Princeton, Williams, Georgetown’s application numbers down- Loosing charm?

“It’s been a while since I looked at this, but back then it seemed to me that there’s likely an antitrust issue (Sherman Act).”

Shock of shockers- an anti-competitive practice like ED that locks in and reduces choice violating Sherman anti-trust!

I don’t get why some people don’t believe ED is designed solely to benefit the school, not the applicant. Simple math and economic theory tells you all options have value, both intrinsic and time values. ED takes away an applicant’s valuable option to make a college selection, based on any and all criteria (including financial ones) s/he may want to consider, at a later date (by May 1). Colleges use ED to increase yields and to reduce the overall cost of financial aid. To entice applicants to apply ED, they purposely make admissions easier for ED applicants. Is that a good trade-off? For some, the answer is clearly yes because they wouldn’t be admitted otherwise. But it’s no free lunch. There’s a cost to the schools, and the students. The schools would have to either lower their standards somewhat to accommodate these students, or take the risk that some of these students would struggle.

I’m not a fan of SCEA or REA either, because it also restricts an applicant’s option, making it less valuable. It at least doesn’t take away that option as ED does. Among the privates, currently only MIT and Caltech offer fully unrestricted EA (an applicant can even apply ED to another college at the same time), to go along with other meritocratic admission policies (no consideration for legacies and/or development cases, need-blind admission, meeting full needs without considering primary home equity, etc).

@ApplestoApples89, Of course schools engage in advertising. That’s nothing new. I remember receiving mounds of glossy mailings and offers for free applications back in the early 80’s. I was smart enough to know it didn’t mean anything other than that my SATs were good enough to get me on a mass-mailing list purchased by colleges.

You can slice it thinner than that. Applying for one of 8 spots for Latina non-athlete girls from the Pacific Northwest (a totally made-up stat) but what’s the point? No one is guaranteed admission.

I know you are disappointed by the outcome for this student to which you have an unnamed connection, but you have no way of knowing what the student’s application looked like beyond the stats. Maybe one of the recs. implied he was a grade grubber. Maybe he wrote a mediocre essay. Maybe the school had a spate of applications from kids who looked just like him on paper. Maybe he’s just not as impressive as you think.

ED is a great deal for kids who have a clear first choice and don’t need to compare offers. In my extended family there are 3 kids applying to college this year. One applied ED and got in (not my kid), one applied ED and was deferred, and one is only applying RD. None were recruits and all seem happy with the choices they’ve made to date.

@TheBigChef I agree with most of what you wrote. I didn’t call it a scam bc I’m not saying it’s illegal. I’m calling it a scheme bc it’s a planned-out way for them to build their stats by getting emotional buy-in from naive teenagers without really giving much in return. Well other than a handful of admission decisions and with that the obligation to attend that school without yet seeing what other options might be out there including financial aid. Really it’s just not a great deal. The problem is you have deferred kids that really love the school and still hope to get in, like the one I mentioned. It’s better to go through heartbreak once, in April, than twice, once in December and then again in April. And I say that only because deferral admissions rates are historically low.—Now I hope Duke will do the right thing and admit more deferred kids who have earned the opportunity but I guess we have to see.

@Nocreativity1 I didn’t read you post because I don’t see eye to eye with you on the subject. You lost me at “best of the best” and the Robertson discussion. Have a great rest of your day.

Well of course @Sue22 the student might be a really bad candidate but this one isn’t and certainly many of these legacy students who got deferred by top universities do not have bad applications, bad recommendations, bad essays. Most of them are probably great which is why they apply to Ivy League schools and it’s so easy to say that there’s no flaw here, no obvious problems and the issue is the darn kid isn’t good enough. But that’s just not the case a lot of the time. There’s subjectivity and arbitrariness in this process. Or, my favorite, “factors beyond their control.” I do wish they’d get rid of ED. It’s not a good system.

SCEA is also about yield protection and it does diminish an applicant’s chances of being admitted to other schools by forcing them to apply to other elite schools in the generally more selective RD round.

Apple- good thing I lost you because upon reflection I see part of your point of view but it’s not great news. Your unknown relationship kid now is in a tough spot because of ED. In the following regard ED is a total scheme as you put it.

She/He now has to hope to get into a competitive school dluring RD round without the benefit of legacy status. Wow that is a hardship. As he/she was deferred with the benefit of legacy status clearly the application didn’t stand out, so unlikely to fair well in the world of 5% acceptance rates when competing against all those other non legacy kids.

As for Duke, legacy kids typically get accepted off deferred at lower rates then non legacy deferred EDs as the initial decision was in essence a “soft” reject out of respect for the alum. Given that legacies get a second look in ED a third under normal circumstances won’t make a difference.

