There are so many schools. You need to make some visits and decide on things you would like-size, location and such. You will be competitive, but so will many of the students applying to the schools on your list. Make sure you apply to some true safeties where the admit rate is great than 60%. Since you seem to be ok coming east, maybe look at some competitive smaller schools such as Wake Forest, William and Mary, University of Richmond. They are selective, but not as impossible as Duke and the Ivys.