<p>Huh?</p>
<p>I would argue that orthodoxy in every religion I know about makes a place for vulnerability, certainly (it may even be required), and even doubt, since the lurking presence of doubt is surely part of human religious experience. But I don’t see “doubt” per se in that lyric. It’s questioning, certainly, but from within a religious framework. (And it’s very moving, too.) There’s no suggestion that God doesn’t exist, more a sense of weariness at His mystery and the challenge of loss. </p>
<p>I also really like the reversal-echo of one of my favorite “Christ” songs, U2’s “With Or Without You”, where the speaker’s plaint is that Christ continually gives himself away. Too much giving, too much taking, too much beauty, too much pain. It’s Jonah. </p>
<p>I don’t understand why you assume that I would draw a dichotomy between an evangelist and an artist. One can be both; John certainly was. One can even be a dogmatic evangelist and an artist: see Blake. Anyway, I don’t think I suggested that Stevens is a dogmatic evangelist, only that he is an artist for whom Christianity is a constant, important part of his life, as is well illustrated by that lyric.</p>
<p>Bright Eyes, yes, is agnostic I suppose, and nothing like Stevens in his religious identification, but he seems to spend an awful lot of time worrying about God, much more than a non-religious person would. I wouldn’t argue that he is orthodox anything, only that he cares about religious issues more than most semi-alcoholic, pill-popping, serially nonmonogamous songwriters outside of Nashville. (And you say he’s bisexual??!? Not that there’s anything wrong with that, but he sure seems to hit a lot of balls out of the park batting right, so to speak. I honestly had never heard that he was a switch-hitter. My interest in Bright Eyes has not included learning much about his actual life, except involuntarily, but the first thing you ever hear about him is the women.)</p>
<p>Sufjan on the radio: In Philadelphia, last August and September, on the Penn station (similar to WFUV, but less folky; not really college radio), about every 15 minutes, alternating between Chicago and Jacksonville. (That was hyperbole, but not much.) Illinoise got voted #4 in the year-end listeners’ poll. Plus it got played on the Princeton station and in a lot of stores, restaurants, car stereos, iPods, etc., and, I think, on some WB TV shows.</p>