaged students, close-knit communities, and party cultures exist at institutions of every size. Large universities often have honors colleges, living learning communities, undergraduate research opportunities, and departments where upper-level classes are very small. Small colleges can have mediocre instruction, limited course offerings, and social scenes that are just as alcohol-centered as big campuses.
Often, they don’t look at the tradeoffs. A small college may offer more personal attention but fewer majors, classes, state-of-the-art research labs, professors engaged in both research and teaching, or extracurricular options. A large university may require more initiative to find your community, but it also offers an enormous range of academic, social, and professional opportunities.
Neither model is bad, just different. The mistake is assuming that stereotypes about size accurately predict the undergraduate experience. There are some kids who would flounder in a big school, but not near as many of them as parents think. Most college bound kids can succeed and thrive in a big university, and the better the student, the more that’s true. The great students have the initiative, the professors notice them, and they end up with amazing opportunities at the cutting edge of their fields.
To SJ2727’s point above, this goes in the whole research area of “signaling”, which won a Nobel Prize for Mike Spence et al. Signaling is more important to how society operates than people generally give credit to, and I believe it’s why so many high schoolers want to attend “college”, and why so many highly qualified high schoolers want to attend the so-called “T20 colleges”. It is a vastly underrated gift to be able to “shift the burden of proof”: meaning, the gatekeepers you encounter in life will assume having a college degree or an elite school in your background means you are smart and will add value… unless and until you demonstrate otherwise. So to OP’s original question “Is it worth it?”, the answer is generally positive.
To NUM’s point above, I doubt that highly qualified high schoolers (and their more emotionally mature parents) bank on getting into a T20 and I doubt they feel that not getting into one translates into annus horribilis. They’re smart enough to know better, simply because we all know there is randomness to college admissions. But at the same time, there is nothing wrong with targeting one of those “T20 outcomes”. So yes, even the most qualified kid should aim broadly, but I would also encourage them to aim high, and celebrating with them if they succeed.
Too often (and now I’m not talking about NUM), I see active discouragement for applying to the top schools, and an undertone of “the T20’s aren’t really worth it” / “you can do better if only you chose more carefully”. In counterpoint, I would say, “yes, they are absolutely worth it, they can be cheaper than your in-state option because the private ones are so wealthy, and they provide invaluable signaling effects far beyond your first job…. but at the same time you can still have a wonderful life if you don’t get into one, and you shouldn’t attend Dartmouth if you dislike being very remote, or MIT if you dislike STEM”.
The top 20 may indeed be “worth it” for numerous attendees. The question really is, what about the next 21-40, or 41-60, or any number of private schools that also cost $100,000 per year for a full-pay student? Likely not for all but a few, very specialized, paths.
Perhaps more accurately, the name of the college can say something about what kind of achiever the person was in high school at the time they were in high school (and/or at their first college if they transferred to the college they graduated from).
Well, they will have a college GPA/coursework so it’s a bit more than that.
No signal is 100%. There are people who graduated from West Point who turn out to be cowards and liars, regardless of the honor code and the leadership training. There are people who take an oath to protect and defend the Constitution who spend their time undermining and/or violating said oath.
It’s a signal, not a guarantee.
So just as a basic issue, I don’t see the point in letting the US News National Universities list dictate to me what “aiming high” should mean to me. Like I am fine with wanting to get as much as you can afford out of your college experience, but using that list to tell you which colleges that means for you personally will never really make sense to me.
And that point is so obvious to me I always start looking for some other purpose that using the US News National Universities list like that could more plausibly be serving. And I don’t think it is too hard to see what in fact it is really being used to do in most cases.
And no, general signalling isn’t the explanation, because surveys suggest the vast majority of people don’t know the US News rankings of any colleges. Like, many college kids don’t even know the US News ranking of their OWN college.
But sure, if in their specific limited social circles, US News National Universities rankings are treated as markers of status for certain kids, or perhaps their parents, then that does provide an explanation of why those specific kids and parents may be so wedded to using those particular rankings to dictate their college choices.
I think the key question is less “Is a $100k college worth it?” and more “Is the additional $25k–$30k per year buying something the student actually needs?”
