Please chance my potential engineer for these schools, and suggest some more! [rising junior, MD resident, 4.0 UW, 35 ACT]

Didn’t read the entire thread, but this student definitely needs to put RPI on his list. RPI is likely to award him merit money that will bring cost of attendance close to that of student’s in-state flagship, plus I have heard that there are hands on club opportunities available right away (such as the car clubs), whereas at some other schools these are only available to upper classmen. In terms of reputation and selectivity, RPI is only a step below the top engineering schools.

In my opinion, the only draw back of RPI is the same as that at any all-engineering school - that the students are all engineers, which means a higher percentage of males attending, and also can affect social life. As a couple of young women I knew who attended RPI said, when I remarked that the male to female imbalance meant good dating odds for women, “The odds are good… but the goods are odd.” But as I said, that’s likely at any school that is all engineering.

1 Like

So I know about kids who have been happy with each, but those are pretty different colleges. Obviously Cooper Union is way smaller with a lot more focus. NYU is then way bigger generally than Columbia, but I believe actually smaller in engineering.

I’d personally sort of put NYU in the GWU category–I can see why it checks certain boxes, but isn’t normally a school I would recommend for engineering. That said, if you are visiting NYC for colleges and can visit all three, why not?

Yeah, as I recall Maryland is one of the EA colleges that notifies at the end of January, which is a bit of a bummer as that is past many RD deadlines.

But still, we are spending a lot of time discussing options that might immediately be mooted if he is accepted at Maryland. Which is fine, but hopefully Maryland works out!

2 Likes

Columbia Engineering is definitely a “reach” option. I would recommend you and your son visiting the campus or arranging for a virtual visit prior to applying to make sure it’s a good fit for him.

Yes, unfortunately, he’ll need to decide where to apply before he knows about UMD. On that list, there are only a handful of schools that I think might have a shot at beating UMD.

2 Likes

I have heard that Columbia engineering is on the traditional theoretical end of the spectrum. If that’s true, then I don’t think it’s a fit. Which is too bad, because he loves NYC. Do other people have that impression?

It could be. I know a bit more about Cornell engineering, just for comparison, that for most disciplines, it tends to be more rigorous and reputable; I only know this from WOM; I wouldn’t be able to provide any supporting evidence to substantiate it. I was thinking more of environmental fit; he loves NYC but would he be able to handle being & living in Morningside Heights while pursuing engineering at Columbia. There is also Columbia’s Core Curriculum, required by both Columbia College & Columbia Engineering for all undergraduates and whether this would appeal to him.

1 Like

Thinking about Columbia, makes me think about something that I have been struggling with a little. My kids’ Dad believes that rank/selectivity/prestige matters a lot in college selection. He would, for example, think that even if WPI has the educational approach he wants, if he gets into Columbia he should go there because it’s Columbia. My guess is he will push for him to apply to a lot of reaches, and if he gets into one, will strongly encourage him to go, increasing his financial contribution if need be.

I don’t know what I think about that. I want to believe that rank doesn’t matter much, that it’s what you make of the school that counts. His sister didn’t want to apply to any reaches, got in anywhere and then picked a school that wasn’t the most selective or prestigious of her options, and I think that will turn out to be exactly the right choice.

But then I think about how academically disengaged this guy was in our highly rated local elementary and middle school, where he rushed through his work and still got A’s on everything, and how dramatically that changed when he got into the highly selective program where he goes now, with higher expectations, and lots of similar kids. I look at the test scores for some place like Temple, which checks so many of his boxes, but where his ACT score would be 5 points above the 75th %ile, and I wonder if he would find experiences there that engaged him.

I’d love to hear people’s thoughts on this.

What is WOM?

I don’t have any concerns about his ability to handle the city, or Morningside Heights in particular. I do have questions about the core curriculum, and whether it’s a fit for him.

Our family’s experience is for engineering specifically, hiring is very egalitarian. If anything, the engineers who went to the big flagships like UMD had better outcomes than those who went to Ivies.

8 Likes

I’d agree with this. With the possible exception of Cornell.

WOM= word of mouth

I guess I am wondering more about the experience in college rather than after college, although the latter is important too!

Now I feel silly! Of course that’s it! Thank you for being patient!

I think you will find that the engineering programs are really so rigorous and challenging at all the schools that it will feel like the experience you are describing from a rigorous HS. The ABET requirements means that they have similar (and similarly complex) things to accomplish. I think your child will be pushed at any of the engineering programs.

5 Likes

Kid’s dad sounds a bit like a doofus. Sorry. I tell my kid choosing a college is more like joining a track team. You can join a prestigious team of fast runners but they ain’t gonna make you run faster. Professors don’t have magic formulas for making you smarter. Actually profs at R1 schools are selected and rewarded for primarily for research, not teaching. I mean you gotta be satisfactory but papers and funding talk, bs walks.

Maybe take your kid skiing in Utah? His mind will be blown by the big mountains and deep powder. U of U is a very good school and super close to some of the best slopes in the country. He’ll have the best four years of his ski career.

Just rambling.

1 Like

You know, it’s interesting that you compare it to track, because this is my kid who avoids individual competition and loves team sports and team activities like robotics. I think one of the reasons he wants a project based approach is because he imagines it will include more opportunities to work in groups.

I don’t know how that translates into the question of selectivity and colleges, but in team sports the level of play and the skill of both your teammates and your opponents definitely changes the experience.

As MD resident with a child who graduated from one of the same technical magnet, here is our experience. Your problem is magnet. Why? Because 99% of his class will apply to the same schools. Most of the class will end up on waitlist at top schools. Each college will take 1 student and put the rest on WL. They cannot take the whole magnet. Your kid will end up competing against his classmates and not against general population.
Your kid is 99.9999% in UMD. Forget about CMU, UMICH, Ivy, NYU or California schools (I put it just in case.) That is list of every magnet kid. They all will be full price unless you qualify for FA. 0 merit aid unless there is miracle,and I do not believe in them.

If you are not interested in UMD, for merit aid look into smaller private schools not popular by magnet kids.

George Mason? VCU? Seriously? He doesn’t belong there.

4 Likes

I would drop VCU and UNM. Overkill.

Likely -cut in half. He is in for all of them. You do not need so many schools. Keep UMD.

Target - he is in for all of them, except I am not sure about merit or FA.

Reach - see my previous post.

1 Like

I was going to post something very similar.

Any ABET engineering program has a difficult and time-confusing undergrad curriculum. And in fact, quite a few kids try one and drop out. And in fact, some engineering colleges have a sort of sink or swim attitude–they will let kids give it a shot and expect a lot of them to drop out.

The ones who persist are then mostly very serious, and often pretty enthusiastic, students. I won’t claim there are never any smart slackers getting by, but mostly the survivors are the sorts of students any academic-minded parent would want their kids to be hanging around with.

Indeed, if anything, I think there is more a danger of undergrad engineering being a little TOO all-consuming. But most engineering colleges are well aware of this issue, and make sure there are all sorts of opportunities for their kids to do fun, social things too.

Long story short, I would personally say this is a non-concern for anywhere this kid would plausibly land. And that does mean I think a higher priority should be the nature of the undergrad engineering program, not the overall “prestige” of the undergrad institution.

1 Like

I really think your kid is going to get into UMD. Sure, apply to UMN or UNM as backups if that will give you psychological breathing room. But really it comes down to the question of is there anywhere your kid would rather go than UMD? Focus on UMD and those places. Anywhere else is unlikely to be where he ends up.

1 Like