Please chance my potential engineer for these schools, and suggest some more! [rising junior, MD resident, 4.0 UW, 35 ACT]

Actually, Caltech’s NPC comes back as affordable, but it doesn’t sound like a fit in other ways.

3 Likes

This student is a rising junior. In my opinion, I would give this a little rest. His point of view and priorities for colleges could change vastly in his HS junior year. He might decide to look at smaller LAC types of schools. He might want to venture further from home. He might ditch engineering entirely (you can PM me for details why I KNOW this can happen).

As an example, we visited SMU with my older child. The younger one LOVED it and for several years said we didn’t have to go on any college tours because she was applying to SMU. Well…during her junior year, we suggested a visit to SMU with the eye of possibly applying. Her response “I’m NOT going to college in Texas.” So that was the end of that.

Students pivot all of the time.

The key for your son is to keep doing well as this will open up doors for him. In addition, he should prep for the PSAT which he will take this fall. Getting a top score on that could open the door for NM status and some colleges which do recognize this for significant merit aid.

Good that you are thinking about this now…but he’s a rising junior, and also might be interested in playing his sport in college…

3 Likes

RIT has this too, for all majors to my knowledge. can’t speak to quality but it is about getting a job etc.

2 Likes

Thanks. Good to know. :+1:

1 Like

One thing RIT is amazing at is they have a full curriculum and outcomes for each major on their website …and what Co-ops are required (this varies a lot by major - length, number and type), some allow research to count, some allow paid international internship to count, etc etc). Also have average pay for co-ops by major - it really has a WEALTH of info by major for which they are unusual..

eg. for a random (unusual) major co-op info: (not my kids major but intentional picked an unusual one)

​ Co-op and Experiential Learning Options for Computer Engineering Technology BS | Degree Programs Coop | Career Services and Co-op | RIT

The pre-coop required class is called

EEET-299 EET Career Orientation
1 Like

I think you have this mostly categorized properly although I’d put MN into the target category since you are OOS, and I think Mines is a likely.

Do you think Mines is a likely for financial aid? I put it there because I think he’s likely to get in, but it’s less likely to be affordable.

We know a number of Mines students who were academically strong, and got very good merit aid from Mines. Of course, this does not mean the same outcome now. But, they LOVED the school too.

2 Likes

This really isn’t an apples to apples comparison though. Each of the Ivy League ED admits includes about 200 athletic recruits. Yes, Carnegie Mellon does have athletic recruits, but I’m pretty sure their ED numbers do not contain a similar number of athlete slots as the Ivy schools.

Mines relentlessly pursued my daughter and kept increasing their merit offers. It’s been 8 years though but from what I’ve heard, they are still heavily trying to entice students to come.

3 Likes

So I know CMU better than most institutions (although not quite as well as a few), and I am in a mood to be blunt, so . . .

I don’t find myself recommending CMU much for undergrad, aside from maybe for Arts stuff, or MAYBE Tech + Arts stuff.

Again, just to be blunt, I don’t like how they stovepipe their undergrad programs so much, and I also think they have this habit of doing almost everything in a very CMU sort of way. So, like, my S24 briefly looked at them for Bio, and actually took a Bio course there during a summer, and it is very much a CMU sort of Bio they offer. All this could be perfectly fine for grad school, assuming they had whatever faculty and research focus you were looking for, but I don’t like it for most undergrads, unless perhaps you are dead sure you know exactly what you want to do (and how can a HS kid really be that sure?).

And again being blunt, I think the grind culture thing does in fact show up. I actually think these are related issues, the stovepiping and the grind culture, but I also think this is one of those things that feeds on itself, like typically CMU kids actually see grind culture as being a good fit for them, or at least not a bad fit, so it reinforces that being the culture. Again, I think for some kids that may well be a great fit, but I generally wouldn’t encourage that sort of college experience unless you really knew it was what you wanted.

3 Likes

Also, I believe that Mines allows stacking of scholarships (although double check that).

1 Like

Thank you, that’s helpful! He already has a long list of reaches he wants to investigate where the aid is likely to be better, and the location is likely to be a better fit. It sounds like CMU won’t rise to the top.

1 Like

Mines sounds like a really special place.

I really appreciate the feedback on Caltech and CMU because you probably saved me a trip. Are there other schools you want to talk me out of for this particular kid?

I believe some of us might be wondering about why George Washington. I can sort of see the appeal on some dimensions, but it is also a demonstrated interest school, so I would wonder if it was really worth it.

I feel like he and I need to understand what’s out there, to make a plan for what schools to see. We are very busy, and weekends fill up fast!

He also needs to make a decision about recruiting. There are schools on the list above where assistance from a coach could make a big difference. But are they the schools he wants? Without looking at both the schools expressing interest, and the schools where he probably couldn’t play, he can’t figure that out.

And yes, he could change his mind. I know that. But we have to decide what schools to go see somehow and going off what he says he wants seems logical to me.

1 Like

Would you put MN in the target category admissions wise, or financially? They ask for academic stats and include merit in the NPC, and it comes back as affordable.

GWU hits three things that are priorities for him – urban, close to home, and very liberal area. I’m not sure it’s a fit academically though. I don’t know much about it.

Admission wise, but I’m conservative when making those assessments.