Experience begets experience. He’ll find his place…that he’s had a great experience is what matters.
And I’m not sure how to play it if you have an offer, but we all know in the past, sometimes offers have been pulled - economy goes in the crapper. I’m not suggesting kids who have offers continue to look because they can’t take another - but until you start, there’s always that level of nervousness.
But in your case, your student has a great experience to build upon - and that will put them in a huge advantage for a position next year. So if he hustles, I’m hopeful he’ll create some good luck.
And you never know - even his summer company may come back. Not all make offers after Summer. My son interned twice at a company who told him, they don’t have a recruiting process in place to do this and would assuredly come back to him in the Spring. He stayed in touch and they did. He had other offers by then and didn’t go back - but if your son stays in touch, you never know how things shake out in a year. Maybe they lose employees over the next 6-9 months and have to back fill.
If it makes you feel better (or worse?) - we had a crop of great interns this summer, but felt so guilty from Day 1 because we knew we’d never hire them also because of our company’s financial situation. They worked so hard all summer but we knew that no matter how much they impressed us they would have to find jobs elsewhere. The best we can do is give them good recommendations.
Thanks, and yes, sounds like a very similar situation. S23’s mentor and manager have been wonderful. They feel so badly that they can’t hire him that they are helping him network at other biomed companies. And yeah, great recs from this company should put him in a good position for hiring this fall (I hope so, anyway. One thing that I worry about is that it seems like engineering firms mostly hire their own interns, especially those who co-oped with them. I don’t know how many positions remain open for outside hires.) Oh well, nothing I can do about it. He’ll figure it out. They all will, right?
I think you are panicking over something that is unlikely to be true. I don’t know about in Canada (if that’s what the name up north refers to) - but there are companies hiring 50, 100 - and I promise, most don’t come from within. Some companies hire interns but not kids out of school as a strategy. My company does that - sort of low cost summer project work. At the same time, other companies that hire people (whether a formal program or individually) don’t even have interns.
I would feel good about your kid’s internships. Having them puts them far ahead in the job market of those who don’t - so there is nothing at all to feel sad about here.
They are much better off for having the opportunity and if they’ve made some great connections to help them for the future, even better!! I don’t think recommendations matter though - as most won’t check them. But connections certainly do.
But hopefully the job will get them in the door for an interview - that’s the most important thing. And that hasn’t been lost.
S23 is a horrible communicator. Always has been (partly caused by growing up in a split family where he was told he could not communicate with me when at his dads but alas). Always makes my heart drop a bit when I actually see his name on the caller ID. He said after 5 weeks I was due and he owed me.
He got the competitive AI intern position he was hoping for. Its about information security and internal AI development. They only selected one candidate. His resume is reading pretty well I guess. He has done 2 internships in QA, 1 in data science using AI, and now this one more AI/security based. He is taking 18 credits this semester to make up for time lost freshman year (he started as a voice major with a goal of adding a minor but quickly found out it wasn’t possible and with cutting programs and such, he pivoted to IT). For all the stress he has given me the past few years, fingers crossed he will easily find a job after graduation as I know it isn’t looking great out there for many new grads right now!
S23 is also not the best communicator. It just doesn’t occur to him to share. I found out this weekend that he has a double major. Why would you not share that?!
Well S23 has a small dilemma. He just got offered a graduate research assistant position. Which is great, however, it means he’ll need to work this project over the summer so he won’t be able to do a summer internship with a company. It’s the one thing he’s lacking on his resume – he’s done paid summer research each summer, but nothing with a company. He’s staying on for one year to complete his masters but he does not think he wants to do a PhD.
He has to decide by tomorrow whether to take it and he’s leaning on taking it b/c he has not gotten any bites at the space companies he wants to work for. The good news is it will fund his graduate school completely, the only other downside is it puts him down a pretty narrow specialty - additive manufacturing and materials science.
Overall it’s good news, just not unambiguously so.
Question: In his field of study, does a research assistantship count as job experience in the same way that an internship does? (If so, that means there really isn’t a resume gap.)
