Parents of the HS Class of 2025 (Part 2)

I think so, was it Syracuse?

Yes I think it was.

Blurbs nearly exactly like this have appeared for a lot of colleges, ranging from nonselective to hyperrejective, in the Chronicle of Higher Education’s financial tracker the past few years. Syracuse isn’t nearly alone in this.

2 Likes

Well yeah, the writing has been on the wall demographically for at least at a decade. The question is why these institutions didn’t do better planning for it. Why is their first response to always pass the cost on to the consumer, especially when there are fewer consumers? Isn’t this counterintuitive to the laws of supply and demand?

1 Like

In some ways, this is the same question as why didn’t more parents save the amount of money they needed to pay for college since articles about that have been floating around for almost 30 years (if not longer).

Most people struggle to envision the future at all, let alone clearly. Institutions are made up of those same imperfect people. The people who can’t/don’t individually save for their children’s college expenses are the people who are making the choices of how to run colleges/universities.

Maybe some of the colleges/universities thought it would all work out regardless, maybe they thought they could position themselves to be in a better place than they actually ended up, maybe they just stuck they heads into sand like ostriches.

3 Likes

That’s a valid comparison; however, the consumer has more choices than the business. What I’ve been reading is that more and more families are foregoing college, or turning to cheaper non-flagship campuses, or opting for trade school / community colleges. Some families simply do not see the value of a 4 year degree that can cost well over $250K per student. Certainly it would benefit the college to retain the students they already have (side eyeing Baylor here).

Location matters too, as southern and sunbelt colleges continue to attract record numbers of applicants. One thing I did not appreciate until this year is how much marketing goes into attracting students.

Because it’s hard to—there have been a lot of unknowns, and while the demographic shift was known, a lot of other things in the then-future weren’t,* and that makes planning subject to large errors. (And your assumption that costs are consistently passed to the consumer is incorrect.)

*Like the federal government no longer funding research and teaching support (which reduced costs to both colleges and students/families) at promised levels, immigration enforcement changing in ways that destroyed a lot of budgetary assumptions, the elimination of anti-“poaching” policies, et cetera, et cetera, and so forth.

2 Likes

These are different issues than the demographic cliff though. Also, difficult to forecast.

I agree and definitely think this is hurting Syracuse. Also difficult to forecast.

Even though a college raises their gross price, that doesn’t mean net price is going to increase. For Syracuse specifically, we will see how much they must discount to get fannies in seats.

In the big picture, average net college tuition costs and average net college COA continue to decline (and have for over a decade), because the average discount is increasing.

2 Likes

Net tuition has decreased, but non tuition expenses have increased. And the general rise in COL and wage stagnation means that it has become more difficult for families to save enough for the total COA. Scholarships also help mostly the highest achieving students (as they should)…which leads me to my point that many families are now reconsidering whether a 4 year university is worth the cost.

2 Likes

I agree that ROI is a hot topic. But squishy at best in terms of how to actually calculate that. I also think part of the issue of people rethinking college is a general erosion of trust in higher ed.

With regard to scholarships only going to high achieving students, I see it differently…some/many less selective schools have high discount rates (merit aid, need based aid….it’s all just discounting.) It’s the relatively more selective schools, where high stats kids congregate, that don’t discount as much.

2 Likes

True, but the biggest discounts in terms of merit go to the highest achieving kids. A $4K scholarship because you managed a 3.0 in high school is not that helpful when the yearly COA is in the tens of thousands.

1 Like

I am not sure where your data is coming from. This is a good report that shows the net price trends after adjusting for inflation, I don’t want to derail this thread though so am happy to chat via PM. See average net COA, as well as average tuition and fees by public and private four year colleges below. Average discount rate at four year schools is around 55%.

1 Like

(S23 is using Tuition Exchange at Cuse so we have been somewhat protected from unexpected huge hikes in costs).

2 Likes

Sure, I’m happy to provide sources if you need them. Check CPI data. But lived experience should be enough to verify that food costs are up exponentially, housing costs are up exponentially, the cost of clothing, gasoline, utilities, cars, and all services have increased dramatically while real wages have decreased…everything but electronics is more expensive than it was a decade ago. The dollar is less valuable.

Tuition is one thing. But your kid has got to eat, and that’s another thing entirely.