Taking you at your word that there was a stated or implied likelihood of acceptance I feel for you given the reality that the candidates chances are now so daunting for a top 20s. With most schools taking more kids ED and general applicant pool rising unhooked RD rates are sure to go down at most of the Duke peer schools. Hopefully some other AO will see what Duke apparently didn’t. In that regard ED and Duke failed him/her.

I am comforted that you say there was no sense of entitlement so that a lesser ranked school won’t be a disappointment. I hope the student has applied to safety school’s and gets into any and all schools they are deserving of. Given your arms length relationship but unfaltering support sounds like a great kid who will succeed anywhere.

And you have a great day as well. Please let us know how it turns out.

The conspiracy theories and resentment come from lack of transparency/hiding the numbers. For example, each Ivy league school has slotted recruited athletes that occupy ~190 SCEA/ED slots. This number is fairly similar year to year and by lumping all the numbers together makes it actually not trivial to compare EA/ED to RD rates. Also the Harvard Dean’s list of megadonors (revealed in lawsuit) also likely come in the SCEA round. If the schools were more transparent about specialty admits the public could be better informed. Dook does clearly say they give an advantage to ED applicants, so the question is do the actual numbers reflect that? Again, without knowing how many donor kids, athletes etc. are in the ED pool hard to know. From what I’ve heard unless a legacy’s parents are donating enough to be on the dean’s radar it’s not as big a hook as people think.

@1NJParent maybe the entire set up isn’t beneficial to students, but it certainly can be as it works- individually and not just to athletes/legacies/people who are full-pay. My D, who as previously stated was borderline for admission to her school, was accepted ED with full-need aid. That’s been calculated as a parental contribution of 3% of the COA. That’s about the dream right there, and she didn’t have to stress over Christmas break either. At this point, at meet-full-need schools (not even necessarily need blind- D’s wasn’t) even unhooked low income students can stand to gain from the process. It’s all turned into a chess match though, and I agree that it should all go back to RD, perhaps with the obvious exception of recruited athletes who are always going to get that jump anyway.

Excuse me @Nocreativity1 but that’s not what she said. I usually lurk but you are saying that Apples2Apples said that her kid was promised admission and she told you three different times that didn’t happen but that there is pressure on legacy applicants to apply ED. Those are 2 diff things, yo. I’m not looking to fight with you about this but I don’t think you should keep putting words in her mouth especially something like that.

Yeah at NCCU :smiley:

Katcenter- these are her words and you are correct.

“When an alum is told if your kid doesn’t go ED were going to hold that against them, and then they do but get deferred or rejected despite being HIGHLY qualified, it does look like a scheme designed to shore up ranking”.

I shouldn’t have said promised instead coerced would have been more accurate.

Apologies I hope that corrects my mistake.

But ur missing her point @Nocreativity1 isn’t that they are being told if they apply ed they get in but that they are told if they don’t apply ed they will have a harder time getting in regular cuz legacy should already know they want Duke, @Nocreativity1

ok cool- I’m out of this discussion.

Wow @Nocreativity1 , someone set up a brand new account just to respond to you! That’s special!

Actually, what I am certainly taking out of this discussion is that ED is more beneficial for the applicant at non-tippy top schools (where the legacy/donor/etc applicants take up so much space, as do athletes). Seems the next tier (maybe top 20-40 or so? …however you rank them, don’t want a rankings argument!) is better for ED for the normal, unhooked, hardworking student because they don’t have to compete with the same % of applicants who are legacies, kids of donors etc taking up their spaces.

My neighbor’s 2 kids went to the same (large) ivy (one kid is still a junior there). Neighbor said at a parent reception they were asked how many were alumni, and over half the room raised their hands. Now - that’s pretty daunting to non-legacy applicants. Some might even say it’s unfair.

Katcenter- I believe you are missing the point. Legacies that apply RD just don’t get the benefit of legacy status. If you apply ED as a legacy you do.

In other words you can’t have your cake and eat it to by leveraging legacy status without giving up some optionality. Apple’s friend took their “best” shot and failed. They were only coerced because they wanted their best shot. Everyone else in the world just has to apply based on their accomplishments (not those of parents) as a non legacy regardless of ED and RD. I think I got apples point, it’s unfair because my candidate didn’t get in and they are a legacy.

Welcome to CC and thanks for surrogating for Apple.

And for the record I have no problem with legacy carrying some influence. To hear people however whine about a benefit (that has nothing to do with the candidate) not superseding a holistic review is distasteful.

SJ2727 Cheers!!

MODERATOR’S NOTE:
Most of the users on this thread have been around long enough to know the rules. There is a negative ROI on my time cleaning up the snark, so I’m closing.