Cornell has 1000+ athletes on 31 teams, meaning about 250 in the freshman class.
CMU HAS 600+ athletes on 19 teams, meaning about 150 in the freshman class.
BUT . . . Cornell has an undergrad enrollment of 16,000+, meaning 4000 freshman.
CMU has an undergrad enrollment of less than 8000, meaning 2000.
So, yes, CMU has fewer athletes ED than Cornell, but in proportion to the size of that freshman class, the athletes are potentially a higher percent.
One other source of hooks for CMU is their drama & performing arts programs. Their programs in these fields are big time, really big time. They may have students in these areas whom they are admitting ED who are a non factor at Cornell.
The bottom line is that we really don’t know. But what we do know is that ED numbers are inflated to some degree and so we really can’t compare them 1:1 with RD and assume that there is an advantage applying ED.
That would be New Mexico Tech (New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology).
Small school in a small town (8500 people) about 45 minutes south of Albuquerque. Liberal. Outdoorsy (like Mines in Colorado), but drier mountains.
Tech punches way above its weight class w/r/t grad school placement. According to the NSF, NMTech was #1 for the percentage of BS grads who later complete a PhD. Tech grads go to to some of the highest ranked grad programs in their fields. And Tech is the only college or university in the US to offer a bachelor’s degree in explosive science.
UNM is in a major city, Albuquerque. International airport is 15-20 from campus. Nearby mountains for recreation. Also the Rio Grande run literally through the middle of the city. Liberal city in a blue state.
UNM offers automatic merit to OOS students based on GPA/ACT or SAT that will give instate rates so COA will run about $25K/year. There is also a competitive full ride (tuition, fees, housing and meals) Regents’ Scholarship that comes with lots of special perks.
Great internship opportunities at both New Mexico National Laboratories, plus White Sands and Cannon and Kirtland AF Bases.
UNM sounds really wonderful. Other than distance it seems like a perfect fit. Would you say it’s a true safety? It would be great to have another one of those!
Tech also sounds wonderful, but probably not for my city lover.
I would say CMU is behind MIT, Stanford, Georgia Tech 7.2% (OOS), UC Berkeley (OOS) for competitive admissions for Engineering, but yes still extremely competitive. I just think with this profile since CMU has ED, chances are better than “lottery”.
The University of New Mexico advertises that they get admissions decisions out quickly. So if your kid applies early in the season, he could probably have an acceptance in August or September. There are no essays or recommendations required.
The University of Minnesota at Twin Cities accepts 84% of OOS applicants. I think it is very likely that your child will be accepted. They also send out admissions decisions early in the fall.
It is certainly those things! It is also a good all around school, so not crazy, but it isn’t particularly known for engineering. It does have it, and in fact there are some cool specific programs. But usually if I was making suggestions for a kid looking for the sorts of engineering experiences you have been describing, it wouldn’t leap to mind.
ETA: Just since we are also discussing it, Minnesota to me is a WAAAAY more obvious choice for an engineering kid. And it is also located in a liberal city in a liberal state. It is farther from home, but the airport is close and has lots of direct flights. Just an example of what I would consider a more obvious suggestion.
I am not sure about GA Tech being actually harder based on the kids I know who got in, but I agree CMU is easier than the others you noted OOS. (And I said MIT/Stanford were harder in my original post). The GA Tech kids are NOT in the same world as the MIT kids here…. And I just looked up by state, and admissions for the random new england states I looked up were all 15%ish..with average SAT about 1500ish..not Berkeley range.
Then again, in my area, maybe some geographic advantages/kids have higher than average rigor for GA Tech… also, GA is HUGE HUGE in comparison to CMU and Stanford etc, so also have to fill classes… it is more metric-driven I think, and less holistic.
I note my S24’s feederish HS used the College Kickstart framework, and they have a category called Likelies which I find extremely helpful in cases like this:
Likely: the admit rate is over 50% and your academic profile puts you in the top quartile of students from the previous year. These are schools where you have a high probability of gaining admission and merit aid, and it’s ideal to have at least two in your list.
With Minnesota having checked out for merit aid in their NPC, I would say for this applicant Minnesota nails this Likely definition.
Some people then also want to have a true “Safety” in mind. But as you mention, Minnesota has a form of rolling admissions. So, if the OP’s son got an early offer from Minnesota, as I also believe is in fact very likely, then that could become his Safety.
My understanding is the UMN admits by college, and the college of science and engineering is much more competitive than the overall acceptance rate suggests.
University of New Mexico is an absolute safety for your kid. I know an out-of-state kid with way, way lower stats than your kid who got in as an engineering major and got good merit too. The total COA was ~$25K. This kid actually switched out of engineering after 1 semester because it was too hard, but this would not be a problem for you student. Incidentally, my D has a friend who is trans (a transman who sounds a bit like your other son, gender conforming, active, outdoorsy) who found UNM to be welcoming. Had no trouble making friends or dating.
That’s right, and so it would also be reasonable to categorize it as a type of Target for the OP’s son.
On some level this sort of stops mattering once you decide to actually apply. Assuming the OP’s son ended up sufficiently excited about Minnesota, then an early application would be a good idea. And then the OP’s son would likely get an actual answer soon enough to inform the rest of their application plan.
Here is a breakdown of the academic profile of fall admitted freshman applicants by college.
They list the middle 50 percentile of fall 2025 admitted freshmen.
For the College of Science and Engineering, the unweighted high school GPA is 3.62-4.00, and the SAT composite, with about half of students submitting, is 1380-1510.
It actually is harder. This cycle for GT. They received 27, 921 OOS applications for Engineering and admitted only 2,028 for an acceptance rate of 7.2%. For OOS and international all majors combined…54,555 applied and 4,871 were accepted for an acceptance rate of 8.9%.
BTW I am only responding because you made this statement “GT kids are not in the same world as MIT kids” is just an absurd statement. My kid knows students at GT who passed on MIT for GT. Some of it financial but some also wanted a Top 3 engineering school but still being able enjoy a more normal college experience with BCS Football and ACC Basketball etc and school spirit. Georgia Tech provides both.
Lastly you bring up Berkeley score range. Are you aware that Berkeley is test blind and before that high test optional? GT is test required and has been for years.
I think we need to see how he feels about going far from home in a year. I know his sister matured a lot between summer before junior year and summer before senior year. He could do the same and be fine with being far away by the time it’s time to apply. Hopefully he gets into UMD, which I think he would choose over both UMN and GWU.