Please chance my potential engineer for these schools, and suggest some more! [rising junior, MD resident, 4.0 UW, 35 ACT]

Thank you, thank you everyone. This is super helpful!!!

Here are some answers to your questions.

I agree. I hadn’t thought about Minnesota until my other thread about him, but once we started looking, it stood out as one he’d probably love.

I think WPI and RIT both seem like they’d be such a good fit for him. He really loves the hands on approach, would love to coop, and loves both the emphasis on global service at WPI and the strong arts at RIT. Neither of them comes in as affordable on the NPC, but there’s the possibility of merit at both, plus money from cooping could help. I’m less sold on RPI for him. I hear the curriculum is more traditional and research focused. If he got the RPI medal, that could change our mind though. If there are things that make RPI a really good fit that I’m missing, let me know!

I will check it out. That location would be very tempting.

These have come up several times. I’m curious what makes people think they are a match.

NPC’s for Lehigh, Lafayette, and Villanova are all unaffordable, although all have big merit scholarships that could change that. Lehigh and Lafayette are definitely not urban though, and I think the culture at Villanova is too conservative for him, based on the experiences of kids we know there.

To be clear, this is “schools to look at” list. He’s not applying to this many schools!

Can you tell me which ones?

He struggles with perfectionism, the 35 is driving him a little nuts. I have learned to just let him take the lead on things.

I think it’s too rural. I agree the skiing is a draw there, but I’m not sure it would be enough to overcome the location.

We haven’t really looked at the Colorado schools. Those, and UVM are on there because of the access to skiing.

I’m a little hesitant to visit WPI, because I think it would be a great fit, but will probably be unaffordable. I sort of feel as though he should apply, and if it’s affordable we can visit and he can fall in love.

I hear from many people that UMD admissions are super unpredictable, and that it’s not a safety for anyone. At the same time, I feel like if they aren’t taking instate kids with 4.0’s, tons of rigor and relevant EC’s then that’s messed up. I don’t feel like he’s “entitled” to a spot anywhere else, but I will be pretty salty if he ends up without an in state option, and MD does not have another public option with the breadth of engineering options he wants.

I agree with you that he should pick what he wants, not based on prestige. He is an incredibly hard worker, so in that sense I think MIT is a great fit, but we’ll cross that bridge (UMD vs. MIT) if we come to it.

UMD doesn’t have ED, but they only give merit aid in the EA round, and their RD acceptance rate is very low, so he will 100% apply EA there.

3 Likes

There are a number of colleges that meet full need. Cal Tech is most definitely a “fit” school, and in reading what this kid wants in a college, I’m not sure CalTech is a good option.

@aunt_bea can you please discuss Cal Tech so this poster understands why it differs from many other highly competitive colleges?

1 Like

WPI considers demonstrated interest, so if you visit and he is clear with his interest and communicates that, it could be to your benefit. Remember, these schools what students who want them (and vice versa). Their yield has been low, so demonstrating interest will be, IMO a big plus and they could entice him with merit $.

5 Likes

I think Caltech would be worth looking at. I also think Stanford and Mudd would be options to look at. I think the only ways he would end up in California would be either if his brother ends up on the West Coast, or if he didn’t have a comparable option closer to home. But either of those things could very well happen. Or he could just mature.

1 Like

I’d love thoughts on the chancing, and on how many schools to look for in each category.

Someone on my other thread commented that UMN is a reach, for example. Is that true?

I see zero problem with applying only to WPI and RIT, and not RPI, for the reasons stated. Focusing on better fits is a good thing.

Speaking of which, I also think visiting WPI might be worth it despite the risk of it not being affordable, because of the demonstrated interest issue but also just to further refine his preferences. Of course that takes some maturity to be OK with cutting it in the event of an insufficient aid offer, but at least some kids end up pretty good about that as long as they have other strong offers to consider.

Brown is an interesting school on that list for Engineering.

1 Like

So, I just asked Chat GPT about the differences between Caltech and MIT, and it gave me this:

”While both Caltech and MIT are world-class STEM institutions, they differ significantly in size, academic scope, and culture. Caltech is a tiny, close-knit "pure science" research community. MIT is a sprawling academic behemoth with a broader focus on applied sciences, engineering, architecture, and business. :

and also this:

  • Caltech: Follows a theoretical and research-driven approach. Students engage in hands-on research early on and have strong ties to NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL). [1, 2]
  • MIT: Follows a mens et manus (mind and hand) philosophy. It is heavily geared toward applied science, building things, entrepreneurship, and innovation. [1, 2]

I don’t know how accurate that is, but if it is, then the bolded parts, which describe MIT, are a much better fit for my kid than the italicized parts describing Caltech.

