Is Paying $100,000 for College Really Worth It?

Whether or not paying $100,000 a year for college is worth it depends upon a family’s financial situation and values.

As an aside, it seems clear that I have been on CC too long as my instant response to both issues noted above regarding college and buying a Bentley was to apply for financial aid, then I realized that Bentley dealerships are probably “need-aware” and do not provide need based financial aid.

9 Likes

Students who would be at the bottom of the class at ASU would be nowhere close to being admitted to Harvard.

1 Like

These posts are hilarious.

1 Like

You are partly right on early prep but there are enough high achieving STEM kids who take a lot of AP classes and then discover these careers later in college. As far as exposure to similar thinking kids, I remember when my son got into Berkeley almost all of his best friends were shocked. They were an eclectic set of kids who only talked about gaming, basketball and made silly music videos for fun. Other than an inkling due to his AP classes schedule nobody had a clue about his goals or grades.

Early exposure is always helpful but it’s not necessary for success. The kids with the raw smarts can always get to places once they lock in.

6 Likes

I don’t believe in smarts for the most part :-). I think much of life is 95% prep, 4% luck, and maybe 1% smarts.

works in volumes where offer rates are <1% :winking_face_with_tongue:

I don’t mean kids are consciously prepping. I mean some kids just learn very early, how to learn, and by the time they come to junior year of college, starting in kindergarten, they are far apart from other kids out of deep passion and immersion. Access to some professions becomes trivial at that point. They may look smart from the outside, but I think that is a poor characterization.

1 Like

I’m late to the thread and saw the heading and thought, “Well, we certainly thought it was worth it to pay close to $100,O00 for college for each of our 3 kids.”

Then I realized this meant per year, not per kid!

:rofl::rofl::rofl:

7 Likes

And maybe these are the same kids who take the full ride to Pitt rather than pay full cost at Vanderbilt. Are those kids successful? My answer is yes.

And round and round we go….

Do what works for your family.

7 Likes

I would replace the word “prep” with hard work. Merriam Webster defines preparation as the action or process of making something ready for use or service or of getting ready for some occasion, test, or duty. Hard work can include preparation, but it includes so much more.

3 Likes

Sure. If you want to be picky, kids that are seriously engaged don’t think of it as hardwork.

The share of such students that might get such quant roles is not very high. Perhaps 2-3% of UChicago students get quant positions. And that’s supposedly a top 10 feeder into the industry (lags MIT I admit).

1 Like

I think kids who are seriously engaged can be smart and also think of it as hard work.

You will find these students at colleges that come in at all price points.

3 Likes

We’re a full-pay family who will send our S26 to Wesleyan in the fall. I’m so excited for him. It’s a terrific fit for who he is and I haven’t thought about ROI in terms of his future career or earning potential. I only want him to make the most of the wonderful education on offer, one that will shape him and inspire him for the rest of his life. He will sort out what he wants to do professionally and I hope it grows out of the knowledge he gains about himself while in college. I hope he makes lifelong friends, tries new things, surprises himself, fails sometimes in a safe place that helps pick him back up and learn from his mistakes. I realize I am very fortunate to be able to pay for Wesleyan, and I’m also proud of us for making decisions that have made it possible. We are not generationally wealthy, the money is not a “nothingburger” for us, but I am happy to spend it. So, yes, to me paying $100K a year is really worth it.

24 Likes

That number is not so bad. Math, Stats and CS make up about 20% of UChicago. You are saying that 10% of these majors place into quant. At Princeton, the numbers are more like 10% of 30% – CS used to be 15%, and Pure Math used to be some 2-3%, applied math maybe more like 6-7% (called orfe) and another 2-3% of the kids in Physics. The kids in engg usually show little interest. So we are talking about 25-30% of the undergrad class have majors that are aligned, and about 10% of them go into quant – so again about 3% or a bit more. Similarly, I doubt MIT has more than 10% of their enrollment goes into quant, but they have probably 80-90% in Physics/Math/CS. That is what makes their presence seem larger. What is perhaps more conspicuous though is that probably MIT kids have better placements within quant – there is a spectrum of quality among the various quant firms, and the median MIT kid probably places better than the median some other university kid.

3 Likes

You’ve said beautifully what I referred to earlier about ROI not just being a future earnings stream.

8 Likes

I have 2 kids. One just graduated from college. One is still in college. They both told me that for certain niche professions like IB and quant, the name of the school and the clubs they belong to (for IB) are extremely important. For IB, those 2 associations matter more than academic achievement or major at their university. This is purely anecdotally, since neither is pursuing a career in those professions.

I think part of the issue is the most competitive highly-compensated finance entry-level positions are SO competitive, everything can potentially matter. And there is some cyclicality too, so you don’t know what it will look like your graduating year.

But of course there is way more to finance in general than that, and you can also do a “normal” finance job for a while, then go back for a finance MBA or masters, and then look for entry points at that level.

So while I think it is fine to consider these issues, as usual I don’t think you should take on excessive financial or opportunities costs to try to marginally improve your chances at just a small handful of certain highly competitive finance positions available directly out of college.

1 Like

I always thought that IB needs a gpa that is 3.9 on the low end. In a rigorous major. And strong networking skills. I always take the gpa very seriously because it indicates work ethic and attention to detail. I assume other people may also look at it the same way.

1 Like

I understand your point. In college, I took ballroom dance lessons with a fellow student who did well each year on the Putnam (as in he scored points each year :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:.) We were great dance partners and became good friends. But this did not make it possible for me to take the Putnam. I would have had to go back in time many years to get on that train.

2 Likes