Is Paying $100,000 for College Really Worth It?

And various forms of public assistance were enough in some parts of the country to help a family catapult into the middle class.

I’d love to see an analysis of the impact of the GI Bill, the VA system, etc. a generation ago vs. now.

1 Like

I’m probably in the minority here, but as a millennial (37 y/o) I had to fund my education for both undergrad and graduate school. I studied theatre and got a BA at a state school, then a few years later I got an MFA in Acting from Juilliard. To date, I have worked extensively on Broadway, off-Broadway, in tv and film, audio plays, readings, workshops and more. I have two 401k’s, two pensions through the unions and over $100k saved. This took 8 years. I’m still paying off federal student loans that total about $150k. Not ideal, but loan forgiveness is on the horizon and I’ve started my own business. My return on the investment is EXCELLENT (to me): I’m happy, financially comfortable and get to do what I love!

12 Likes

People do pay six figures for other stuff whether it is worth it or not, so maybe these schools have done their market research and they are the target audience.

3 Likes

In fact, couldn’t you write a similar article titled, “Sales of Six-Figure Colleges Show No Signs of Slowing”?

That said, these recent enhancements to aid packages for what we might call the lower-upper-middle class could be seen as resulting from the marketing teams identifying some issues in that specific submarket.

ETA: By the way, it is supposed to be illegal to charge different consumer different amounts for the same thing based on assessing willingness to pay. But things like generous need and merit aid would not be considered to violate this rule. Just another way in which a cynical person might suggest these economic entities are getting favorable legal treatment.

6 Likes

Apples and oranges. I’m describing the connections to get into a hedge fund or other Wall Street money making machine, because it’s owned by your college friend’s father. You’re describing someone who creates a tech startup that gets sold. The first happens largely because of social connections; the second, yes, was guided by the two profs but could definitely have happened at schools other than MIT - many state flagship U’s have such people. Taking your argument further, people can be wildly successful without ever going to college, and some are. What I’m pointing out is that for certain students who want certain things, it may be worth paying 100K/yr to be in the wealthy social pool that one finds at the top schools.

1 Like

Just curious–what law are you talking about which makes this illegal? The only one I am aware that prevents price discrimination based on size or wealth is Robinson Patman, and that is applicable only to manufacturers giving large retailers price breaks compared to “mom and pop” stores.

1 Like

I think you misunderstand how most hiring decisions are made. It’s primarily based on assessed merit within the recruiting pool. Knowing someone may help getting a more thorough read by HR, but it rarely goes much further than that. And the reason for that is simple: incompetent people can quickly damage a finance firm.

It’s not the social pool that matters. It’s the recruiting pool defined by the colleges where these firms recruit.

5 Likes

You may be thinking of the fact Robinson-Patman applies only to physical goods and not services, but it does apply to consumers as buyers as well as retailers.

True. And it’s not enforced these days. It was aimed at chain stores like A&P. But there was a big exception:: if one offers a discount to “meet competition “ then that was legal

Even though Robinson Patman doesn’t apply anyway to college tuition, colleges are “meeting competition “.

A colleague whom I had very good relationship with pinged me to let me know her college roommate’s daughter was applying for an analyst position at our firm, and asked if I could help out. I made a point of interviewing her and found her to be a very good applicant, so I sponsored her. If she wasn’t qualified I wouldn’t have hired her, but she was just as good if not better than other applicants. At the same time, if my colleague haven’t asked for a favor I probably wouldn’t have bothered.

7 Likes

Both of my kids went to Cornell. We were full pay, even though price was lower back then. The older one married someone from the same school. Most of her friends have married someone from the same school. They all have jobs that are paying substantial salaries. Some of them are MDs at banks, Partners at law firms, or very senior positions at tech companies. One may say they were all high achievers and probably would have done just as well at other less expensive schools, but I do think by going to a top school increased their odds.
My younger one went to law school, did clerkship and working at a big law firm. All of her jobs and law school applications were helped by people she knew from school, especially earlier law internships.
Like some people said, is it worth it really depends on if you could afford it or where else you would rather spend the money. I am not going to say it was no big deal to pay for private schools from K-college, but I believe it was money well spent. I can’t stop thinking how much more I would have today if I didn’t pay for it. :slight_smile:

6 Likes

Cornell, the other Ivies, MIT, Duke, Cal Tech and maybe U. Chicago and one or two others are likely worth the big bucks at least for some students, but all of the other expensive private schools of various levels of prestige? Not usually!

1 Like

Not right for YOUR kid is not the same as not right for everyone else’s kid.

A neighbor of mine stretched to send one of his kids to a full pay private U with a generally “it’s fine” reputation. Kid wanted to become a mechanical engineer, and nobody who had ever taught the kid (or sat next to him in math class) thought this was an achievable goal. Lovely kid. Math not his strong suit. The “Any ABET engineering program” crowd would drop snarky remarks because our own state flagship has a respectable ME major at half the cost of the pricey private. Neighbor would point out that he- as a HS kid- also wanted engineering, but lasted two semesters in engineering at a large flagship until his advisor, his professors, and the Dean persuaded him that with his GPA he would never work as an engineer. So he switched to accounting and has had a fine career doing something he claims he’s hated from the git-go. And like many of us, wanted more for his kid.

