My IRL friends have totally made fun of me for packing his lunch. They also gave me a hard time when i asked for suggestions for things to put on a “kitchen stuff” spreadsheet for him (he and two friends will be living together next year. I wanted to make a spreadsheet of all the things you need in a kitchen so that they could share it and determine who will bring what.)
They (my friends) were all “gently, don’t you think it’s time to let your son be independent and start adulting.”
FWIW, it’s a huge random trigger for me when people start with “gently” - dude, softening the criticism doesn’t make it less like you are acting like you know best and talking down to me. Phrase it differently.
Anyhoo, it made me pause and think, am I doing too much for him? Am I somehow making it so that he’s some infantile not ready to adult young man? Am I being like the parents on the college facebook page that ask questions that seem so like they are taking ownership of things away from their kids?
And I decided no. This is my love language. I packed my kids lunch right through HS graduation. Not because they couldn’t, but because I wanted them to think of me during the day and I wanted to make sure that they got something good to eat. Was it spoiling them? Sure, but I was doing it mostly because it made ME feel good.
Same with the kitchen stuff spreadsheet. Am I lifting a burden from them (of having to think of the things and organize it all)? Sure. But it makes me feel so good to feel like I’m lifting the burden. And it’s not like they couldn’t do it themselves.
My boys know that spreadsheets are my love language. I make them spreadsheets of possible courses they can take each semester to meet their major requirements and allow room for fun, I make them spreadsheets of links to job applications that I think would be interesting to them, I made my older son a spreadsheet of possible places to live in the town he’s moving to post grad. They know that it’s just my way of sharing information and trying to share in their lives. They can use or ignore the information on there (I know S22 used the spreadsheet of jobs religiously, I also know that S25 paid no attention to the “possible courses to select” spreadsheet).
So I’ve thought about this a lot - the “am I keeping them from adulting”. And I’ve decided that maybe I’m lifting a burden that it would be helpful for them to do. But they know how to do all of these things, so it’s not like they are missing a learning experience and, frankly, it brings me so much joy to pack the lunch and make the spreadsheet, that I don’t really care. I’m confident that they can manage just fine without me. I just don’t want them to feel like they have to.
(And that had nothing to do with anything, just it’s been really in my head. I guess the “gently, shouldn’t he be doing that” got to me more than I thought.)