For some students, the answer may be yes because of a particular program, recruiting pipeline, location, or financial aid situation. But if two schools offer similar opportunities, I’d have a hard time justifying a large premium purely for prestige.
I’d also compare the four-year net cost, not the published cost of attendance, and think about how much debt the student would graduate with. A $100k price tag can mean very different things for a family receiving substantial aid versus one paying the full amount.
For me, the biggest test would be: What specifically are we getting for the extra $100k? If there isn’t a clear answer, the cheaper option probably deserves serious consideration.
But remember, we’re talking about signaling. As it relates to signaling, remember that the US News rankings aren’t tailored for “you” specifically. Rather, they indicate how “others” perceive a set of schools. So if your goal is to send “signals” to others, then the US News list (and similar lists) help you do exactly that.
As analogy, suppose you want to use your dress accessories to send signals around yourself: you personally may think the handbag from Macy’s is just perfect for YOU, but the one that will more likely indicate wealth & status is the Hermès Birkin bag. Similarly, Fordham may be the ideal school for you, but it is undeniable that Harvard “signals” more.
Well, of course it is axiomatic in this discussion that we’re talking about sending “signals” to people who know or care about such signals. There is no point is carrying around your Birkin handbag instead of your Macy’s bag if you’re with an audience who is clueless to such signals or don’t value the difference. Just as I’m sure that many gatekeepers only care that you attended college (of any flavor), and it doesn’t matter whether Fordham or Harvard.
To the OP’s point is “is paying $100K for college really worth it”, I come back to saying “yes, it is worth it if you can afford it” because parents and kids intuitively understand that the ability to send signals (i.e., shift the burden of proof) is so valuable throughout your whole life. It is not just for evanescent bragging rights at the next PTA meeting.
But do they?
A lot of the US News methodology has nothing to do with that.
You could of course strip out the Peer Assessment scores and just look at those, but then you run into the problem that US News has carved up the college universe by the old Carnegie classifications (not even the current ones). But if you really wanted, you could assume the Peer Assessment scores meant roughly the same thing no matter the Carnegie classification, and bodge together a Peer Assessment-only ranking.
I don’t see a lot of people who talk about T20s doing that, however. They just take the US News National Universities list at face value, and ignore the other Carnegie classification lists entirely. And that’s not what you would do if you were actually serious about real world perceptions and signaling in that sense.
But of course if in your social circles, or your parents’ social circles, people use the latest US News National Universities rankings to keep score, then that might explain this behavior. Then it doesn’t matter what methodology the US News is actually using this year, doesn’t matter that they have put other colleges on other lists, it just is whatever it is, because that is how your social circle has decided to keep score.
I note the actual empirical work I have seen on broad public perceptions of colleges indicate there are something like four that have an actual broad reputation for academic excellence. Harvard is definitely one of those, also Yale, probably MIT, and probably Stanford. After that, the number of people with much impression of their relative academic excellence rapidly dives.
As far as I can tell, this is explained by pop culture using that short list repeatedly. Like if a character in your TV show or movie is supposed to be very smart, you write they went to Harvard. Maybe Yale if they are supposed to be a nice and/or creative person. MIT if a science or math person. Stanford if on the West Coast. And that’s about it. Other colleges get used very, very infrequently in comparison for such pop culture purposes, and so most people just don’t have similar impressions.
I do note many people have some impressions of colleges in terms of specific sports, but that is a different matter. And similarly driven by them actually following college sports.
OK, so the US News then ranks something like 1700 colleges. Pretty much no one has impressions of that many colleges academically. And again, not many people have much in the way of academic impressions outside of those few repeat players in pop culture.
OK, so of course it is not wrong to say Harvard creates a stronger impression among many people than Fordham, because Harvard is one of those few pop culture schools that many people know about.
What is not true is you can look up Fordham’s current US News ranking (which I had to do–#97 as it turns out), and then assume many people have the impression any college, not just Harvard, above Fordham in the rankings is a better “signal”.
Like Case Western is #51 (also had to look that up). I am quite confident most people have no real impression of either Case Western or Fordham, and therefore no impression of how Case Western and Fordham compare academically, what attending one of them would signal, or so on.
Case Western is then tied at #51 with Florida State. Now, Florida State they may have heard of . . . for sports. But they would still have no impression of how Florida State compared to Fordham academically, including because they would likely have no real impression of Fordham at all.
