Meeting Daughters boyfriend

<p>I tend to agree with those who say the best course is simply to meet the BF and have a nice meal with him and D. Once kids are beyond a certain age, parents have to step back and let their kids make their own decisions when it comes to who they are with. That doesn’t mean we have no right to an opinion or to give feedback where we think we need to but it has to be used judiciously. I don’t care whether the kid has been on their own since 16 and totally supported themselves, or we continue to help them, there are areas where they have to make their own decisions and where our role is limited to sparingly giving advice. Yeah, kids are going to crash and burn, they are going to find losers, they were going to find winners (for them) we consider losers, but it is their life, we don’t own them and quite honestly the only thing they owe us is to go out and try and live the best life they can. Obviously, if my son was dating someone I thought had serious issues, where I saw signs of what I thought was mental illness or drug use, for example, my reaction would be different then let’s say I didn’t like the way she dressed.</p>

<p>I also would hope they both would feel comfortable with my wife and myself, that they enjoyed being around us though obviously we can’t always control that. One poster said it was more a test of the BF being accepted by them then vice versa (whether in jest or not I don’t know), but I don’t agree, quite honestly while our children are always our children, they are going to live their own lives as they see fit, and if we assume we are going to be part of their lives no matter how we act we might be in for a big surprise.</p>

<p>“Traditional” cultures often have this idea that “FAMILY” comes before “family” (i.e the birth family and the various appendages weights more heavily then our own, created family) but that to me is crap; if relatives are nasty, if they are people you don’t want to be around, if they act in ways if it was someone outside the family you would kick the crap out of them verbally or otherwise, why would you put up with it simply because “it is family”…having lived through that I look back now and say why, why would I want to put myself or my own family in the line of fire of that? Among other things, it gives nasty family members carte blanche to act the way they want and not expect repurcussions (and yes, that includes parental in laws as well). If you assume that no matter what you do, that your child and their spouse will accept it, you are also heading for a situation where you are locked out of their lives. Obviously, that doesn’t mean putting up with bad behavior either as a parent, if the BF is a loudmouthed boor who insults you, or makes clear he wants nothing to do with you, then you have every right to protect yourselves as well; the point is, it needs to be a two way street of mutual respect, if not love. For me, I respect and love my son too much to denigrate his choices and even if I don’t particularly like someone he is with, I will make the effort to respect his choices and be as kind as I can be, as long as the reverse relationship is respectful as well.</p>

<p>

I love that idea. I think I will order a pair for me and H. that Hilarious. Good icebreaker.</p>

<p>I didn’t meet my oldests current boyfriend till she had been going out with him over a year.(her sister knew about him though)
Unfortunately, it was a bad weekend. I had scheduled a “relaxing weekend” in D’s city, because I had been under a lot of stress. Combination of my mothers recent (& unexpected death)& the extended decline of our 16yr old lab for whom I was the primary caretaker. However shortly before I was to leave, it looked like our dog was not able to rally anymore, and the day I left was the same day my H & our youngest took our dog to the vet for the last time.
So while I was happy to meet her BF & I took them out to dinner, I was more interested in talking to D and sharing our memories.</p>

<p>(she has now been going out with him for about four years & living with him for one)
They are both finishing up grad school, so they are stressed, but they seem happy. That is enough for me. ( well no- not really but she doesn’t often ask for advice):wink: I want different things for her than what she wants- but I recognize that is my problem not hers.</p>

<p>Anecdotal evidence nonwithstanding, there is a big paint brush that is being used to paint an entire set of situations into the same solution. </p>

<p>In practice, there’s a big difference between 16, 18, 20, 22, and 24 years. The 16 year old is not hearing wedding bells or a long term relationship - the 24 year old, maybe. The 20 year old college junior has a totally different outlook than the 18 year old freshman. The only common theme (for all except the 24’er and then maybe even her) is the degree of financial support from First National Bank of Dad…</p>

