I sent you a DM
I do lean towards fit over prestige, and I laughed out loud when my ex (who is a great Dad, and reading this thread, since he’s obviously invested in the question I posted) got called a doofus.
But, this isn’t about thinking that the kids at a less selective school are “less than” or somehow not worthy of my son’s association. He has plenty of hard working, academically motivated friends, teammates, and siblings. I certainly don’t think he’s better than they are, or that he doesn’t benefit from friendships and relationships with them.
I said it is my experience and I can see the data in 2 schools near me.
GT also posts admissions by state. Nobody near me is getting into MIT with 1500 SATs (you need very, very close to 1600), and 1500ish is average for states near me for GT enrolled…not close. The kids going to MIT are truly otherworldly.
E.g. CT Admissions: Admission Snapshot | Undergraduate Admission go by STATE - CT average SAT is 1500, MA 1517. That doesn’t meet MIT standards for those states.
It may be within certain areas it is same as the kids…but in my area. Level of ECs would be hugely different too.
@Twoin28 I hope you are having these discussions with your son. He is the one who will be eventually going to college.
We would find out about colleges, and send the info to our kids…they then decided what to do from there. One of our kids wanted to go to college across the country where we had no familiarity with the colleges. We got some great suggestions from this forum…but we simply passed them on to our kid. And she did attend one of the suggested colleges, one we had never heard of!
It’s not too soon to have your kid be involved in some college talk, but I would keep it very limited at this point. This early, we answered questions when our kids asked. And when we went on family road trips, if there were colleges along the way, we stopped and did at least a walk through. It gave our kids a sense of what was out there.
Of course I am!
That admissions by state is an average from each state from 2020 -2026. GT applications have increased more than two fold the last few years especially for out OOS applicants. I would also add that GT makes it a point that their admissions is not just about stat numbers as they are huge on the holistic review. They take the motto “Progress and Service” very seriously. It’s not just abut the scores for them. Are you a leader and how have you shown dedication to service to your community which are big factors they look at. You are assuming that all kids with close to 1600 OR 1600 are getting in GT. I know for a fact that’s not the case. Different schools different school missions.
I think the concern about theoretical vs. hands-on is a college sophomore year problem as a kid works with their advisor on research options, maps out their course selection, etc and not a pre-admissions problem. Civil engineers (probably the most hands-on of the disciplines) get to play with soil and water. But not until they have taken the same math and physics and chem as the more theoretical disciplines . I would not be evaluating programs with that lense. Not helpful IMHO.
Columbia is a fine place to study engineering if the core works for him. He should check out MIT’s HASS options….in my opinion, these types of breadth requirements are more relevant than hands-on vs theory. Engineering is both. Pretending it is not is a bit disingenuous on the part of the college.
I am not a huge co-op fan although it works great for some kids. But plain vanilla research projects and a summer job is great as well. Don’t believe the hype that without co-op experience your kid will be unemployable because it isn’t true.
I think the ease of switching majors is an important factor for an undecided kid. And if I had a dollar for every “I’m totally committed to BME “ who ended up majoring in math, or “I’ve wanted to study CS since I learned to program in 4th grade” who ended up in something else I could buy a nice dinner with wine.
Don’t discount the impact of a fantastic, charismatic, incredible professor on a students trajectory!!!
One thing I would emphasize is in my experiences talking to people who do next-step selections, they have pretty much all been well-aware how complicated this ends up being. So, they know outstanding HS students end up at all sorts of colleges for all sorts of reasons, including financial reasons, non-academic priorities, individualized academic preferences, and so on. And particularly when it comes to something like engineering, they are very happy to consider outstanding college students from a wide variety of programs.
And honestly, we’re not even talking about a very wide range here. Like there are something like 700 ABET undergrad programs in the US, and we’re still just talking about only the best-regarded programs on that list.
Of course if one of the most selective few engineering programs even among those highly-regarded engineering programs checks all the other boxes your son is looking for, and then admits him, and it is comfortably affordable, then great!
But as soon as you are talking about choosing a program that would either cost a lot more financially, or require serious compromises on other things he is looking for, I think that stops making a lot of sense. Because again, next-step gatekeepers know lots of great kids will choose the lower cost and/or better fit engineering program in such circumstances. And if such kids do well in those engineering programs, they will be very happy to consider them.
Engineering is one of those majors where it almost doesn’t matter where you go to undergrad, unless you’re aiming for a rarefied set of companies who simply don’t recruit at your school. And although ABET accreditation is important in general, it is actually NOT if you attend one of the few rarefied schools that everyone knows and recruits from: Caltech (for example) is not accredited in chemical engineering and their grads have no problems getting ChemE jobs.
I think that the number of schools in each category is really dependent on the individual applicant. Beyond external factors (like how much money the family wants to spend on application fees), the biggest thing is what the applicant’s mental makeup is like.
For some students rejection is a fuel that makes them want to be even more incredible wherever they land to prove their naysayers wrong. For people like that, a reach-heavy list can make sense.