If anyone has thoughts on the rest of my list and which school they’re more like, I’d love to hear it, because that was actually really helpful.

Also, if AI is wrong, I’d love to hear that too!

It is, but for a kid who loves the visual arts, and being in a community with artists, the connection to RISD is a huge draw.

ChatGPT is an okay place to start but subject to error. I would spend time on the actual college websites looking up educational philosophy and also vision, mission, and value statements. Which institutions would be the best matches? Caltech’s core curriculum is different from MIT’s core curriculum. Even grading policies vary from school to school. Look at all the different majors offered. Does the school offer the major(s) he’s interested in? What if he changes my mind sophomore, junior year, or even during orientation - is it easy or hard to make a switch? Does the school offer the possible alternative in case he does switch? Your mention that your son’s “struggle with perfectionism” can drive him “a little nuts.” How would he handle failure in one of these environments (looking through the crystal ball) - would failure mean scoring a 97 instead of 100, a “B+” grade, a “D” or “F” on an assignment or quiz, or needing to repeat coursework? How would he react & what possible actions would he take? These failures are most likely completely unacceptable in his current high school environment or anything preceding (looking at the past & present) and may seem unfathomably impossible any future environment.

There is also campus life - the dorms & other types or living groups - are there any suitable fits at these schools - remember, your son will be living here for four years, (about age 18-22). Does he visually himself being happy and successful here? Where would he build the strongest relationships, not just with fellow students but also instructors, professors, and other staff? Which school would lead to the highest level of accomplishment?

Does anyone have thoughts on Carnegie Mellon for him? I didn’t put it on the list, because I don’t know that it would offer enough aid, but it seems to hit a lot of what he’s looking for.

Did you run the net price calculator for CMU? Is it affordable, maybe?

2 Likes

“Affordable, maybe” is about right. It’s in that gray zone where maybe we could work things out, but not in the budget he wants. As opposed to UMD or the no loan schools that are definitely affordable.

Someone told me on another thread, that if you get an offer from a school with really good aid, the example there was Princeton, sometimes another school will match that aid. Does anyone know if that’s just for athletes or do schools do that for other situations? Also, is there any chance that a school like CMU would do that? Or is it just Ivies?

Schools do that for other situations. It’s not just the Ivies, but I don’t know about CMU.

I realize this is a long shot plan, because he’d have to get into CMU and another lottery school.

1 Like

Our son attended Caltech.

It is definitely a fit school.

It is a research institution.
Most entering students have already specified an area of research.

You have to be self-driven and VERY independent. A math problem can take 8 hours to decipher and these students like the challenge.

Your student will be at full speed all 4 years. As @DadTwoGirls has described it, “it’s like drinking water from a fire hose”.

Most students are full pay. Many students use Uber eats so that they don’t have to stop working on their research and coursework.

Merit is limited (because every accepted student would qualify for funding), but low income students and international students may be funded.

Everyone is a National Science winner and National Merit Winner (including our son).

They take 200+ kids each fall, worldwide.
It’s a research institution and it’s not a typical college experience.

Husband attended Stanford. Are your sons legacies or national/international award winners? Stanford is physically large but admitted classes are smaller than expected.

Don’t forget that flights and daily living budgets are expensive in California.

3 Likes

Is CMU really a lottery school for this profile? I believe the acceptance rate early decision for the Class of 2029 at CMU was a little over 20%. Lottery schools acceptance rates are in the single digits. For instance, a few of the tippy top schools for engineering that happen to be public and don’t do early decsions are more of a lottery OOS as they are in single digits. I think CMU early decision is well in the wheel house for this profile.

1 Like

ABET accredited engineering typically takes more than 12 quarters (4 academic years) at Dartmouth.

Dartmouth has a very high fraternity and sorority participation that potential students should be aware of.

3 Likes

My big concern with CMU is the flexibility piece. If he gets into engineering and decides he wants to explore computer science/robotics, it’s not an easy change.

And, my D felt like CMU was another that was very much a fit school. There was a different level of intensity and competitiveness there from many of the other schools on the list.

Personally I already think the list is too long and you don’t need to be adding more reaches.

I’m traveling currently so haven’t read all the replies but I’d think too on your student’s psyche and how they would feel doing all the application work and possibly having a lot of rejections or end up with unaffordable options.

Talked to someone last night with a child with crazy high stats who applied to more than 15 schools and had only a couple of acceptances and then was wait listed almost everywhere else. It was very hard and discouraging. Sibling who was less academic and applied to more targets, had a much easier and better outcome with almost all acceptances.

6 Likes