Who is now an engineer, working his dream job at an aerospace company which is exactly what he dreamed of when he was struggling in math in HS. Turns out that this full pay private U is MUCH better at keeping kids in engineering than the big flagship U. Academic support, tutoring, as many group study sessions as the kids need– and most important, LOTS of handholding counseling. Feeling dismayed that you got a C on the midterm when you studied your brains out? A tutor can help you review your answers and see if the issue is calculation or conceptual. The advisor’s job isn’t just to tell you “go to office hours”- it’s to connect you with the right resources.

Was it worth it? Kid stuck it out in engineering, is working his dream job in his chosen industry, they couldn’t be happier. As the dad told me recently- “I could leave him cash when I die- or I could give him the career he wanted and worked so hard to achieve. The math is easy even if you aren’t a CPA”.

15 Likes

I note the Chetty studies, and other studies, have found that for advantaged kids, going to an Ivy+ instead of another very selective private or higher-quality flagship public is very likely to make no statistically significant difference in career earnings. The Chetty studies found after controls there was something on the order of a 5% chance it resulted in significantly higher career earnings. And even then, they didn’t really look at LACs, and arguably didn’t go a great job controlling for self-selection effects.

That’s not the only possible definition of “worth it”, but I do think it is helpful for people to know.

Of course this is less suggesting other full pay privates are worth it, and more suggesting if you don’t think most full pay privates are worth it, making exceptions for the Ivy+ might be fairly hard to justify in ROI terms. Like if turning down some merit or in-state offers would cost you $200K more in initial investment, and there is only a 5% chance of a higher return, well, that’s pretty challenging math.

3 Likes

Challenging math because with the money you save you are going to become a tech titan by investing in your next startup idea?

Most people who brag about how smart they were by their “ROI” because they did not pay full freight do remarkably dumb things with that money. They buy a boat…a classic money pit. They rip out their patio and install a professional grade pizza oven and hot tub. They buy a fancy watch when their cruise ship docks in Hamilton.

These things have negative ROI in virtually every case. You want to take a cruise to Bermuda? Terrific. But don’t pretend you evaluated the ROI of your kid going to private U vs. state flagship in order to do so. People’s consumption habits usually reveal the stacked deck.

3 Likes

It’s a nice story but we don’t know that the kid wouldn’t have been in the same place at the lower cost school.

I’m not against the premise - the family made a decision, was able to pay and that’s their choice.

But no one can say the outcome would have been different at the other school which no doubt has support as well of the student sought it out.

But in the end, all are happy and if no one is on the government dole, that’s all fine to me.

1 Like

This appears to be a counterpoint to the oft-repeated assertion that kids and families aiming for the US News “T20” are simply chasing after peer competition and bragging rights.

“The majority of schools on the US News ranking of colleges with the best ROI are T20’s.”

https://www.usnews.com/education/best-colleges/paying-for-college/slideshows/national-universities-liberal-arts-colleges-with-the-best-roi

It’s a US News article making the quoted claim implying US News ranking is meaningful. The actual top 6 ROI schools listed in the referenced Georgetown analysis that US News claims to be using as a source are below. However, the USNWR article ignores 4 of the listed top 6, only including Mudd and MIT. I expect the US News list is saying that among the colleges that appear on the top USNWR national, LAC, or regional lists, 13 of top 22 from ROI list appear in one of the top 20 USNWR ranking lists, which is a majority.

Highest 40 year ROI Colleges (most recent available year)
1 . St. Louis Pharmacy
2. Harvey Mudd
3. MIT
4. Albany Pharmacy
5. MA Pharmacy
6. Olin Engineering

The bigger issue is that the ROI list is near meaningless, as it does not control for majors or student differences at different colleges (admission selectivity, test scores, …). Colleges that have a larger portion of students going in to higher earning fields like pharmacy, engineering, and business/finance tend to have higher earnings. Colleges that have larger portion of students that are high achieving tend to have higher earnings. The ROI list also considers average price after FA for federal FA recipients (mostly Pell grant kids), not sticker price, so colleges with a high enough endowment per student to have especially generous FA for Pell grant recipients tend to have better ROI. For example, the ROI ranking is computed assuming that Princeton costs $6k per year.

All 3 of these metrics (high enough endowment to be low cost for Pell grant recipients, more selective, more likely to pursue higher earning fields) are correlated with USNWR ranking, so not surprising that there is a correlation between USNWR ranking and listed ROI rank. However, this does not imply USNWR is the driving force for ROI.

When controlling for such factors, the results can look quite different. Quoting the previous referenced Chetty study, "Admission to an Ivy-Plus college has no significant impact on predicted mean income rank. We similarly find no significant effect on actual mean income rank at age 33 . "

2 Likes

Nor does it disprove the notion that some folks chasing Top 20’s are doing so for bragging rights.

1 Like

Yes- but bragging rights come in all shapes and sizes. I have a work colleague who spent from middle school through HS making sure her kid would get into SMU. And then four years bragging about it when she was successful at it. Military families brag about their kid getting into the Naval Academy (as well they should); the families at my local parochial HS are vocal about Notre Dame vs. Georgetown vs. BC– and the “horror” if your kid ends up at Seton Hall or Providence despite being a double legacy at one of the former, and lovely supporting notes from their parish priest.

It’s convenient to dump on the Ivy bragging crowd- but reality on the ground suggests that parents like to brag about their kids.

7 Likes