And vice versa :-). People end up where they want to.
Not true according to my kid who graduated. According to my kid, it’s membership in the finance club which seems to be the most important variable at the university she attended. The IB kids appear to graduate with the least rigorous major at the school and the firms don’t seem to care. My kid knows several classmates who got jobs at GS with GPAs less than that.
That is interesting. Good to know. Which school is this at?
University of Chicago
To some extent, yes. But as you said earlier, kids need to know career pathways even exist, and they need to have access to the road. This is where parents, schools and peers come in. But yes, I think there would be no amount of encouragement that could convince either of my kids to have chosen any career that had to do with money.
Are they graduating with Business Economics?
In my experience, yes.
When I looked at the students in one IB club, pretty much all (95%+) had some economics major. Hard to figure out whether its business or standard track from LinkedIn, but business is supposed to be 50 - 60% of economics majors in general and higher among the crowd going into IB.
Yes. It’s a very popular major. It’s a completely different level of rigor compared to the regular economics major which has a very high dropout rate.
I’m sorry, but no amount of prep will help a kid who had the bad luck of being born to parents on the bottom 80% of households by income, unless the kid was instead of being lucky to be born to wealth and privilege, was lucky enough to be born with either 10X the smarts of their own peers. A kid who was not lucky enough to be born to low income parents and was not lucky enough to be born with “smarts” has almost no chance of succeeding, no matter how hard they work.
Yes, “smarts” is just one more type of luck.
It’s mostly luck, and hard work is just what takes you ahead of other people who have had as much luck as you have. To beat people with more luck, either in family situation or innate talent, you have to work harder. At a certain point, no amount of hard work will compensate for bad luck in talent and family wealth and other privilege.
However, the kids who are born with that sort of bad luck will not have parents who are able to pay $10,000 a year or likely even $1,000 a year, much less $100,000 a year for college
Well said!
My oldest did not have a 3.9 gpa. He was not a member of a competitive finance club. He did not go to an ivy+ school. He still ended up at Goldman Sachs.
That is wonderful. Congratulations to him. There are no false positives in an industry that is very hard to get into. He must be very good in ways that are not measured by grades etc
We can agree to disagree. I think we may have discussed some variant of this in the past. I don’t disagree that environmental factors are important and clearly luck is involved here. But I come from a country where people that are fairly poor (although perhaps not destitute) have done exceptionally well both in that country, and some have immigrated here and have done exceptionally well here as well. Some of them run very large companies here. I don’t give much credit to parental wealth as a factor in all this success, because all those people had very poor parents. It is just focus and work, and lack of confusion as to what is needed to succeed in life. In fact where I come from, rich people do poorly in academics, because the kids are not hungry and not motivated. Middle class kids are exceptionally motivated. And middle class kids where i come from have much fewer resources than poor kids here. For example,‘I grew up in a middle class family. Many of us did not have a tv until I was well into high school. We did not have phone in the house, of any kind. We had one two wheeler vehicle for the whole family for transportation. We may buy one pair of new clothes a year. But there is no confusion that if you don’t study, there is no hope. I don’t buy into this wealth is required to do well argument. My kids went to the public library and read. One of them took the SAT in 7th grade and got a 1550. The reading habit did not need money. He wasn’t killing himself. He would sleep at 10pm. Watch tv with us etc. You just need to go to the public library.
There is no question that I was born into a family in the bottom 80% of household incomes…back in the Stone Age. But my single mom valued education and sacrificed a lot so we could live in a town with a fabulous school district. I was always a hard worker, and continued to be in college. I had a nice assistantship in grad school based on my hard work in undergrad, and my recommendations from my employers.
And I didn’t go to an elite college.
I didn’t work in quant or finance but I had a very rewarding career. And that matters.
Why does UChicago have two different Econ majors?
I personally think it’s a big mistake in the long-term. As this is off-topic, this will be my only post about this.
UChicago’s strength IMO is that it is known for its intellectualism and rigor, whether students majored in English, Philosophy, Math, CS, or the original Econ program. It also had a huge emphasis on its liberal arts core, and the result was that you would have the Math, CS, and English majors all enjoying discussing Kant over drinks.
About 8 years ago, they introduced Business Econ, which gets rid of most of the rigor UChicago was known for, and watered this new Econ degree down to the level of other Ivy League colleges. This makes UChicago more pre-professional, with more students interested in the outcome rather than the process of learning.
As to why they did that? It’s about the money. UChicago made poor investments for decades, and therefore ended with a smaller endowment compared to some of its academic peers. But students interested in the outcomes from Business Economics are both more likely to come from higher income families, and likely to do well afterwards, and hopefully contribute to UChicago.
Thanks. Princeton has one Econ degree, and kids can take three different tracks within it. I don’t believe they are spelled out (I am not a 100% sure about this) but interested parties such as grad school admissions committees can pour through the transcript and make their own assessment. I believe informally these tracks are referred to as frat track, math track, and grad track.
Or less rigor, at least in math, since Chicago business economics does not list calculus as a requirement (most economics and business majors at highly selective colleges have at least calculus as a requirement).
That is what I added the “unless” (which you cut from your quote*), because there are other ways to be lucky aside from being born in a wealthy family. You were lucky to be born smart in ways that allowed to to acquire the skills that you needed, and you were lucky to have been born with an amazing mother.
My point was, and remains, that people vastly overestimate the extant to which their own effort is responsible for their success. The wealthy are generally the worst at this, but everybody is guilty of this.
*and which I also seemed to have dropped a line from.
Of course, a generation or few ago, upward mobility was higher and economic inequality was lower.