Parents of the HS Class of 2025 (Part 2)

Four kids, in birth order:

  • C17 is our budgeter, with relatively low income (that’s what happens when you target the nonprofit sector😞) but equivalently low expenses, and a very rigid budget that will not be exceeded under any circumstances; this is the one who’s heading to law school for immigration law, which is, again, relatively low income for a JD, and therefore there is a budget already penciled out for all three years and the one following
  • C19 spends fairly freely (and is the one who’s likely to consistently have the salary to support that), but can’t handle the concept of going into debt, ever; buying a car was one of the worst things this child has ever experienced, because the cash to purchase it outright wasn’t available but highly reliable transportation was needed, and therefore a car loan had to be procured, and that was kind of torture
  • C23 is the one to worry about, as far as overspending without worry goes
  • C25 isn’t so much debt-averse like C19 as spending-averse; there is very little that C25 sees as worth spending for, and I’ll admit I mildly worry that this is the kid that might end up being one of those people who lives in substandard surroundings while having millions in the bank
5 Likes

Snort. He knows my vocab. :slight_smile: In “how are they just like me” news, I also sent a note to S22, letting him know that I know the weather has been a challenge while training, so if he wants to change his upcoming marathon (set for March 1 on Cape Cod) then I’d pay the entry fee for a later one. And here’s part of his response “First and foremost thank you for looking out for me. However, … All in all, I currently plan on going forward with this event, however I am fully aware of the risks and will continue to assess the pros and cons as the go date gets closer.” I’m like, when did you turn into me? (e.g. someone who writes emails that say “I hear you, you are wrong, I am correct because, so I am ignoring your suggestion”. This is essentially what I do at work…)

13 Likes

This is hilarious. Especially because my kids like to write emails like this, too. Although my D22 is cheeky and will send something like, “Dearest mother, kindly peruse the essays when you have a moment free. I shall be eternally grateful.”

(I told her I would help edit her grad school essays – I used to edit for a living, lol.)

4 Likes

Wow, I would kill for something longer than a one word text!

1 Like

Oh, my S25 isn’t great about communicating. S22 turns on the fancy words (the whole email was about two paragraphs long, clearly laying out all his arguments and rebutting my concerns) when he wants to make a point and silence any pushback. There’s a * reason* his last two internships have had him in management type positions. :joy: (Says the longtime manager.)

3 Likes

Omg this is soooo funny!

Right? I read it and just laughed aloud. You go ahead and “assess” away my child. I couldn’t even be a little cranky that my worries were being dismissed. He was so masterfully passive - aggressive / I - know - better - than - you - just - leave - me - alone, and kind of vaguely snotty while at it. I couldn’t not laugh.

3 Likes

My kid is rushing a frat and I’m having a hard time with it. I keep thinking of all the horror stories that are still happening re: dangerous hazing. I know there are benefits but for me, the negatives outweigh the positives. It seems like a culture of misogyny and racism, while not overt, still prevails. Am I completely wrong? I hope so. I told him I wouldn’t pay the dues, but he got a campus job so I guess he can afford them (I have no idea how much they cost). I don’t mean to offend anyone who loves Greek culture; I’m completely ignorant so any info would be appreciated.

5 Likes

Me too! Even one word seems to be a struggle for my S25 at times. Strings of unanswered texts. We occasionally will text “rsvp” or “see above text” which usually gets him to reply. Sigh. This was the kid who we were worried about because he never really slept away from us. So I guess on the bright side, he is not having trouble being away.

1 Like

I think it really really depends. My S22 is in a fraternity and it isn’t at all like you are thinking. Part of it is the school climate and culture - he’s at WPI which is a small STEM school that doesn’t have the big sports culture that seems to go along with the worst of the fraternity stereotypes.

Do they drink underage, yeah, I’m going to assume they do. But no more than the other underclassmen and it’s not everyone - They’ve got a brother who can’t drink, he’s always got other choices. And they have hard seltzer for the brothers with gluten sensitivities. (I dont know why I felt the need to mention to seltzer/gluten thing. Maybe just because it is SO different from my back in the day memories of the worst cheap beer and or “punch” mixed in a trashcan?)

The fraternity brothers have a major repository of notes on classes and professors, and the older brothers help tutor the younger brothers. Their average GPA is something like a 3.75. At this school juniors are required to do a quarter long project and you apply sophomore year. Early each year the seniors put on a presentation, complete with PowerPoint, about the different locations and pros and cons of each, how the application process works and deadline information to be aware of. They also run internal resume review and interview prep where the older brothers help the younger ones get ready for career fairs and perfect their job applications.