<p>We can pretend that **all **18-20 year olds are adults; the ones working three jobs in fast food are adults, definitely. The trustfundarians, not so, not by my definition at least. </p>

<p>And, don’t think for a moment that it does not work both ways. After a year I met DD1 SO’s family. They’re quite the bunch, solidly in the 1% money wise, honest-to-goodness engineer CEO dad (but their kids are well ‘landed’ and the money has not gotten to their heads as much as I would have feared) and a superbly educated mom. While we chatted I had the familiar sense of dread that I was being RSAT’d in return (let’s just say that I do not inspire much confidence or maturity :)) We have a lot more in common than I thought… They’re also not native US born… Not Elbonians tho :(</p>

<p>Fast forward a couple semesters, our kids are happy in the same OOS state flagship, we share driving during breaks, and it has worked out quite well.</p>

<p>You were all so kind, i just wanted to bring this thread up and give an update: We met my D boyfriend around Easter 2012 at a restaurant in Greenwich Village, and he is really a very nice young man, was able to have a wonderful conversation with us both and they are very cute together. They have officially celebrated their one year anniversary of being together this month. He actually took a chance and moved to NY to be with her from his hometown 3 hrs away when she graduated from College in May. They are both living together and working fulltime in Manhattan. We meet them on occasion for dinner in the city.We are very happy for them both. I try to be not so vested in everything, just in case, but its hard not to when you see the happiness in your child. Life is funny. You never know the direction it takes, just that its a journeyand you are on the ride!</p>

<p>Thanks for the update, m&s. It is nice that you get together from time to time with your D and her BF and that you can see how happy your D is, which is all that truly matters. </p>

<p>Since I shared earlier in this thread, D2 is still with her boyfriend of now more than 3 years (she is 24 and he is 26) and they have been friends for more than 6 years. They live close to one another but not together. I see him when I go to NYC. He even contacted me to go into together on a fairly big Hanukah gift for D. Like last year, his family in Ohio invited my D to spend a week with them for the holidays and she is there now. I have no idea about the future but am supportive of D and her BF and it seems his family is too. And my kid is happy and that’s the best of all.</p>

<p>There is an old saw that when you meet/observe a girl’s mother, you’re seeing the future. Some people put some stock in that. I’d follow the advice to keep a low profile. Being pleasant is always rewarded.</p>

<p>Edit: Just realized the time lapse on the thread, but its not just first impressions advice. :slight_smile: Sounds like you all are doing fine.</p>

<p>A little off the path here. DD has been dating SO for several years (she is headed for grad school in the fall, he has graduated and is out of the country working for a few years more). Over the holidays he (unbeknownst to DD) asked to speak with me and DH privately. Gulp. He asked for (and received) our blessing, without hesitation. He plans to propose the next time they see each other in about 2 months. He has the ring. </p>

<p>I am not looking for advice per se - it’s just that having been lurking here for a little while you all seem like nice folks - and since I am sworn to secrecy and can’t tell anybody in my family - I had to tell SOMEBODY!</p>

<p>Well congratulations to your family Prozack2! Best wishes for a happy, smooth, beautiful wedding!</p>

<p>P.S. We won’t tell ANYONE.</p>

<p>Congratulations indeed!!
I have two d’s, older d lives with her boyfriend. They have been together for close to 3 years. Met when she was in grad school for art and they took an elective class together. Younger d and boyfriend together for 3 plus years. Met him when she brought him home for spring break and DH was out of town so he met him when were visiting to see her in performance the following month. Not sure if either will be future son-in-laws. Younger d’s bf in grad school in another state now so now a long-distance relationship and she is applying for grad school for Sept so who knows where they will be. Both of them are fine young men and treat d’s with respect and are caring. Met younger d’s bf’s parents at graduation but did not celebrate together. Have not met older d’s bf’s parents or his stepmom as they live in the midwest and we are in NY.</p>

<p>Congrats :D</p>