Parents of the HS Class of 2026

D26 got her first acceptance- yay! It was not unexpected but still a relief, especially since it’s her top choice at the moment.

She is stressing though because they had the senior meeting with guidance yesterday and received their transcripts up to this point. She’s very disappointed in herself because her GPA is definitely lower than she wants it to be. However, you can clearly see how her sophomore grades brought the average down and she can use the Additional Info/Challenges and Circumstances on the Common App to explain. It was nothing earth shattering, but she was subjected to some pretty awful cyber bullying that led to a rather serious bout of depression. She rebounded quite well in her junior year.

19 Likes

That is awesome!!! Especially being a top choice of hers! :confetti_ball:

D26 should be getting her first acceptance any day now. This school is rolling admissions (starting in September). This one though is a ‘bottom of the list’ safety. So, it’s a bit less thrilling :wink:. The anticipation is still high though- so we are in the hurry up and wait part of the process with this one. Will be nice to get at least one early acceptance from her list.

4 Likes

D26 made NMSF, cut off was 224 for CA.

18 Likes

Congrats! We are waiting to hear about D26 – cutoff will be lower in GA, but her index is 227, so she should be good regardless.

I thought it came out tomorrow – although I’m not sure when the schools got this info. Mine hasn’t heard officially yet, but that’s what we’re waiting on before she submits her applications.

2 Likes

We were in this exact same boat and she added it up and then averaged it out.

1 Like

227 is a really high score, that will make it in any State. GA is supposed to be no higher than 223.

Congratulations to all NMSF! The score indexes this year are super high, surpassing Compass Prep’s predictions for the first time! Guess we will see for sure tomorrow! S26 got a 222 in VA which we heard did not make the cut. S26 doesn’t seem upset by it and is just happy to get NM Commended.

On the Common App front. S26 finally sent out official LOR requests via Naviance after sending emails first requesting his teachers for a LOR. That seemed to be a huge weight off his shoulders as he curated which teacher will write different aspects of him. Today, he met with his guidance counselor and was pleasantly surprised to learn that his counselor read one of his Lit Mag short stories. They discussed the colleges on his list, the school report, and next steps. Grateful that his school hired more counselors this year to lighten the load for each counselor. He just needs to finish his Common App essay, some supplemental essays, and his writing portfolio.

S26 also got to tour and interview at Denison and Kenyon over Labor Day weekend. These are among his top schools on his list who track demonstrated interest.

About his guidance counselor - it’s interesting that he was suggesting to my son that he needs to aim higher than Wesleyan University/Vassar/UVA! At first we thought, to aim for more selecting LACs, but he was referring to aiming higher like to ivy schools! I have no idea why he would suggest that! S26 knows that all ivies are high reach schools to everyone. He isn’t looking at ivies at all, but why do you think a HS counselor would say that?

6 Likes

I’m jaded & skeptical. First of all, AWESOME that your son’s HS hired more counselors. But as to why a HS counselor would suggest what they did, it could be:

  • counselor is new(er) to the profession and not as experienced.
  • as a result, counselor might be seeing S26’s GPA & test scores and think, “Wow! This kid could by Top 25/ivy league material!”
  • counselor might know more about ivy league colleges than Wesleyan, Vassar, and UVA.
  • counselor might not fully realize how places like Harvard, Yale, Stanford, etc. are usually lottery schools for all who apply and MAYBE if you have a hook of some sort (i.e., you’re an oboe player and they need an oboe player next year) then that might influence the decision a little more.
  • counselor is hoping to get a student into an ivy league school so the HS next year can boast to parents that they get students into ivy league colleges.

Wesleyan, Vassar, and UVA are really great universities. If your family is happy with your S26’s current list of colleges he’s going to apply to and you feel it’s a good mix of colleges AND there’s a safety on the list (where ‘safety’ = affordable, he’d get admitted, AND he’d be content to attend), then you don’t have to add ivy league schools if S26 doesn’t feel like it.

1 Like

Great advice! Yes, he’s happy with his list and yes, he’s got a safety school he wouldn’t mind attending.

His counselor isn’t that new. S26 plays the trombone & baritone but not the oboe lol. Bragging rights might be it. In the end, S26 is not interested in any ivies for now. Thanks for your insight! S26 has more than enough selective schools on his list that he prefers over the ivies.

