Of the New England “NESCAC” liberal arts colleges, Bates, Connecticut College and Trinity profile with a 1300 SAT, all others are much higher. That said, Bates will be very difficult with a 3.6 W GPA given they accept less than 20% - not certain how a 3.5 UW / 3.6 W GPA would profile at Connecticut or Trinity. Other great NE choices would be St. Lawrence and Union. Pennsylvania has a lot of great LAC’s with Dickinson, Franklin and Marshall, and Gettysburg being likely fits. Another great choice is St. Olaf in Minnesota (in same town as Carleton so there’s 5,000 crawling around Northfield).
Not sure if anyone will see this, but did the back east tour over spring break. LOVED Gettysburg with Bucknell and Connecticut College not too far behind. Also really liked Lafayette and F&M, but for fit, considered it a tier below (not academically - just in terms of his own rating system) the others. Might apply early to Gettysburg and then RD to the rest for sure. Lots to love about Gettysburg (I knew very little about it and was really impressed), but he was really taken with the Globalization Studies major - great fit for his interest. Thanks all on here for your advice!