Re: the racism concern, my child is white, the school is majority white, but I’d guess his fraternity is maybe a third men of color. Most are Asian or SouthEast Asian, which is consistent with the school makeup (eg not that many African American or Hispanic men at school).

Re the misogyny concerns - i dont doubt that can be true, but it really isn’t everywhere. In addition to their national philanthropy, his fraternity has adopted The Trevor Project, a recently graduated brother is trans, and I happened to notice in the senior spotlight a few weeks ago that the senior in question uses they/them pronouns. Being LGBTQ friendly doesn’t necessarily = treat women well, but I think it does paint a very different picture from what you may be envisioning.

And yes, this is a traditional “social” fraternity, not like a business fraternity or something. And the fraternity does not have a great reputation nationwide. So I think my point is that it’s reasonable to have questions and worries, but also just know that it isn’t always what you are worried about.

3 Likes

Haha, yes even squeezing out a one word text is a chore; I have to “wave” at him to finally respond! And you’re right, I’m glad he’s not homesick, or having trouble finding friends/things to do.

This frat sounds great, but I don’t think this type exists at my son’s school? Not sure, but it’s a D1 sports school known for partying. And as recently as last year had some horrible hazing incident in the news. I never thought I’d have a kid who would be attracted to a mainstream frat, but here we are… Thanks for your perspective, it’s helpful. The hard seltzer for those with gluten insensitivities :laughing: And I love that your son’s frat seems so diverse; a third men of color is amazing… all the frat photos I’ve seen at my son’s school seem to have only one or two non-white kids.

2 Likes

I’ll also say that even at the bigger sports schools, I don’t think they are all the same. The fraternities have different personalities, which he’ll figure out when he visits them. Yes, some are more of your hard core jocks, some will be more of your rich children of privilege, and some will, inevitably, be some version of stoners. But there will be others that are just guys looking for camaraderie. And from what I’ve seen, if a campus has had well publicized negative events involving their Greek system, that usually means the next few years they react by installing more guardrails - more requirements, more oversight etc. so hopefully it’s not as bad as you are fearing. Regardless, you know your kid. You didn’t raise him to be an a-hole, to be a misogynist or racist. And he’s not going to want to be with people like that. If he somehow finds himself in a group like that, he’s going to leave it. You don’t have to stay in a fraternity (or sorority) if you aren’t happy. You know your guy, you can feel confident that at the heart of it, he’ll make good choices. And yeah, maybe he’ll end up with “the golf bros” who look like total children of privilege (you know the type, they look like they were born wearing golf shorts with designer belts and polo shirts with high end sunglasses) or the fraternity whose Facebook feed is full of the “shirts v skins” football game in the snow and you think - drunk morons. But if they aren’t also good guys at heart, he’ll ditch them.

3 Likes

My grandfather’s life was saved in 1937 because a Jewish fraternity (SAM) “sponsored” him and covered his room/board for college, so he got to come from Berlin to the USA and not be killed in the Holocaust.

As a result, he was nothing but positive about the entire Greek life system for the rest of his life, including strongly encouraging my mother and her sisters to join sororities, which they did.

However, my father was a professor at a big-10 school and so we lived in the heart of fraternityville for my childhood, walking to school and synagogue through party detritus in the mornings, and hearing news story after story of hazing, violence, sexism, rape, and other junk.

These two narratives have been at war in my family, and I think there is truth in both strands. Greek organizations have tremendous potential to do good in the world. Single-sex social clubs, particularly groups of strong young men with access to alcohol, can also do a hell of a lot of bad in the world.

I’m guessing that the system at WPI is similar to at MIT, where I was an undergrad - yes, there were fraternities known for horrible sexism. SAE sent “counter-protestors” to carry signs saying “she wanted it” and “no means yes; yes means anal” to a take back the night rally at MIT that I attended in the early 1990s.

But many of the other frats were mild, and I had hockey buddies from one where I thought the guys were generally great.

Also, except for one kid getting killed during hazing, I didn’t hear about a lot of serious problems in the years that followed. MIT ended up not using fraternities for freshman housing after the death, I believe, which yes, is a tightening of restrictions as mentioned above. Of course, there are also continuing allegations of cheating (including the “course bibles” where alumni give their “brothers” unfair access to old exams, but also including more elaborate schemes).