3 Likes

One could certainly contact the counselor to ask why he/she is recommending that your S26 consider applying to ivies.

1 Like

Very true. I will reach out myself. Thank you! But if S26 is not interested, I will not push him. The only ivy that piqued his interest is Princeton.

2 Likes

Tangentially related, my wife and I have been surprised at reactions to my D26’s college list which is NOT ivy heavy. She’s done well academically, has a bunch of extra-curriculars, and generally pushes herself to do well. When people ask her where she wants to go to college, she always leads with “Well, I’m applying to Rutgers, TCNJ, and some other colleges.” Of course, Rutgers is our in-state flagship and TCNJ is the sort of flagship in-state LAC. People always think she’s dramatically undershooting. I think everyone expects to hear the fancy, name-brand OOS colleges. I’m not saying that a college counselor would think that way, but I’ve been surprised at the people I know around our town, including teachers that went to colleges like TCNJ, that just poopoo the idea. At least D26 has decided that prestige is not a thing for her, so it’s been a reasonably non-stressful search so far. It’s all about vibes, so she’s ruled out a bunch because it didn’t feel right including some ivies that I thought might be right for her. Oh well!

Anyway, my long way of saying that I think just about everyone gets wrapped up in the name game, including probably a few college counselors that might want to say, “My student got into X.”

5 Likes

Ditto everything @sbinaz and @beefeater said, although a counselor clearly should have added the caveat – “if you’re interested in an Ivy, of course.”

SAME for my D26! There are a couple of selective schools we looked at because the programs were a good fit, but she is not at all interested in a school like that. The reachiest school on her list is an in-state public. It’s all about the vibe for her, too – she wants artsy and techy and nerdy, LOL.

I think people have a feeling that if you can achieve an Ivy, then you have WON somehow. Never mind that the Ivies themselves are all different in fit and feel – so I’ve never understood students who apply to all of them.

Meanwhile, SCOIR is yelling at my kid that she’s missing her three “reach” schools because she’s only applying to six schools, most of which are target/likely, with one harder target/reach. (It’s also calling Georgia Tech a likely for her, so haaaa, SCOIR is stupid.)

2 Likes

Haha - mine wants them to stand for something. She really hates the idea of a very “generic” college. If she wants that, she’ll go to Rutgers or TCNJ! It’s basically, “Inspire me so that I want to pay more than my really good in-state options!” So far, that list of inspirational schools is pretty small.

LOL! We’re on Naviance and I can’t even tell if it’s asking for something. It’s D26s problem, and she’s quite happy to ignore whatever it says!

3 Likes

Yeah, when my D24 was applying to college senior year, she got a lot of funny looks from people who meant well but were just using their own limited frame of reference as a comparison.

The first 1 or 2 times my D24 encountered it, she became really self conscious about some of the places she was applying to and it got really old having adults ask her literally all the time about where she was applying to college.

I’d heard a tip elsewhere (can’t remember where I heard or read about this) and told D24 about it and it really worked well.

So here’s the tip/suggestion:
You and/or your kid needs to come up with an ‘elevator speech.’ A short couple of sentences saying something interesting about Favorite College, about College Where Kid Will Attend, or Any Other College On The List.

For example, D24 applied to the following schools:

  • ASU
  • U of A (Arizona, not Alabama)
  • Univ of New Mexico
  • NMSU
  • Centre College (in KY)
  • Southwestern University (30 min from Austin, TX)
  • Austin College (1 hr from Dallas, TX)

In the latter half of senior year, adults’ questions shifted from “where are you applying,” to “Where do you want to go?” After going on a couple of in-person visits to the 3 LACs, she changed her mind from “I’m going to U of A” to “It’s between Southwestern & Austin College + Centre College is a close 3rd.”

Hardly anybody we knew even knew these schools existed. So we’d get weird looks, you know where the person sort of squishes up their nose, and they’d say, “Oh…(long pause)…why would you want to go THERE?” One memorable adult royally put their foot in their mouth and actually said out loud, “Well, I’ve never heard of THOSE schools. They must not be very good.”

