<p>I read the article, and felt that it was not a commentary on music, nor economics. </p>
<p>Not music, because this girl has already said she doen’t want to spend four more years studying music theory. No matter how wealthy or talented she was, she would not be a music major unless she could get past this. Violinists are a dime a dozen, and only those with irrepresible, unquenchable passion have a chance. As is often quoted here, if you can see yourself doing something else, do it. This girl is making a wise decision.</p>
<p>Not economics, because she is employed. She is apparently even supporting herself and another. She isn’t wealthy, perhaps, because of some decisions she’s making or that have been made for her.</p>
<p>She moved out at 16. Still a minor, the state family services would have been required to help her out - perhaps they do. There are Independent Living programs set up for just this type of situation. These children who are wards of the state get money for college. They qualify for pell grants. I don’t mean to might light of her situation; only suggest that it isn’t quite as dire as it could be.</p>
<p>Choosing to support an unemployed drop-out boyfriend and a cat are choices she has made that are not society’s or her parents’ or the economy’s or music’s fault.</p>
<p>The same article could have been written about any number of teenagers abandoned by families and making poor choices who have to give up their dreams. The kid who forgoes college to support his siblings, or the one who drops out from lack of support. </p>
<p>This seems to be a variation on the excuse: I could have been as good as you if I’d practiced. That means, talent isn’t enough. There is drive, dedication, music-at-all-costs. This girl is deciding that she isn’t willing to go that route, and the NYTimes feels it’s newsworthy? Let me show you hundreds more.</p>
<p>The more valid point of the article is that many music programs are endangered right now. People see music as expendable.</p>
<p>There is a quote or story that I can’t find right now - will search later for it. It talks about the damage we have done to music because we define it as an art, whereas it has so much more to do with thought, emotion, and basic framework of our beings. It is not a frivolity; it is essential. In the meantime, here are a couple other quotes.</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>
</p>