Thought #1: A fully funded masters degree is as rare as a unicorn in most fields.
Thought #2: In most fields, it IMO isn’t worth worrying about the narrow specialization that a masters program slots you into. That’s the point of a (research-based) masters program: to show that you can focus on something highly specific, not to show that you intend to work in that narrow field forever.
I think it counts as job experience, but I really don’t know enough. He wants to do aerospace structures work for the space industry, particularly with additive manufacturing parts. This work will take him a bit further down the materials side of things, and he’ll need to see if he can broaden it in his thesis to be more applicable for structures work.
As I said, he’s going to take it and be happy about it… he just wishes it would have been offered at the end of the semester so he could have had time to evaluate more options overall. It’s a tough market for his admittedly narrow target for jobs.
I get that, however the complicating factor here I think is the research would be with his thesis advisor.
He’s not going to withdraw any applications he’s already submitted, and if some amazing opportunity pops up, he’ll consider, but he’ll need to tread carefully. Also, even if he can’t take an internship with a company because of this, he might be able to network a bit (“oh man, I’m sorry, while I was interviewing here, I got this amazing opportunity to fund my master’s program, can we keep in contact for post graduation full time work?”)
It’s too late - but this is the issue right here. My question would be - has he gotten any bites at companies he doesn’t want to work for? When building a resume, you need experience - not a name. The desired name can come later. You know how many corporate hires come from small, unknown company because they come in with a skillset or skillsets that many at the bigger company never had a chance to acquire? I’ve seen many in my career.
All that said, he has to make a decision by tomorrow so he has to make one.
As for will a grad research experience be seen as a job?
The answer is - it depends.
That’s because different companies will see it differently. Some may love it. Some may say it’s solely academic. Others may have it somewhere in between - a job but not what we want to see. Or others may say it’s a wonderful job.
It’s October - I wouldn’t expect him to have an internship yet. Maybe November / December but many don’t happen to late.
It’s not necessarily the right thing to do - but as @neela1 said, he could hedge - accepting it and if something better comes along, giving it up. A company or school would have no problem doing it to you, if they needed to - i.e. funding dried up, etc.
But students have to open their minds on internships - to location, company, duties and more. Experience begets experience. Without experience, it will be harder later.
I don’t think he will be typecast, at all, from the grad research position. If he has an industry in mind (space), that wont’ prevent him at all. If he was in the job 20 years, sure - but not from this.
He’s definitely applied all over the country and to dozens of companies (not just the big ones, but the small subcontractors as well). What he hasn’t done is applied to companies that do things that he’s interested in but for a different subject. It’s definitely a numbers thing, or some issue with his resume.
He’s taking the research assistant job/position - he’ll keep his current applications open for now, just to see. Funded grad school in a research area he’s interested in is too good to pass up. He also looked at all the additive manufacturing jobs with space companies doing exactly what he’ll be doing here, and it gives a level of comfort that he’ll have skills that have some demand in the industry he wants (and the number of jobs in general with additive manufacturing is good overall).
If there is a choice, I’d be careful working for a subcontractor. Pay is a function of size, and a function of who in the value chain extracts the most value – and it is often the firm that is closest to the end customer. And often it is hard to move up from the small firm to the big firm. It is easiest to land at a big firm right out of school.
An update on my C23, who graduated a year early this past May into the ongoing “stuck” job market.
The child wanted out of Texas (missed mountains!) and wasn’t really able to come back to Alaska (seasonal depression, the winters here are brutal for that), and so moved to West Virginia to live with the grandparents, and has been looking for a job there.
Well, the kid has now landed a job with the public library system there, which is kind of perfect, since they found out that they absolutely love libraries through their campus job (working in the archives at North Texas’s main library), and this is a chance to feel out whether that’s the sector they really want to build a career in.
(This is the one child of the four who was utterly emphatic about never considering going to grad school, and now is seriously talking about maybe needing to get a MLIS. It’s amusing, it is.)