I was present for that one. At the time, D24 looked super mad, but kept her cool and was polite and stammered a bit trying to figure out what to say. So I spoke up and said this to set the Foolish Adult straight and politely put the person in their place:

“D24 really likes Austin College. They have a great pre-health program and right now, D24’s goal is to go to PA school down the road and they just started a PA graduate program this year. AND they have a really great track record of helping all of their students get research and internship experience as undergrads. It’s only an hour from the Dallas airport, so getting home won’t be a big deal. And she’s already received a big merit scholarship so the tuition, room & board is comparable to her attending an in state university. AND all of their classes are in person. Did you know that a lot of ASU and U of A classes now are hybrid or totally online?”

In that little brief moment, you end up redirecting the person’s attention. And then they’re curious about the college you’re talking about and ask for more info. AND they’re no longer asking how come your kid isn’t going to Harvard.

People would sometimes grimace when D24 would tell them that she’d applied to Univ of New Mexico. Some would even say, “Ew why would you want to apply THERE?”

They all shut up when I’d tell them that tuition, room & board was going to be cheaper than in state in AZ AND that it’s a pretty kick butt school if you want to be a film major since Netflix has a whole huge studio literally right next to campus AND the film majors often get film industry internships with Netflix as undergrads (D24 wasn’t going to be a film major but that’s beside the point).

I’ve already gotten lip from some adults about some of the places that D26 is applying. But since this is Kid #2 going through this, I’ve reached the point that I don’t give a rip anymore about what other people think of where my kid goes to college. It doesn’t matter that they think that my kid is applying to lousy/low-ranked colleges. Their opinions are none of my family’s business. They’re just uninformed.

MOST people have good intentions when they ask about this stuff. They just don’t realize how rude it sometimes can sound when they ask though. :slight_smile:

2 Likes

YES! I actually had a talk with D26 about this before last Thanksgiving when we knew this was likely to start. She had a whole speech prepared for it. She’s continued to use that speech with just small variations around additional schools she’s considering. But she’s been pretty adamant, so not many people want to go up against her! :slight_smile:

Ok, the craziest one that I got recently was when I was speaking with a colleague and we were talking about her student, who is at one of the northeast tech colleges. I mentioned that D26 was actually looking at a different one, and she immediately said, “Oh, we looked there but the kids looked SO DEPRESSED because there’s nothing to do there but study.” Lol, thanks, I wasn’t asking for your opinion!

3 Likes

D26 hasn’t gotten too many rude college questions yet. I’ll tell her to prepare, lol.

I have no patience for that sort of thing. Off topic, but I have twins, so when they were little, you wouldn’t believe the number of people – acquaintances and strangers alike – who had no qualms about asking, “So were they natural, or did you do IVF or something?”

I eventually started retorting, “Are you seriously asking me whether I had sex to get pregnant?” Then people turned red and started stammering, but I couldn’t bring myself to feel bad about it. Don’t ask nosy personal questions!

That hasn’t happened in a decade, LOL – but can you tell I’m still deeply annoyed? :sweat_smile:

More on a funny level, my twins are boy-girl, and so many people asked if they were identical. I kind of understand because if you don’t have twins, the science of it isn’t necessarily at the forefront of your mind. But I did start answering, “Almost, but one has a penis.”

Usually this elicited laughter along with embarrassment. :joy:

Okay, sorry, sorry – back to our regularly scheduled college conversation!

11 Likes

We have twin boys too and we used to get the IVF question all the time. My answer was always, “No, I’m just that good!”

7 Likes

Senior photos are scheduled. It’s a bit more $$ than I expected even with a family discount. Traveling to the Boston area from Maine for a weekend to complete them. She’s an AMAZING photographer and I’m so happy we were able to get booked. She’s the wife of my husbands cousin and normally does weddings and commercial photography and is generally booked solid so we are so grateful!

My daughter has the common app like 90% done, just needs to sit with her counselor to complete a bit more, then hang out the supplemental essay for Smith before she can submit! :smiling_face::smiling_face:. I’ll be so happy when she’s DONE.

7 Likes

It’s very interesting when you have a mixed marriage (Im Asian, my wife is white).

Once, when our 2 daughters were young and my wife took them out, someone said to her: “Wow, your kids are so cute, were did you get them from?”

My wife said, “Target. They were buy one get one free so I picked up 2”.

15 Likes