Corey singing When I See You Smile.
I am kind of underwhelmed tonight.
Corey’s performance was the weakest so far tonight, imo.
Koryn closing it with alicia keyes, this girl is on fire. I didn’t want to bum anyone out, I wasn’t jumping up and down for anyone.
Ok…bottom 3?
I liked Koryn, but it wasn’t a perfect performance. I do think she has grown more than others on the show.
Hannah has got to go. I’d like to see Meghan follow her out the door. I just really can’t stand the braying part of her voice, and I’m sorry but her habitual facial expression just annoys the hell out of me. Although Corey was better than last week, and I continue to like his voice, as a performer he just hasn’t got it.
Everyone else was good.
I must be in a good mood tonight. 
I thought all of the performances were pretty solid and it just boils down to personal preference. The opening group number was actually good. Blake and Matt were good.
My bottom three would be Joshua, Meghan and Hannah.
I would not mind if Joshua went home. He does nothing for me. He is nice looking and seems like a great guy, but I can’t imagine who he appeals to. He has a very nice and soothing voice, but it does not move me in any way except maybe to go to sleep! All the camera shots of his wife and babies makes him too much of a family guy to appeal to the younger girls. I think he is talented, but is boring to me.
I thought Meghan was too screechy in parts of that song. She might be in jeopardy.
Hannah had to go first and I’ve already forgotten her performance.
I thought Corey’s performance was his best to date. He should get through one more time.
I love Over the Rainbow and India did not ruin it, so she is safe in my book.
Well, this was an evening worthy of American Idol. Mediocre and boring performances with crappy overproduction. Oh, and a truly horrendous guest who fits a bad evening to a tee. Prediction? Sawyer, Joshua, and Kimberley will get most votes and this based on the past weeks and not tonight’s.
Fwiw, the CW posse should save Corey. And rightfully so!
Xiggi, those 3 are doing the best on itunes. Sawyer is crushing it.
Meghan, Hannah and Koryn are in trouble right now.
Corey is in good shape so far…
Okay, I have a very good sound system this week, and I do not like the opening number at all. Didn’t hear anyone that sounded great, too much vibrato from every single girl. And I want to slap Hannah on both cheeks in rapid succession, if you know what I mean, as I doubt I can say that word on this forum. Yuck! I’m hoping this gets a lot better.
I think Kimberly was great!
Just saw Hannah, now I really want to puke, she is so annoying. Joshua is going to make it through on this one. Not crazy about the song arrangement, how the words were rushed together in parts, but still good.
Meghan is the worst she’s been this week. That was awful.
Really liked Kimberly’s performance this time.
I agree that Kimberley was particularly good this week. (Again. )
I missed the group number, which is usually no loss. I thought Blake’s new song was really sub par. Blah and instantly forgettable.
Here Consolation, I’ll help you remember it. Your lips taste like San-griiiiii-a!
I thought Kimberly was good, but I doubt I’d want to listen to her on the radio. Not crazy about Meghan’s performance, just kind of screechy and too much yelling. And it seems wrong to have someone who has been a professional for ten years competing in this competition.
“And it seems wrong to have someone who has been a professional for ten years competing in this competition.”
I agree.
And Sawyer just finished the best performance he’s given so far. I may actually download the song to my phone. A really intriguing sound.
Sawyer was awesome.
Talk about overpraising… Corey did not sound great, though he gives a very nice performance, his voice is just weak. Blake completely overdid it.
I thought Koryn was really good, but she seemed awfully nervous, and it detracted from her performance.
Compared to the ladies, the guys opening number sounded like a Grammy award winning performance. The ladies were off-key, off the beat, and LATE!
musicmom, you are so lucky that you can forget Hannah’s performance. It’s going to haunt me for days.
I am a Kimberly fan but did not enjoy her performance tonight.
Meghan is in trouble after that performance. Poor genre, song choice, set, wardrobe, styling, etc. I am really shaking my head with her choices.
India was okay but the whole performance, set, and styling was weird for me.
Joshua’s performance is really “holding up” so far, compared to all the subpar performances.
Sawyer gave his best performance so far, imo. It gained momentum as it went along, he didn’t get overpowered by the band, and he showed more emotion. He is in a class by himself. He has such broad appeal.
I thought CKW gave a really solid performance. He’s becoming my 2nd favorite male singer after tonight and think he will be Blake’s last teammate standing.
Koryn gets a nasal sound in her upper register that I find really annoying. I don’t think she will be going home… yet.
The guys were all solid tonight.