<p>AtomicGirl - best wishes on the ACT. I truly believe certain kids are suited better to one or the other.</p>
<p>And thank you for your input on auditioned programs. I do think it’s possible to sense if a kid can really handle - or honestly, if they really want - that kind of pressure, or that kind of focus even within themselves. </p>
<p>My D1 thought she wanted vocal performance, for a long time. I suspected this wasn’t a real passion, and that was OK. But I found myself not comfortable making plans with her to do the auditioning and all of that rigamarole. I became certain when we visited her first choice school (which had a combined BA/BM 5-year degree, with the audition for the conservatory half). She was SO bored in the music theory class! Then she came home and over the next few months put only the most basic effort into her audition CD (required for screening the in-person auditions). I think even she knew she wasn’t going to make that cut. But by that time, she was fully invested in another route, and I felt much more comfortable, too.</p>
<p>Fast forward, and she is going to that very school, finishing her BA next year (in science), and has sung in the choir the entire time. I know she will always sing; she just really didn’t want a music degree. She’s never taken 1 course in the music department!</p>
<p>D2, however, hasn’t wavered in her determination to get into an auditioned program (this time in theater, although she is very involved in music, too). I don’t know if she’ll get into any of them, let alone her top choice, but I do feel that she is on track with this process, and fully invested. She also has strong, non-auditioned alternatives. I, too, hope some of these places see how passionate she is and how much she can offer their program.</p>
<p>I’m not handing out advice here - I’m saying I’m with you. We know our kids, and how they fit into the spectrum. I do think music is very competitive, and I hope your S finds people who will support his dream, no matter how far he’s gotten in the process in HS. I also think he should try for a couple of auditioned programs, if he really wants them. The auditions themselves are a real learning experience (my D2 found several of her music auditions to be some of the best “lessons” she’s every had), and you might be surprised at the results.</p>