OK, and then the current “T20” includes Carnegie Mellon in the tie (I actually already knew that one, to my shame). And, once again, most people will have no real impression of CMU. Also in the tie is Notre Dame, and they will be WAAAAAY better known, but people still won’t know how it compares to Fordham.
Again, you can keep doing this, and from what I have seen, it really does get down to just that true handful of pop culture schools. And you don’t need the US News to tell you about those schools.
But as soon as people would need to consult the US News National Universities rankings (or memorize them) to know where the US News ranked a couple colleges respectively, then the US News National Universities rankings are no longer telling you anything important about “signaling” . . . beyond the small fraction of people who have memorized the US News National Universities rankings.
Fair enough, so who is that exactly?
Again, I think the honest answer is the people who really care about these signals care about what people close to them think. Like, very, very often when I am talking to kids online about why they are restricting their consideration to such schools, it turns out that in some way, it is because their parents are making them.
So, if you like, the kid is trying to send a signal to their parents. Fair enough, but then why do the parents care?
When talking to parents, sometimes it starts with the parent saying they care about things like job placement, generous need aid, and so on, and they heard somewhere the T20s or whatever are best for that stuff. And if you then help them explore alternatives, they sometimes seem very relieved to learn nothing like that is as exclusive of a club as that.
Other times, though . . . parents can get very defensive about maintaining this “signal”. But to who? And I do think the likely answer is their own tight circles–maybe their own immediate family, work colleagues, and other people they know who might talk about where their kids are going to college.
And so why do those people care? Because they are in the same social circles.
So I do think that closes the loop. People in these very specific social circles use the US News National Universities rankings for comparing the kids associated with them, or signaling about those kids if you prefer. Indeed, I think a lot of this is that telling people where your kid got on the US News National Universities rankings is supposed to signal something about the parents themselves to these other people in the parents’ immediate family and social circles.
And I can’t question it works in that way for them. But I don’t think it is good for the kids.
Sorry, I meant to address this.
I actually went to one of those four pop culture colleges, and it has not been very valuable for most of my life. I think most of my college friends agree. Not that people don’t think it is a good school still, it just doesn’t do much for me that they think that.
And then beyond those schools–again, if the T20 signal’s value is limited to people who have recently memorized the US News National Universities T20, then in fact who else is that but the people at your PTA meeting who actually did that? Because it isn’t most people out in the world.
But in the real world- where the non-Cc parents live- colleges are not an amorphous blob.
If your kid is at a Catholic HS, you’ve got a different pecking order than a kid at Roxbury Latin or Stuyvesant. And if your kid is at Bronx HS of Science (or any other exam-entry public HS) the pecking order is different than if your kid is at a pricey prep school- whether a “feeder” or not.
Your description ignores the fact that the US is not a monoculture.
I was at a graduation celebration for a kid who was graduating from a NYC public exam HS. First Gen American, first gen college. She was off to Hunter and the family and neighbors were cheering and crying as if she’d won Powerball. I know several work colleagues who are BYU grads- same deal. Whether or not your neighbors know what or where Fordham is is irrelevant. It is both a top destination for kids from a certain religious background or from certain HS’s and is well known to both grad school adcom’s and employers in the NY metro region. It is its own “powerful signal” regardless of whether those BYU families know what it is (or care).
So I may have been unclear. My dream outcome is for every college-bound kid to be excited about where they are going to college. And I don’t want kids to see them all as interchangeable degree-stamping machines, I want them to have strong preferences, which is what feeds into them being excited.
My issue is very specific to using the US News National Universities rankings as a way of forming preferences, particularly when kids are talking about things like T20s. Because if every kid really found only those colleges exciting, it means something like 98+% of college-bound kids couldn’t be excited in the end.
And I know we have wandered a bit, but I do think this is relevant to the “worth it” question. I don’t think any of these colleges is actually worth it if your family cannot comfortably afford to pay what they would cost. But I think if you can comfortably afford these colleges, then very likely you can comfortably afford more. And I would wish for kids, and parents, to be open to those other ALSO being worth it, again assuming it was affordable for them at all.
Because I want as many kids as possible to be excited about where they are going to college.