If one of my sons expressed interest in being in a social fraternity, I would be extremely concerned, because it would be wildly out of character for them, so I really hear you, @norcalimom1 Have you talked to him about what he is looking for? Maybe there are other social groups that could be a better fit and give him a “home” away from home..?

3 Likes

Fraternities can be everything you said. As my husband says you have 20 year olds telling 18 year olds what to do. What could go wrong? Fraternities are not the fraternities we (collective 45-60 something parents) had. The limits can be pushed and social media doesn’t help. Schools are spending insane money dealing with lawsuits and many have little tolerance at this point. But, for a freshman student trying to make a big school smaller it’s everything. They are willing to do a lot just to find their tribe. You are right to be concerned, but remember you raised a great kid who has values you taught him. Don’t close the communication door. They won’t tell you the tough stuff, but they will share and it’s important to follow to be sure it doesn’t head sideways. Trust them to find their tribe, but also give them strength to pull out if not right for them. Hoping it goes well for him.

4 Likes

I love your answers: full of information, levity and humor! Thanks for the optimism, I’m trying not to catastrophize and I do think my son is a good kid at heart (don’t we all though?) but I don’t think he’s the leader he thinks he is and I fear he wouldn’t speak up if things cross the line. I tend to think the worst of things though so thank you for the reality check.

3 Likes

What an interesting history you have re: the Greek system; thank you for sharing! I absolutely agree that frats can be both positive and a curse. My son seems to have a good group of friends so I didn’t think he would need to join a frat. I’ve talked to him about the dangers of hazing and groupthink since he was in high school. He’s a much more social person than I am, so maybe it’s not completely out of character. I’ve asked him why he wanted to join and it’s really for the parties :expressionless_face: (his school is fairly isolated so all the socializing is on campus). I’ve detailed all the reasons why I don’t think a frat is a great choice for him and listed other things he could do instead (that I would financially support). However, I also understand it’s ultimately his choice and don’t want to alienate him by nagging him further. Sigh, I guess I’ll have to wait and see how it all shakes out. Thank you for your perspective.

2 Likes

Thank you! Yes, I think that’s my next step: making sure our communication stays open and encouraging him to leave if he has any doubts. Back in my day, my parents had no idea what was happening at college; ignorance is bliss!

2 Likes

AH! This is actually a point in a good direction, it’s just not obvious.

A million years ago, I went to William and Mary. The greek life percentage for men on campus was ridiculous, like 35-40%. Why? Because it was adjacent to Colonial Williamsburg and there was NOTHING to do. Because there was nothing to do, a ton of men who otherwise wouldn’t have been interested in Greek life joined fraternities. But that meant that while, yes, there were the sports focused houses (I distinctly remember houses for “large football players”, “small football players” and swimmers) and the stoner house (but they had the best music and best parties), there were also houses of just… guys. Like the one that four guys from my Monroe Scholar cohort joined, and which also happened to have a handful of guys from the men’s a capella group. Not all machismo all the time guys, but guys who wanted a place where they were welcome on Saturday night when there’s no outside or off campus social life to be had.

When you are isolated, I think the fraternities tend to also attract more of your “normal” students, and less of your Greek Life Or Bust stereotypes. Hopefully, that is the case for your guy. The key is just for him to find that house.

3 Likes

Goodness gracious. I’m so far behind. But just skimmed through to catch up. I am on day two back in the office from the great ice storm of 2026 and our visit to West Virginia to scout out neighborhoods. Trip to WV was good, although it was so icy there. Thankfully husband is a midwestern guy and had no trouble driving. (I, on the other hand, was a southern lunatic the one time I tried to drive on the ice.) We had a great time and found some neighborhoods we liked, met with a realtor, and had dinner with his new colleagues. I have an interview next month for 100% remote job (which seems rare in higher ed) and am also talking with a hiring manager at the local university about an in person job there. Crossing my fingers one will work out. My current boss knows I’m leaving, but I haven’t given my official notice at work yet. Hoping to have another job lined up before I do that.

S25 is pretty good. His motivation isn’t the same as last semester, but he still seems to be doing well in his classes. I think his work load is lighter this quarter, and so he’s back to his old ways of just skating by with last minute cramming. Hoping he continues to develop better study and time management skills.

As for the living on campus talk, he’ll move into the frat house next year. Lord help me. But it seems like a good group of guys, and they haven’t highest GPA of all the greek orgs. So I guess it could be worse.

Hope everyone has a good evening!

2 Likes