3 Likes

Turns out there is an option of not eating, and that is a poor option (ask me how I know) :wink:

3 Likes

What kills me, a little, in terms of cost increases are the way it’s being done. S22 went to WPI, we had pretty much a straight 3% increase in tuition every year. They charged tuition, housing, food and I think possibly an activities fee and a health center fee. Ok. Understandable and clear cut.

S25 goes to Clemson. Because it’s a state school, and the state of South Carolina has opted to hold in state tuition flat (who knows for this year, but the last several years) the school is doing a number of things to get around that. First, there are large tuition increases for OOS students. Fine, I get that. I don’t like it, but I also don’t pay taxes to SC, so it’s understandable. But then there’s the nickel and diming they are doing for everyone so as to get extra $$. Here’s our fall 2025 bill (this doesn’t include the rebates he got from scholarships; the thing labelled “unlimited + 300” was his meal plan). What kills me about this are all the little fees. My other kid went to an engineering college with a much smaller endowment, and he didn’t pay a single lab fee. Here, S25 has two lab fees for math and physics courses, and one “design build program fee” (but the class that generated that fee had no lab and no designing or building.) But wth with a “career center fee” and a “matriculation fee”? Then there’s “athletics fee” + “campus recreation fee” + “activity fee”? those aren’t the same enough that you need three? And “technology fee” and “software license fee” are not the same? (Software license fee was NOT the cost for software associated with a specific class, that was different and charged with books.) And don’t tell me that you have “free campus buses” if there’s also an $80 “transit fee”. Bah.

Sure, don’t raise in state tuition. But charge everyone a $4 career center fee and a $5 matriculation fee per semester and that’s $9 x 24,000 undergrad students twice a year. That’s an extra $432,000 per year. It’s not chump change, but it’s also ridiculous to nickel and dime to get to that point.

I feel like a cranky old man who should now shout “get off my lawn!”

5 Likes

College education is one of the classic case studies for Baumol’s cost disease—education is an industry that, unlike most, is extremely limited in terms of possible efficiency gains. Potential efficiency innovations like MOOCs (remember those?) more often crash and burn than not, and those that are widely implementable are things that are unpopular with consumers and degrade the product (like, e.g., larger class sizes). This means that education is trapped into costing more and more relative to most other industries to maintain its quality, because they are able to use efficiency gains to hold down price increases in ways that education cannot.

Add to that Parkinson’s Second Law,* the tendency of administrative organizations to increase themselves regardless of the utility of such growth (i.e., academic bloat in academia), which also increases costs without increasing efficiency, and higher ed costs are in a bad place.

*Which was originally presented satirically but has been found to hold up in serious business research.

I have no solutions, simply presenting the root of the problem—and as just pointed out, one result is that well-meaning initiatives like keeping tuition static (whether for one group or all) has very negative effects on either pricing or the product, or often both.

2 Likes

I agree with you about the fees. My son was OOS first year and will thankfully be instate this year. BUT even with the very low instate tuition (which I am eternally grateful for) there as TONS of fees. So probably another $3K in fees for the year.

Well, S25 was officially notified tonight that he’s lost his scholarship. We knew this would happen, he didn’t get enough As in the spring - he only got one A and he got one C, so that cancelled out (he needs a 3.0 and needed to pull up some classes from the fall).

We knew he couldn’t fix it over the summer - he needs four As and nothing else below a B and he was only going to take three classes this summer. So once it became clear he couldn’t salvage it over the summer, we let him withdraw from one of the summer classes. He’s struggling with the 100% virtual asynchronous set up. He’s not able to focus on the lecture and is struggling to turn stuff in. This is the last week of the first class and at this point I’m just hoping he manages a B (it’s not looking likely).

Sigh. He’s so capable, but so so bad at executive function.

16 Likes

Speaking for myself (but I suspect I am not alone in this), one of the most difficult aspects of parenting a young adult is sitting back and watching them make mistakes. It is especially frustrating when those mistakes cost us money, or were easily preventable, or both. I have often found myself metaphorically tearing out my hair and screaming (not literally) “why didn’t you listen to me and do what I told you to do?!” Wouldn’t all our lives be so much easier?

I always tell my kids—and have since they were 12– “mistakes are normal. Just don’t make mistakes I can’t fix.” I know what your Clemson Tiger is going through is frustrating to watch, but it sounds like it will “just” cost money. These are learning experiences, not just in the academic sense, and in the end, those are priceless. Hang in there, momma.

12 Likes