<p>The more agreeable people probably value their agreeableness (for whatever reasons) more than whatever they would get (like extra money) by not being as agreeable.</p>
<p>Nice people may be broke losers, but let’s not forget what they are - nice. Niceness is just as much a value as wealth is.</p>
<p>PS I see no indication that the study controlled for other variables. Maybe nice people seek lower paying jobs–like teaching or volunteering–for instance.</p>
<p>This is not a case of nice guys finish last and it has never been, this is ‘introverted guys who lack confidence’ finish last.</p>
<p>Every time I hear the old adage ‘nice guys finish last’ I can’t help but cringe. Agreeableness is not intertwined with being nice, it is however connected with having low confidence to take on challenges and risks. Those who continually agree often do so out of fear of the consequences of taking a risk and the less risks you take, the more you narrow the scope of potential in your career.</p>
<p>Why do people continually think agreeing is a short route to being nice? It can often be quite the opposite, you may withold opinions which could better situations, how can we truly analyse a situation if nobody offers alternate thought? An ability to play the devils advocate is one of the most important skills a person can have.</p>
<p>^ agreeableness does not equal niceness, good point.</p>
<p>I think you are falling into the trap of over-enthusiastically supporting an alternative viewpoint due to its alternativeness, though.</p>
<p>Truly analyzing a situation and playing devil’s advocate may be important skills - and skills that not being complacently agreeable can offer us - but I don’t think they have any relevance to being nice (not at least to the way that I think about being nice).</p>
<p>I think it’s obvious that most people in most situations do not prefer disagreement, criticism, etc. Even if one is only being agreeable because they fear disagreement - and not with the goal of being nice - inadvertently they end up being nice, and doing what most people would prefer, agreeing</p>
<p>So the person may not consciously be trying to be any nicer than the person who is less nice, but I don’t think this takes away from the fact that they are nicer. Maybe it’s good to see why they are considered nicer though, that them being nicer is not actually a result of any intention to be that way.</p>
<p>Yeah I exaggerated a bit, but what I was really trying to say is that being nice isn’t the reason that these guys finish last. It’s the fact that they often lack confidence in comparison to their more outgoing counterparts, and as it just so happens, if you lack confidence you are more likely to agree than disagree simply to shield yourself from potential conflict. </p>
<p>The reason why the saying annoys me is that I feel it can lead to in particular high school boys feeling as though they have to become a mercenary to get anywhere. If you’re confident in your abilities you don’t need to shy away from your moral compass to get places.</p>
<p>Yeah, i see why the message nice people finish last could be troubling - you don’t want to enforce that being nice is something you shouldn’t be.</p>
<p>The study may be terrible from a - what influence on society might it have - standpoint.</p>
<p>Also horribly innacurate by the study to assume nice = agreeable. That doesn’t take into consideration any moral/ethical factors, you could agree with a friend to help them commit a robbery, hardly a nice guy?</p>
<p>LOL I love these “nice guys finish last things.” The best part about them is that people take them seriously and actually act like jerks because of them. I wish someone came out with a study saying how, “people who change their personalities around because of a ‘study’ they found on the internet will finish last.”</p>
<p>It’s confidence, bro. From an evolutionary standpoint, why would any woman want to go out with an omega when she can be with an alpha? Omegas are weak (this doesn’t mean physically weak, mind you), boring and subservient. Alphas are strong-willed, confident and ambitious.</p>
<p>Alphas aren’t necessarily mean, but you’d know better than to f*** with them. </p>
<p>A little Machiavelli goes a long way.</p>
<p>(I understand this is about jobs, but whatever…)</p>