For many people, however, rejection is an emotional hit. And although many might be able to handle a few hits, as the blows become more numerous and frequent it can cause people to seriously question their own value (and for highly rejective colleges, they tend to release in close succession near the end of the process). Additionally, some students begin to question the value of the acceptances they’ve already received with the thought that since they received so many rejections, the schools that actually accepted them can’t be that good, despite the fallacy in their thinking.
I find that most people do better if they get more acceptances than rejections, but it’s really individual-specific. As a visual aid (feel free to PM me feedback on it), I created the chart below. For most people, when totaling the “value” of the colleges on their final application list, I would suggest it result in a positive number. If one’s total is negative (especially if it’s very negative), then I would think long and hard about the applicant’s ability to handle that much negativity in a safe and healthy manner.
For a magnet student from MD, I would say 2 safety max! Mostly Targets and Reaches. (We considered only 3 categories: safety, Target, Reach.)
My magnet student applied to 10 colleges -0 Ivy and 0 CA schools. Safety was UMD. At the end student had 5 acceptances and 5 rejections. Student was very proud to be accepted into 2 absolutely unaffordable options (UMich and CMU).
In my S24’s feederish private HS, the baseline recommendation was 2 Likelies, 3-5 Targets, 3-5 Reaches.
However, if you were chasing discretionary merit, you might want more colleges that counted as Likely for admission, but you weren’t sure would come through with enough merit. Same deal with possibly more colleges that counted as Targets for admission with realistic but uncertain discretionary merit.
Then sometimes kids chasing merit would have no Reaches, because no Reaches they would like had attainable merit. But if they could find 3-5 Reaches with merit being at least possible, they could end up with more colleges in total, which is fine.
I hear a lot of people say that their kid would have better college outcomes from their comprehensive public than the magnet program, and I could see that being true for many kids. But my kid is so much happier and excited about school in the magnet that it will have been worth it.
I think that now that he knows what it’s like to have a peer group that engages him that way, he will be better able to seek that out in a more academically diverse environment, but I do wonder if there are some schools where it would be hard to find.
He loves UMD, and I think he would be happy there, so I hope you are right about his odds!
At many of the reaches the NPC’s are affordable for us.
Now…but isn’t this kid a rising junior? The NPCs are set for students starting college in 2027…and that is not your student.
College costs change and sometimes so do policies and formulas for computing need based aid. And your 2028-2029 financial aid forms will use 2026 tax year data and assets as of the day of your filings. So please use these as an estimate…maybe a decent one, but still…an estimate.
Because Maryland doesn’t notice EA applicants until end of January, it is possible he could end up on the high side for total applications if he has both Reaches and alternatives to Maryland out of caution.
But maybe not. It could depend on whether a college with early enough admissions rises high enough.
I know that they are estimates, and that both the formulas and our family’s financial situation could change. But I don’t really understand your point. I feel like you are saying that parents of juniors shouldn’t be looking at NPC’s, but even if they’re imperfect, for those kids who will need financial aid, NPC’s are the only tool we have to help us decide which schools to visit, and in his case, because he’s an athlete, which schools to target for recruiting.
In our case, it appears that the schools with the most generous need based aid (e.g. Princeton), will likely come in as more affordable than most OOS public options, and private options that give merit. Of course that could change, and of course that depends on him being accepted, which is very far from a sure thing, but it does make me feel like it’s worth looking at those schools.
The internet tells me that NPC’s won’t be fully accurate for the class of 2028 until Fall 2027. Do kids really wait that long to start visiting and making lists?
This is this kid. Not so much that he wants to prove people wrong, but that he likes challenges, even if he doesn’t succeed. He has been this way since he was a toddler.
My other kids aren’t like this.
No. But, if needed, parents might want yoset financial budgets to guide these students once acceptances start coming in. IOW, some parents do say that they can only contribute $XXX and if money to meet that price point isn’t forthcoming, those colleges will need to be dropped from consideration.
It’s not just your case. Princeton is probably THE most generous school WRT need based aid. It is also likely one of the most competitive for admissions…as you noted.
What I’m saying is…visit wherever you want to visit. It’s the time for the student to see if a college is appealing to them. And in your case, it’s possible the college will give a financial preread IF the student is a recruited as an athlete. Some colleges do this.
Some students actually don’t visit colleges until they get acceptances. They choose the top several accepted colleges to visit…and often the financial aid awards have been received so they know the colleges will be affordable for their families.
It sounds like you are in the position to visit colleges…so absolutely do so. Your student is fortunate that this is the case.
My two cents is if an NPC at this stage is not close, and merit is not realistic, then just strike it from the list. No point wasting the time falling in love with colleges like that.
If the NPC looks good and/or realistic merit would look good, then that is fine to keep investigating. However, if you are relying on the NPC, you will need to recheck before actually applying.
Whether pre-offer investigating includes visits is very personal. I actually personally love visiting colleges, and enjoyed the time with my S24. But he might have burned out a bit sometimes toward the end of trips, so in retrospect I should have probably pared things back for his sake.
