Please chance my potential engineer for these schools, and suggest some more! [rising junior, MD resident, 4.0 UW, 35 ACT]

Self driven, independent, and 8 hours on a single problem sound like him. But he’d definitely want the problem to be something concrete with a real life application. An engineering or robotics problem, rather than an abstract math or physics problem.

He does not have legacy at any school that would be a fit.

The key is that if a school considers ‘matching’ a financial aid offer, it generally has to be from what the school considers a peer school.

We are also only talking about need based aid in the case of CMU because they only offer need based aid (outside of a very few merit awards in school of drama and music.) So, for example, CMU considers Rice a peer school, but if a student were accepted to Rice and received merit aid, CMU wouldn’t match the merit aid piece.

Here is the list of CMU peers as determined by CMU. I don’t know have any insider knowledge if they would really match FA offers from some of the highly generous schools on this list:

I agree with everything momofboiler said about CMU…it is a fit school, like CalTech. Definitely visit…he should know quickly if it’s a fit. Here is some info about changing engineering majors…it is not easy nor guaranteed:

4 Likes

Yes, the ED acceptance rate may be higher, but it’s very much a fit school IMO, so this student should be absolutely sure they’ll like it there.

Some students I know simply haven’t enjoyed their experience there, so OP’s son needs to do his own research.

6 Likes

Actually, Caltech doesn’t offer merit aid at all.

5 Likes

I am interested in that list, because when I tried to guess which schools CMU would think of as peers, JHU is the first one that came to mind but it’s not on the list. Am I wrong that there are similarities? JHU is one school he’s already seen and likes.

1 Like

I just want to be clear this is absolutely not a list of all the schools he plans to apply to. It’s a list of schools he plans to investigate further. Other than UMD, there aren’t any schools he knows for sure he will apply to.

His brother’s school suggests that kids apply to 8-10 schools. His sister applied to 7. I am thinking his list will be somewhere around there. I am hoping to get feedback on Safety/Likely/Target/Reach to help him figure out which categories he needs to find more schools in, and which categories he needs to pare down.

I think he will do fine with rejection. He is a kid who likes to chase a goal. His reaction to the 35 ACT wasn’t disappointment, it was more like “Ooooh the gauntlet has been thrown down! Challenge accepted!”

1 Like

Brown ED was 17% last year, Cornell 19%, Dartmouth stopped saying, but was 19% last they said…not different than CMU… is CMU engineering easier than MIT or Stanford? Probably, but not easy at ALL and as hard as pretty much anything out there IMO.

I had a CMU AO tell a small group their CS admit rate was low single digits in recent years – CS admits by school, engineering by major (I don’t have major by major breakdown at CMU though).. so the 20% for CMU is overall…. their theater and CS are super duper low, engineering low and others higher..

All that said, I think applicant has a good profile!

4 Likes

I didn’t realize that robotics is in CS and not engineering. Is CS or robotics at CMU like BME at JHU, or CS at UMD where transferring in is impossible but transferring out is doable, or is it hard both ways? Things could change but right now the latter would be a reason to cross it off the list.

Yes, Robotics is in the School of Computer Science, not Engineering, at CMU. When we toured, we were told transferring in would be very very difficult/impossible. Transferring out, a bit less so, but certain engineer majors may still be closed out, like EE and ECE. I’d have your child reach out to both schools and ask the question directly.

4 Likes

Recently toured and heard same…but seemed to take away that minoring is possible and there were a fair number of secondary majors (surprisingly?) which I didn’t entirely understand…

FWIW @Twoin28 it was a bit of a downside to CMU for us… my kiddo has similar interests and decided they would likely (if applied) would apply mech-e (most flexible major it seems long-term and easiest to get in) and likely minor in robotics or just take some robotics classes - they are more into the engineering side of it anyway..(that seemed doable at first pass - but would dig more before EDing). It does seem hard to go from mech-e to CS or ECE or (i assume) robotics which is the newest major.

Just FYI I have a kid at RIT - getting co-ops for most kids is like a PT job on top of classes. not saying it is not necessarily worth it in end (I can’t say yet from personal experience as my kid is only going into second year), but it is a LOT and REALLY required - like in some departments you can’t sign for classes until your first co-op is completed on time even if you haven’t found one..it is intense - more so than I ever imagined. And plenty of schools let you get co-ops (including WPI and Case Western, but they don’t really advertise as co-op schools so much). The coop search is nonstop on parents list and a source of huge frustration right now, some students don’t graduate on time.

Also, switching majors depends on the major and department - it is pretty siloed - some require applications and essays - some it is easy, some have GPA requirements, etc. If your grades are good, I think it is generally it is ok, if your grades are NOT, then it can be impossible. There is an “us vs them” attitude in some majors, though, among at least some admin.

3 Likes

I agree with the school’s suggestion; most students don’t need to apply to 10 schools. What if your son were to apply to 28 schools and only get into 2?; what a waste of time & money that would be! You didn’t disclose the breakdown of his 35 ACT score. Retaking the ACT or attempting the SAT would be a complete waste of time (and money!) in your son’s case.

Edited by moderator to comply with forum rules

I hope you’re being sarcastic. Not a waste of time & money at all because if he eliminated schools to apply to, the 2 he got into might have been among those eliminated.

I second this comment 100%. Co-OP’s and internships are becoming increasingly hard to get. The best school for this is RPI because they have a full semester required course in sophomore year in which they not only teach you how to get a placement but in which the work of the course is actually getting one! Every school should be doing this.

1 Like

Of course, I am being sarcastic! I would love for every student to get admitted to the college of their dreams! It’s quite difficult to optimize the college application process.

1 Like

Teenagers waste time and money sometimes. One of my other kids loves expensive basketball shoes and saves all their money from their job to buy the latest. Another wastes a fair amount of time on video games. I waste a lot of time watching cooking shows for foods I will never cook. If he wants to waste some time and money taking a test, I can live with that.

1 Like

Then by all means go for it! Consider score choice, if that option is still available, & send score reports to colleges after reviewing the results, even if it costs more, if he ends up doing better.

Unrelated to everything else, this made me laugh so hard. This is 100% me too. Thank you! I am having a piss poor day at work, and I really really needed this random giggle.

4 Likes

Given your budget, I don’t think Caltech would work for your student.
Yes, it’s a beautiful campus and in a great area of LA County, but it would be unaffordable.

2 Likes

So, back to my original question of chances, can people comment on this list and see if I’ve classified schools correctly? I put in parentheses what I think will be the harder part for each school F if the issue will likely be finances, A if the issue will likely be Admissions.

I have italicized the schools I think I like best for him in each category. Obviously, I’m not the one who will actually be deciding where he will apply and although we’ve talked I don’t know exactly which schools would make his top 10 list.

Safeties

VCU (if he gets NMSF)
University of New Mexico

Likelies

University of Maryland (A)
University of Minnesota (A)
Pitt (F)
Temple (F)
University at Buffalo (F)
Drexel (F)
University of Vermont (F)

Target

WPI (F)
RIT (F)
University of Colorado at Boulder (F)
Colorado School of Mines (F)
GWU (F)

Reach

Cooper Union (A)
Johns Hopkins (A)
MIT (A)
Harvey Mudd (F/A)
Northeastern (F/A)
NYU (F/A)
Tufts (F/A)
Brown (A)
Carnegie Mellon (A)
Columbia (A)
Princeton (A)

1 Like